In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Resonance

Jill just linked to this intensely personal piece by Jessica Valenti. In it, she describes trying to sort through the feelings of wanting to love her daughter, but being scared because it was never certain if her daughter, born almost three months prematurely, was going to be okay. I didn’t have Jessica’s experience, and it resonated in very weird ways for me. This isn’t a complete version of events (there are definitely some parts of it that are too personal and painful to write about, even now), but it covers all the basics.

I had a completely painless pregnancy. I was more tired than usual early on, but I never had morning sickness, no acid reflux, nothing. I can’t even remember being uncomfortable. The worst thing that I can recall about the whole thing is getting food poisoning about 7 weeks before my daughter was born and having to sit in Labor and Delivery while they gave me an IV and tried to convince me to have a few saltines.

That was all before I went through labor and delivery. My due date had come and gone and my midwives wanted to make sure that there were no signs of fetal distress, so they sent me for a monitoring test to check. The results were initially inconclusive, and the person who was on call in the testing center was not one of my midwives, but a physician who specialized in high-risk obstetrics. He came over to me and my husband looking very grave and said I needed to get ready to have my daughter that afternoon. After a lot of back and forth, I reluctantly agreed and asked if I could have time to go home, pack a bag and get organized. They agreed and so I did that. I was admitted to the hospital on a Thursday afternoon. (My daughter wasn’t born until very early Sunday morning.)

When I came back, one of the midwives was there and she talked with me about options. After an excruciating experience with getting my IV placed, we agreed to try mechanical induction first and then go from there. That didn’t work. Neither did pitocin. Neither did rupturing the membranes. I was still there on Saturday, exhausted beyond belief. I hadn’t eaten anything since Thursday lunchtime and late on Saturday night, it was finally agreed that they’d do a c-section.

It was *awful*. Because I’d been having contractions for so long, my muscles were incredibly fatigued and overworked. The measured blood loss was 1800 mLs. (At 2000 mLs, you need a transfusion.) They screwed up the pain meds. I remember them telling me I had a daughter and then blacking out.

When I came to, my daughter was clean and wrapped up. I could see her next to my bed in a bassinet, but I had no idea how I was ever going to get to her. I felt worse than I could ever remember feeling in my entire life. When the nurses came to check on me, I told them that I had terrible abdominal pain. They said that was normal. I insisted something was wrong. The pain seemed totally unrelated to where the c-section was and it didn’t feel like stitches or an ache. The nurse took my concerns to the high-risk obstetrician (again on call), who seemed to think that I’d never had a baby before and had no idea what I was talking about, that pain was normal. He said I was fine and that I could eat something. My mother had brought homemade blueberry muffins, so I had one. It was the last thing I had to eat for the rest of the week.

The pain that I was feeling turned out to be a ileus, which is when the GI tract stops working for a period of time. It’s well-known in abdominal and GI surgery, but extremely rare in c-sections. You mostly hope that an NG tube will keep things out of your stomach and that the situation resolves itself in a few days. You can’t eat or drink anything, and it’s *miserable*. My situation was severely exacerbated by medical mismanagement of the NG tube and the entire situation culminated with me throwing up is the most pyrotechnic ways imaginable and briefly not breathing. After that, I demanded to be moved and they sent me from the mother baby unit up to med/surgery. I got a negative pressure room that would normally be used for burn patients so that there wouldn’t be concerns about the baby picking up any weird hospital-based infections.

And that was how I tried to bond with my daughter right after she was born: terribly ill, in excruciating pain, tethered to all kinds of mechanical equipment, and a tube up my nose. I had no earthly idea if I was going to get better and if I did get better, what might happen after that. But I was determined that no matter how sick, how miserable, and how wretched I felt, I was going to take care of my daughter.

She was mine and I was not, under any circumstances going to let anything happen to her. I would drag myself upright, force myself to take the two steps to the bassinet where she was crying. I would nurse her in weird positions because my arms had been stuck like pincushions for IVs and there were limited ways to position her that didn’t involve mangling the needles. I couldn’t even believe that nursing worked because I was growing ever more dehydrated and I wasn’t eating, but I absolutely refused to give in.

