In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

The online face of grief

Last week, NPR’s Scott Simon’s mother passed away, and Scott tweeted from her hospital bed. It sounds awful, but it was weirdly touching. I’m writing in Salon about public grieving and how we use social media during tragedy. A bit:

Where’s the line between an Internet overshare and a compelling peek into human existence? NPR’s Scott Simon walked it this week as he live-tweeted from his mother’s deathbed. Just that description — “he live-tweeted from his mother’s deathbed” — makes it sound crass and attention-seeking. And yet Simon’s tweets were the opposite. They were largely well-crafted. They were alternately heartfelt, sad and funny, sometimes all at once. They captured the banality of a hospital death, the desire to cherish every moment and the simultaneous slow creep of time as a loved one lies dying. Mostly, they paint a portrait of his mother. She’s clever, she’s funny, she’s vulnerable. She loves her son. Her son feels compelled to tell the world about her.

“Do you want to tell me about her?” is one of the few things therapists and grief counselors recommend one say to a grieving friend. It’s a question that taps into the fact that the grieving person’s entire universe is consumed with the one they’ve lost. It allows them to explain whom it is they’re grieving for, to carve out the shape of a real person in a process that can otherwise be sterile and ritualized, the funeral and its quiet etiquette, the appropriate flowers or cards or donations in the deceased’s name.

We embrace tradition and convention in death because extended public displays of deep sadness in our culture are awkward for those witnessing them and therefore frowned upon, and also because when you’re engulfed in deep sadness there’s frankly not a lot of energy to get creative. “Let me tell you about her” allows the grieving person to explain, in the midst of a familiar ritual, why their loved one was particularly special. The impulse to explain how a person was can feel incredibly urgent in the immediate wake of that person’s death. The telling of stories isn’t just a way to make up for the fact that the dead person can no longer make their own stories; the telling solidifies those things in the memory of the teller, making real again and again the fact that though the person is gone, you’ll remember them.

There’s a fear behind that, too: What happens when I start to forget?

The full piece is here.


2 thoughts on The online face of grief

  1. I’m glad you wrote about this, Jill.

    This subject is particularly pertinent to me because two long-time, very well-regarded people in my Meeting died last week. Even sadder, they departed this life the very same day.

    I myself could offer only a supportive handshake to the grieving widower, but that was enough for him. He mentioned that he was doing as well as could be expected, and teared up. Everyone’s clearly on their best behavior, trying to seem supportive and appropriately reverent. But I’d say everyone’s a little uncomfortable and unsure of the proper response.

    I’ve always sought to strike a balance about what gets shared on social media. I have asked for people to hold others going through tragedy in the Light (Quaker prayer), but have withheld personal details. When a close family member tried to commit suicide, I did post lots of details in the hopes that others might recognize they have other options. It’s a subject that hits home to me because I’ve been in the same situation myself.

  2. It isn’t quite social media, but this reminds me a little of Nick Clarke, the BBC radio presenter who essentially radio blogged his own fight against cancer. These were basically spoken diary entries, which were recorded (though not aired) live and as I understand it, pretty much unedited. The resulting documentary aired shortly before he died in 2006. I wouldn’t listen to it again, but it remains one of the really formative experiences of my youth, listening to that very very real struggle, as opposed to the dramatised impressions I had had from fiction, however well-observed. I think watching live grief on social media possibly has a similar impact.

Comments are currently closed.