In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Bill Seeks To Outlaw Abortion in Indiana; Take the Issue To Supreme Court

A Republican lawmaker has filed a bill to make abortion illegal in Indiana, saying if it became law, it could ultimately be a vehicle to get the U.S. Supreme Court with new members to overturn abortion rights.

But Gov. Mitch Daniels said Thursday that his sense was “it would have a very limited prospect of ultimate success.”

The bill by Rep. Troy Woodruff of Vincennes would change Indiana’s feticide law to make it a Class C felony, punishable with a two- to eight-year prison sentence, to perform an abortion. The only exception would be when carrying a pregnancy to term would pose a “substantial permanent impairment of the life or physical health of the pregnant woman.”

Woodruff said he filed the bill Wednesday in part because there will be a new U.S. Supreme Court and a state must pass a law and then appeal it to the highest court to see if the landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling would stand.

“Also the people have never had an opportunity (through their lawmakers) to vote on the matter,” Woodruff said…

Daniels said he was a “supporter of the right to live.” But he questioned whether it have any prospect of success and whether any time and money spent on it would lead anywhere.

“Ultimately for this to change, I think, first the heart of the country and maybe ultimately the view the courts take of states’ rights to place some limits would have to evolve,” Daniels said.


23 thoughts on Bill Seeks To Outlaw Abortion in Indiana; Take the Issue To Supreme Court

  1. Gee, who could have possibly predicted that someone would try something like this just as soon as Roberts was confirmed, and Alito looks likely?

    Certainly not all us civil liberties chicken littles who were told by “moderates” to shut up; that Roe vs. Wade was in no danger because it’s stare decisis.

  2. We all knew it was just a matter of time…didn’t we? Would this be happening if I’d volunteered more hours for Kerry (not my first choice but I figured lesser of two evils)??? Guess so considering how Bush stole both elections.

    sigh…what sort of world will it be when my kids grow up???

  3. I’m willing to take a political stance on this issue and be aborted. Just, you know…end my misery. I’m losing what little hope I never actually had to begin with. People suck.

  4. I love my state…

    First Daylight Saving, now this…

    I can’t wait till all our roads are privately operated toll roads.

  5. Don’t you just know our state-level elected representatives, like Brandt Hershmann and Patricia Miller, all have big throbbing erections right now?

    That smell, which I thought was eminating from my new Glade Plug-In is, in fact, the collective blood-engorged genitalia of the Short Session.

  6. Yes, yes I did. I can’t wait till the next bright idea the state has. Our state rep came here to Fulton County touting the benifits of a county income tax, and how it would be a good source of revenue for counties in the upcoming years. I dunno if he missed the memo or what, but we already HAD the county income tax, and we have it jacked up to the max rate. Why? Well how else do we pay for such things as water hazards for the local golf course? I kid of course, they payed through public funds for the water holes long ago. Now they are paying to fill them in, the stagnent water would just become smelly in the summer…

    I live here because?!?

  7. All I thought when I read this was “Well, here we go.”

    All of the “feminism is outdated” naysayers will surely show up to explain this sometime shortly.

  8. Oh Lord – why does every state I move to seem to be insane?

    Probably because I keep moving around the South and Midwest rather than getting to the coasts.

    But I like Indiana, it’s so much better than Iowa, and it’s pretty. Why couldn’t they just be sane?

  9. Eh, sanity in Indiana? Not in abundance, I’m afraid.

    I’m a native Hoosier. I moved out to the Portland, Oregon area a year ago. It seems like Indiana’s winger politicians get more unhinged every year.

    But I like that you think Indiana’s pretty. As a nature photographer, I spent a lot of time and effort convincing people of that.

  10. Boy, the fundies are getting bolder! There’s this going on, and then there’s some in Virginia that’s decided to attempt passing this bill:

    § 54.1-2403.4. Prohibition on the provision of certain intervening medical technology for unmarried women.

    No individual licensed by a health regulatory board shall assist with or perform any intervening medical technology, whether in vivo or in vitro, for or on an unmarried woman that completely or partially replaces sexual intercourse as the means of conception, including, but not limited to, artifical insemination by donor, cryopreservation of gametes and embryos, invitro fertilization, embryo transfer, gamete intrafallopian tube transfer, and low tubal ovum transfer.

    The above is almost the same, word for word, as that notorious Indiana bill from a few months back.

  11. My two cents… yes Indiana is pretty… SOUTHERN Indiana. Northern Indiana is so flat that you just have cornfields next to cornfields… It not so pretty up here.

    We may have nuts in the government, but come on… they are follower nuts. I bet this bill never passes (crosses fingers…)

  12. Don’t I keep telling you to move nearer to us, Tapetum? But, nooooooo. Your kids are growing up completely deprived of sledding and it’s all your fault.

  13. Is there no democrat in Indiana to introduce a reasonable amendment … something making it illegal to introduce legislation that violates any womans’ civil rights (such as abortion), on penalty of having bowling balls inserted rectally for nine months …

  14. Your kids are growing up completely deprived of sledding and it’s all your fault.

    Oh there is snow in Indiana. We have sledding and snowmobiles. Skiing… not so much.

  15. Well, ya see, everywhere Tapetum (old college roommate o’ mine) has lived since college has lacked either snow or hills. I keep telling her she’s got to come visit in the winter so we can throw her kids down a hill, er, I mean go sledding.

  16. Mark, I agree, it’s mostly only southern Indiana that’s more interesting than watching TV static. But the Dunes and the prairies (most of them nature conservancy projects) up north are lovely — in the summertime.

    But bills like this, as well as the increasing indifference to green space, piss me off. Patricia Miller’s single-people-can-only-screw-to-have-a-child bill cited by aeonsomnia was vile. Great — my home state has become a petri dish for right-wing lunacy.

  17. This was inevitable but I read an interesting post a few weeks ago. If the court with Roberts and Alito (both relatively young) upholds Roe, the possibility of overturning it will be gone for quite a while. There will still be fights over limitations but any blanket overturning will be off the table. This could turn out to be a win in the end…

  18. sigh…what sort of world will it be when my kids grow up???

    I won’t answer that. I’ll let you sleep peacefully…for now.

    Our state rep came here to Fulton County touting the benifits of a county income tax, and how it would be a good source of revenue for counties in the upcoming years. I dunno if he missed the memo or what, but we already HAD the county income tax, and we have it jacked up to the max rate. Why?

    No matter the party, politicians love taxes like a junkie loves dope. It’s in their veins (so to speak). My state enjoys a lovely 9.00% flat sales tax on EVERYTHING (food, child care, prescriptions, etc.). Oh, you want to go out and eat or buy a bottle of wine? Then you’ll get the 12-15% tax. They just can’t imagine someone enjoying a night out without taxes. I worked an array of retail jobs to put myself through college and used to watch people from out-of-state shit all over themselves when they checked out.

    What’s even better is that our state representatives want to start an Internet tax. They want more? Oh, goody! I might as well lube my ass, grab my ankles, and let’em start pumpin’

    Don’t ask me why I chose to be a Libertarian. Call me a simpleton, but I think less government equals a better quality of life.

  19. Man, I grew up in Vincennes, IN. I went to high school with Woodruff’s relatives. Yet another reminder of why I live in Madison, Wisconsin now.

    But yeah, the state is beautiful. Drive through Brown County in the fall some time.

    Oh, and Lauren, where are you in IN anyway?

Comments are currently closed.