If you asked me, I don’t think I would ever describe what I felt for my daughter then as love, at least not a sort that I’d ever heard anyone else describe. It was just fierce determination to make sure that she was okay. I didn’t feel giddy or mushy or ga-ga over her. All I wanted was to protect her and to make sure that whatever agonies the hospital was visiting on our room were falling on me. I can remember thinking, “Kid, you are asking so much of me right now. Please just make this worth it, because I am having such a hard time seeing it right now.”

It was a very long time before I grew out of that sense of feeling like I was throwing myself physically in front of whatever was happening. I never really knew how to relate to mothers who talked about holding their children immediately after birth and feeling blissful. I am 100% certain that bliss never, ever even crossed my mind. As much as I wanted to feel happy when I looked at her, my own pain (which was being treated with fucking ibuprofen) was blinding. There are two pictures of me in the hospital and one of me leaving the hospital with my daughter. In all of them, my face is kind of gray and I’m not smiling. There’s sort of a keep calm and carry on sort of vibe about them. They look like they’re about survival.

When people ask me now how sick I was, I just tell them that I lost all of my baby weight plus another 10 pounds by my daughter’s two week check up. I spent 11 days in the hospital and was given an extra three weeks of medical leave (in addition to my six weeks of maternity leave) to recover enough physically to go back to work. It was about a year before my body really approached the state it had been in prior to that epic disaster.

I love my daughter more than anything, but it’s always going to have the mark of what happened at the hospital when she was born. At this point, it a very faded scar, but it is the sort of thing that won’t ever fully fade. I’m perfectly fine with not having been blissed out with my kid at birth, because she is an amazing child who astonishes me every day. But like Jessica, I really, really wish there was a better narrative for this sort of thing.


41 thoughts on Resonance

  1. I read Jessica’s piece and had a similar compulsion to tell my own story. I might still, but for now (given that i should really be sleepng) I just want to say I empathize deeply with your experience of feeling ferocity instead of sentimentality. Both are forms of love, I’ve come to believe. My life wasn’t endangered quite like yours may have been, but textbook-style bonding was still unimaginable. I love you for your honesty!

  2. evil fizz, your reference to the nightmare of getting an IV resonates with me. I was stuck no less than 25 times for a recent major surgery.

  3. I remember you coming to visit my spouse in the hospital not long after this, and looking pretty much normal. At the time, I was so wrapped up in what was going on with him that I didn’t realize what a feat of strength that must have been.

  4. Love–or “bonding”–at first sight is a dangerous modern myth. We don’t form partnerships that way and we don’t love our children in that way. It is the experience of common hardship and the rare common joy that brings us together and, over time, “bonds” us to one another.

  5. Before I had my baby, I always assumed I wouldn’t feel anything for her until she was at least a year old (or whatever). I have never really “gotten” babies. I mean, they’re cute, I suppose. I imagined that yeah, I’d feel protective and responsible, and obviously I’d care for her, but I wouldn’t really LOVE her until she was “really a person.” I certainly didn’t feel anything for her while I was pregnant.

    My sister was born 3 months premature, and my mother talks about having felt SO attached to her already then, being in the hospital, very sick, wanting to choose to continue the pregnancy for the sake of the baby, because she LOVED the baby, not because of some religious ideas or anything, and when I was at that point in the pregnancy, I thought, man, it is weird that this thing could be born right now and have a shot at being a person, but that is just NOT ME. If my life is remotely at risk, I’m choosing me.

    Then three months later, after four days of labor and (finally) an emergency c-section, despite all the physical stress, she was immediately wide awake, and curious about the world, and made faces at us when she was only a day old. And her eyes were so big and looked JUST like her father’s (they still are, and do), and I was deeply attached. I don’t expect it to go that way for everyone or even most people, but sometimes it does.

  6. Ibuprofen?!!! Fuck. them. I understand that morphine slows the bowel and might not have been the best thing in your case…but there had to be SOMETHING that could have made you comfortable. (not to mention the doctor not taking your pain seriously in the first place)

    And there’s no reason for an IV stick to be that big of a deal unless the tech is just incompetent. I’ve seen peds techs stick my sister in law, with the collapsed, tiny veins, on the first try.

    RE: nursing. Ugh. I wish we had better access to milk banks. It would save a lot of heartbreak. I don’t want to say that you’re “lucky” nursing worked out (nothing about this sounds lucky) but certainly rare.

    Anyway–YES, we need to change the “fall in love/bliss” as soon as you are pregnant/feel the baby move/hold the baby narrative. Even in a healthy birth, bonding can take time and effort. That doesn’t make the end result any less valid.

    Even beyond that, though–what if we opened up our definition of love to include that kind of fierce desire to protect?

  7. I’m so sorry this happened to you. I only have had one surgery in my life, to remove my gallbladder. Being in a hospital for a long period of time, can be very mentally exhausting. Not to mention all the messing up they did, I really can’t believe so many people could be so incompetant. It’s almost to where, I think you should’ve sued the hospital.

    I really respect medical people though, because they have to put up with a lot of grumpy miserable sick people, and that has to just be extremely difficult, especially when you have someone in pain and can’t help them. I just wish things had gone better for you and your daughter.

    Maybe it would help you get some closure to understand why what happened happened. That maybe it’s normal to lose that amount of blood from a c-section, or I don’t know. I’m grasping at straws trying to think of something that could put the situation from a context of feeling you had no control, into one where you understand what and why and it becomes a situation where you understand why that all had to happen.

    I find with myself, and my experience in the hospital, what’s really upsetting is the feeling of a lack of control. This is why horror films about someone getting a disease, or something happening weird to their body are so popular. It’s a fear everyone can relate to. At least it’s over, and hopefully the doctors were doing the best they can, even though in the moment you feel miserable and just want to be grouchy towards everyone. I’ve watched many shows about situations from the doctor’s point of view in hospitals, and medicine is much much more complicated than most people can think. So perhaps, them figuring out your stomach pain was due to a c-section was the best they could come up with at the time.

    I hope it doesn’t seem like I’m defending the doctors too much, it’s more that I’m trying to offer the perspective that things might not have been as out of control as they seemed when you were experiencing them. Hopefully, you can find some comfort in understanding how medical things work, and feel less of a sense of sadness and fear at what happened. I feel, that education makes one feel less out of control of things that happen in life.

  8. Thank you for sharing your story. These are important stories to tell if we’re going to improve medical & maternal care but also to burst the myth that every both story is all butterflies and bliss.

  9. Jackie, I started out writing a measured response to your comment, but it’s just making me angrier and angrier. Do you have any earthly idea how patronizing this sounds? “Doctors are good people, and medicine is complicated, and maybe if you understood that, you could come to terms with your problems.”

    A) Some doctors are not good people. Some doctors are not good doctors. Sometimes there is overlap between these categories. Sometimes good people and good doctors screw up and badly.

    B) I KNOW that medical management of cases isn’t easy, but the stuff they fucked up was not the result of complexity. If your patient says “I have this very specific symptom and it’s getting worse,” and your response is “Awww, you just don’t know any better,”, YOU ARE FUCKING UP AS A MEDICAL PROVIDER. If you inject the wrong things into an IV port, YOU ARE FUCKING UP AS A MEDICAL PROVIDER. If your patient’s husband is running through the hospital to locate someone who can appropriately address your patient’s medical crisis, YOU ARE FUCKING UP AS A MEDICAL PROVIDER.

    C) I am fully medically recovered from what happened. But that doesn’t mean it wasn’t painful and scary and that I’ve been able to put it aside and pretend that it didn’t affect me. There’s nothing wrong or irrational about me loathing the medical providers who fucked up.

    D) I can cope with bad things happening and weird medical complications arising even if I’m not happy about it. I can cope with people fucking up my medical care. What I cannot cope with is someone telling me that I do not know my own experiences.

    And, as a point of clarification, I am legally barred from suing the hospital. It’s called the The Feres Doctrine.

  10. Chava, you’re a peach. Thank you.

    Even beyond that, though–what if we opened up our definition of love to include that kind of fierce desire to protect?

    I think there is the mama bear narrative out there, but it’s certainly simplistic. I also think that outside of a childbearing context, the desire to protect as a sign of love has been heavily coded as masculine. It’s out there, but just in a crappy form.

  11. Your story and Jessica’s resonated with me. I had two bad birth experiences (not, thankfully, as bad as either of yours). In both cases I felt like the word I associated with motherhood was “painful” and my affect was more grim determination than anything else. I admire your strength in the face of such overwhelming difficulties.

  12. Even beyond that, though–what if we opened up our definition of love to include that kind of fierce desire to protect?

    I think that was my saving grace during my daughter’s premature birth (25 weeks, 1lb. 10.oz/735g, 6 mos. hospitalization)—that was my vision of a mother’s love. Which isn’t to say that couldn’t be yet another reductive trope too—just that it wasn’t for me, in my time, in my place. It was very functional. It gave me something to work with (and “work” is the operative word there; having something to do, a direction to go, was critical). Above all else, having some small slice of control, some small slice of something I could have an effect on in the midst of the larger uncontrollable situation, was important. And…I did have a measurable effect by being there, by talking to her. I could see that in the stats. That gave me something to focus on.

    If all I had to operate with was a nebulous “feeling”—something I was supposed to be feeling but didn’t, or wouldn’t necessarily recognize because I’d never felt it before, or was feeling it “wrong”—-that would have been totally nonfunctional for me. And probably for most people. Crisis situations tend to spur a strong need to do something; spur a tunnel-vision type of reaction as a survival mechanism.

  13. Thank you so much for sharing your story and to Jessica for sharing hers. I’m so sorry you had to go through this and I imagine it wasn’t easy to write this either. I’m expecting my first baby in January and have no idea about what to expect in so many areas. I’m not a sentimental or demonstrative person by nature and I wonder sometimes if my own kind of bonding will look deficient if doesn’t include tons of public gushing and cooing from day one. Of course, maybe I’ll become that way in ways that will surprise me. You just can’t know. Even though stories like yours are scary for a first time mom-to-be to read, it’s really helpful to be reminded that we don’t need to follow any script; we just have to do what we can and what we need to to get through.

  14. I’m really sorry for your experience. The person I know who came the closest to dying in childbirth also had doctors and nurses who ignored her repeated insistence that something was really, really wrong after her c-section. It’s terrible to not be listened to and not have pain taken seriously.

    I was induced with my first for non-reassuring fetal signs about a week past my due date. Fortunately, I was able to have a vaginal birth after about 23 hours of labor, but it was not easy. My son was fine, and I was fine, and it still took me weeks to really feel the love come on. I know some women (many women?) feel like they bond when the baby is still in the womb, but I felt like I’d met this stranger and invited him into my home and now I had to get to know him. (Also, I think getting through labor sent me into such a deep, internal place that I kind of forgot I was having a baby until they placed him on my chest.)

    My second birth was better, but there still was a lag with the love thing. I think it’s more common than most people will admit.

  15. Thank you so much for sharing this. As someone who’s most likely going to be pregnant in the next couple of years, I am thankful for these stories, even though I wish they hadn’t happened…but I do want to have a realistic expectation of pregnancy and learn about how it is experienced differently by various individuals. I’m actually intimidated by the cultural narrative that ALL pregnancy and motherhood is perfect and beautiful. I know that’s just not realistic.

  16. I feel sorry for my own mother in what she had to deal with me. I was born a month and a half early, but was not classified premature because I weighed enough. It has been postulated since then that my mother could only carry a child past a certain birth weight until delivery. Had I gone for a full nine months, I am certain I would have been quite large.

    Mom quickly realized that I cried too frequently, I was too easily overstimulated, and I was unusually fearful. I had a severe, months long bout of colic whereby I did not sleep at all. My mother remembers being so sleep deprived that she began to hallucinate and saw bats flying across the room.

  17. why did the doctor decide that you needed to have the baby that same day? what was the matter with it/you? i’ve heard so many stories of (seemingly) unnecessary c-sections – it makes me feel so angry, like the doctor – the whole establishment – is insisting that they/it know your body better than you, no matter what.

  18. For me, after my emergency c-section and before my second child’s birth, it was incredibly healing and important to hear these types of stories of “not love at first sight.” So, thank you for sharing.

    For others reading this thread, you can find some of these stories through ICAN and in the local ICAN meetings. I, too, suspect that it’s much more common to not have love at first sight with your child, especially if you have just had MAJOR abdominal surgery. With c-section rates that are truly astronomical, I think too many women (including myself) start out motherhood feeling incredibly guilty because when we were in pain (and for some of us the first really majorly painful experience of our lives), we were more focused on ourselves than our new babies.

    I had my c-section after 48 hours of labor, 2 failed epidurals, and a spinal tap experience that was excruciating. By the time my daughter was born, I was done. I had nothing left, and for the next 8 weeks, I was trying to build that back up. Love for her definitely came slowly.

    (As an aside, I find it interesting that I felt a deep need to qualify my birth experience as physically tough before I could justify my love coming slowly. That’s problematic I think.)

  19. I love my daughter more than anything, but it’s always going to have the mark of what happened at the hospital when she was born. At this point, it a very faded scar, but it is the sort of thing that won’t ever fully fade.

    I can speak as the daughter in a situation much like this. My mother had an dissecting aortic aneurysm the day I was born (I was born vaginally, which is weird now, but it was the late 70s). As soon as she gave birth to me, she was rushed to the nearest major city to have open heart surgery. I was brought up to the same hospital a day later, and we stayed in the hospital for roughly 3 weeks. After she got out, she could not pick me up, though she could hold me if someone brought me to her–I’m very lucky we had family and others willing to do so.

    These incidents mark everyone involved, but only my mother carries the physical scar. I’ve got mental ones from this (if she hadn’t been pregnant with me, would this have happened?), to be sure, but my mom has the marks. Every time I see her, I’m reminded of how much it cost her to give birth to me and live.

  20. evil fizz:
    Jackie, I started out writing a measured response to your comment, but it’s just making me angrier and angrier.Do you have any earthly idea how patronizing this sounds?“Doctors are good people, and medicine is complicated, and maybe if you understood that, you could come to terms with your problems.”

    Point headings AND a cite. Lawyer dudgeon!

    Fucking hell, what an experience you went through.

  21. This is exactly why I’m very much in favor of using midwives, doulas, and homebirths (for those of whom it would be possible). The kinds of stories I keep hearing about from my friends when they go into the hospital are horrendous.

    Come to think of it, none, not a one, of my friends who went to the hospital to deliver had a vaginal birth the way they wanted. Every single one of them were coerced into c-sections. If the time ever comes that I become pregnant, I’m going to stay home and do it, so help me cosmos. There are far too many obstetricians out there fucking around with penciling in birthing appointments for their daily planner to have even a decent chance of birthing naturally in a hospital. Screw that.

  22. And to be quite frank, I too think there are parents out there that don’t actually love their babies until they get older. I certainly suspect that was the case for me. For whatever reason, I can recall that my mother never was bonded to me as a young child. My father was pretty decent to me until I hit grade school, and then whatever bonding we had sort of disappeared. I never got many hugs and kisses as a tot, but strangely my other siblings did. The bonding experience does not appear to be equally spread.

    There should be more studies on this (with scientific methods, not just evo psych).

  23. I’m fairly crunchy. I had hoped to have my first out of hospital, and I was able to have my second out of hospital. Midwives caught both my kids. But. For everything that is wrong with modern obstetrics, simply opting out is not an option for many people, and we need to work for hospitals to be places where people who need or want the treatments they provide will be respected and listened to.

  24. Evil Fizz, I’m so sorry you went through that. I don’t have a happy/fuzzy birthing story either, and you end up feeling a little robbed, no? It was simply not as advertised, dammit! At least at this remove my family can laugh about our little jaunt through Emergency C-Section Land, but I still can’t talk about the postpartum and the inability on my part to bond early because my brain had apparently been commandeered by Stephen King. Yikes.

  25. @sulyp–Midwives/doulas/homebirths aren’t automatically better. Both of my shitty experiences were with midwives, one of whom was mostly a homebirth practitioner, and I had a doula for the first one who wasn’t very helpful (despite seeming very qualified). I have several friends who have also had bad experiences along these lines. Both obstetricians and midwives can operate with misogynistic viewpoints of “women/births=X” that erase the mother’s experience (e.g., wanting to see birth as an emergency to make it interesting vs. thinking that all women can really have a natural birth, if they try hard enough). My last midwife seemed to be very scientific in her thinking and very feminist–her attitude throughout my prenatal care was that she generally didn’t recommend invasive stuff (ultrasounds, amnios, genetic screening) but that I could have it if I wanted it. During the early part of my labor, she was much more supportive than my previous midwife or doula had been (though not as supportive as she would said she’d be with respect to helping with comfort measures). However, long after it was clear to my husband and I that things were not going well and we needed some interventions she was unwilling to admit this and dealt with it by disappearing for long periods and dragging her feet. We were terrified. I eventually had a c-section and the recovery was much harder than if we’d stopped things earlier as we’d wanted.

    Another friend of mine shopped long and hard for a homebirth midwife and really liked her, until the birth. She hasn’t told me exactly what happened except that she felt very disrespected and wondered if her inability to get pregnant a second time had to do with the midwife.

    My midwife is loved in the community where I live–I’ve never heard anything bad about her. I’m not saying anything publicly about her because I’m still fighting my insurance company to try to get reimbursed for her and need her cooperation (it has been months now). I also needed her to sign my back to work letter, etc. These people have a lot of power over you, and they don’t necessarily use it well. There’s this idea out there that midwives are more woman focused–I’m not sure it’s true, really. Maybe it is, but they’re selected for low risk births and they’re not going to do a lot of interventions because they’re not trained to. That doesn’t mean that they’re treating their patients respectfully.

    I don’t know how to tell you what to look for because I did those things and it didn’t work out for me. The unfortunate reality with respect to maternity care and health care in general is that often we don’t have the choices we’d like to have. However, most births go okay. Even when they don’t, you usually recover. And aside from dealing with people who want to erase your experience by trying to force you to say that it’s all okay because your kid’s healthy now or your practitioner probably meant well (see above), the scars fade with time.

  26. chingona:
    I’m fairly crunchy. I had hoped to have my first out of hospital, and I was able to have my second out of hospital. Midwives caught both my kids. But. For everything that is wrong with modern obstetrics, simply opting out is not an option for many people, and we need to work for hospitals to be places where people who need or want the treatments they provide will be respected and listened to.

    This, so much.

  27. I am so sorry this happened to you, and my heart goes out to you. I don’t have kids (yet), but my mother had a horrible time giving birth to me. I was an emergency c-section, and they had to (or thought they had to) cut her open before the ahesthesia had begun to work… They then did not answer her repeated question whether I was alive or not, leaving her thinking I had died before I was born… She went through a year of therapy after that… I still have no words for what she went through.

  28. chingona: I’m fairly crunchy. I had hoped to have my first out of hospital, and I was able to have my second out of hospital. Midwives caught both my kids. But. For everything that is wrong with modern obstetrics, simply opting out is not an option for many people, and we need to work for hospitals to be places where people who need or want the treatments they provide will be respected and listened to.

    This. I had a homebirth with my second and was a homebirth transfer with my first. And, I really do think homebirth should be a more accepted option. But, I only had this privilege because I live in WA where my insurance had to cover my care with a midwife, and I could afford to pay out of pocket for my VBAC. I know many, many women who cannot.

  29. I think that whatever provider you wind up with (doc, midwife, etc.), there’s always the risk that they won’t listen to you, do the right thing, etc. And childbirth is pretty much never as advertised. You can’t plan it, and the idea that you can have it exactly as you want it sets you up for disappointment.

  30. I totally cried reading this…I had an emergency c-section last Tuesday. I am a total hippie and never doubted that I would have a natural birth. I saw midwives instead of an OB/GYN. I had a doula (who ended up being super-helpful during the 13 hours of labor I went through before the section, and in holding my hand in the OR while they stitched me up so my husband could follow our baby to NICU). I purposely picked a hospital that offers water birth and has a very low section rate. I believe that they considered my section to be completely necessary.

    My son spent the first 24 hours of his life in NICU, and I had to wait 12 hours to see him because I wasn’t allowed to get out of bed. I woke up in the postpartum ward with about 4 hours left to wait until I could see him, and everything just felt so wrong. It’s hard to describe. It was like someone kidnapped a chunk of my soul and was hiding it from me. I can’t imagine what it was like for the moms here whose babies were in NICU for months.

    I didn’t have nearly as tough a time physically as you did, but I did get a headache from the spinal and none of the nurses would do anything except give me Tylenol and tell me the headache must be due to exhaustion, until the last day, when I had a new nurse who took me seriously and brought in a nurse anesthetist to talk to me.

    I’m working on writing out my full birth story, but it’s hard. Sometimes I wake up at night thinking about the worst parts of it and panicking. Everyone tells me I should just be grateful that my son and I are healthy now, and I am, but it was still a really hard experience to go through.

  31. Bridget: Everyone tells me I should just be grateful that my son and I are healthy now, and I am, but it was still a really hard experience to go through.

    I’ve been guilty of saying the same thing when I didn’t know what else to say, but it’s really a crappy thing to say. Of course we are grateful that we’re okay, that our kids are okay, but giving birth is a major life experience, both in terms of what it takes physically and in terms of a life change, and we’re going to have feelings about that. It’s okay to be sad, mad, disappointed, scared, proud, exhilarated, numb, confused, whatever. Any and all of that is perfectly reasonable and rational and needs acknowledgement so we can process those experiences.

  32. Bridget: Everyone tells me I should just be grateful that my son and I are healthy now, and I am, but it was still a really hard experience to go through.

    This.

    I think that this is also a big part of the reason that women don’t talk about not being over-the-moon in love with their babies right away (regardless of their birth experience) because any admittance of those feelings garners a “well you should be grateful and just shut the hell up” from most people.

  33. Or, maybe, this is none of your business?

    tessa:
    why did the doctor decide that you needed to have the baby that same day? what was the matter with it/you? i’ve heard so many stories of (seemingly) unnecessary c-sections – it makes me feel so angry, like the doctor – the whole establishment – is insisting that they/it know your body better than you, no matter what.

  34. I had what most would consider to be a pretty perfect birth with my daughter. I had a short labor, gave birth vaginally in a birth center without interventions, etc. Doing it without pain meds was my choice, and was not due to delay or people not listening to me. However, it was still kinda traumatic, and I spent the first few days feeling weak, dazed and out of it. I did not feel overwhelming warm fuzzies for my girl exactly, though I did insist on sleeping with the light on for the first week so that I could see her at all times and I also had a weird instinctual urge to lick her head clean (I refrained from actually doing it).

    Part of what was weird for me was that I had been through this big, scary, painful experience, and everyone was treating it as wonderful and perfect. When you’re in a car accident your husband and parents aren’t all like “what a beautiful, joyous day! Congratulations!”. It was just weird. As happy as I was, I was also recovering from and processing a kind of scary traumatic experience. Getting to tell my birth story right away to a couple close friends helped the most – with processing it and fitting it all into a narrative I could understand and feel comfortable with.

  35. Oh, man, thank you for sharing your story–and naming the feelings I had three years ago after the birth of my son. I had a psychotic breakdown and had to be separated from my one week old to spend some time recovering in a mental hospital. While I wasn’t physically in danger, since I’d stopped eating, I dropped 45 pounds (baby weight + 10) in the first week.

    “Ferocity” and “survival” are the perfect words to describe my relationship with him over his first year; after I recovered a little of my mental stability, I was determined not to let anything happen to this kid–my fault or otherwise.

  36. Thank you for your sharing your story, your reflection and your thoughtful comments above. I find it hard to fathom how the leading cause of hospital admissions (birth) is such a marginalizing and dehumanizing experience for many people who experience it. Thank you for highlighting that active duty personnel don’t have the same access to medical malpractice, I was not aware of Feres v. US.

Comments are currently closed.