In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

NYPD Fakes Statistics, Downgrades Rape Charges

Anyone who’s seen The Wire knows the drill here: There’s political pressure to have lower crime rates, and so crimes are downgraded and not fully pursued. Which, in New York, has let serial rapists go free.

An investigative report by the Village Voice uncovered nothing short of a scandal. A series of articles exposed the New York Police Department’s practice of consistently “undercharging” crimes in an effort to meet “performance measurements” (quotas are illegal) and make crime statistics appear more palatable. The manipulation of statistics was caught on tapes in which NYPD higher-ups can be heard telling street cops to downgrade crimes or simply not to report particular crimes at all.

Numerous courageous police officers have come forward to tell their tales of questionable police policies, such as retired detective Harry Hernandez, who details a harrowing account of police misconduct related to serial rapist Daryl Thomas. While NYC sexual assault prevention groups say that the issue of under-reporting and undercharging of crimes has been a “growing problem” over the last two years, these “shady police policies,” writes Alex DiBranco on the Women’s Rights blog, had particularly devastating consequences when Thomas was able to sexually assault six different women in a single neighborhood over a period of two months. He was on his way to a seventh when a “lucky break” fueled his capture by police. The brutal spree should have triggered alarm bells, but went unnoticed for so long because the NYPD kept downgrading the assaults to “criminal trespassing.”

Read the details here, and in the Village Voice.


8 thoughts on NYPD Fakes Statistics, Downgrades Rape Charges

  1. When all we are concerned about is a lack of negative publicity, then it shows how we as a society narrowly define and judge success versus failure. Fear drives decisions like these as much as cowardice. There are so many factors that influence criminal activity, but if we focus too much on quantitative statistics rather than a qualitative rendering of the facts, we lose sight of the larger problems, plural.

    We overuse qualitative measurements here and even when numerical data is adequate for what we are attempting to measure, there should still be enough qualitative analysis present to back it up and bring out the full picture.

  2. This was reported as happening in Philly in 1999. In Baltimore, this year. Now New York.

    At this point it would be news to hear about a city whose police department does *not* routinely downgrade rape charges. It seems to be standard practice in large cities.

  3. I cannot believe we are still doing this. Nahida

    Of course they are. Police aren’t interested in protecting, thats just the slogan they use to sell the presence of armed thugs to the handful of comfortable, privileged voters who don’t like the idea of organized oppression on it’s face. I mean, saying “To send children of color off to prison to be raped for smoking pot” just doesn’t have the same ring as “To serve and protect” does in our progressive, post-racial America, does it?

    I mean, being honest about the number of rapes might look bad. Theres no way our boys in blue are going to risk bad publicity because of a bunch of whores and sluts, right? Not while theres still black folk needing to be put in their place.

    /disgust

  4. I had a talk with an NYPD family member about this today, and he gave me a lot of detail on why this happens.

    The short version is that rape is one of seven crimes that have to be reported to the FBI for use comparing crime statistics nationally. City officials want it to look like crime rates are comparatively low, and the pressure they put on the police leadership to make the reported rates go down (one way or another) is handed down through the ranks to the officers who make and follow up on arrests. They experience an implied pressure to downgrade certain crimes where possible.

    It’s an awful phenomenon that is pretty firmly embedded in the structure of many police departments. And it starts with politicians who want to make themselves look better.

  5. @J: Interesting, but I am not sure that this covers for example the Daryl Thomas case above, since none of these incidents seems to have been a completed rape. (Should have been classified as burglary and at most attempted rape according to the Village Voice article).

    In this case it appears that they wanted to reclassify the incidents as misdemeanors instead of felonies to keep statistics looking good.

    The whole Village Voice series (part 3 is the one linked in the post) is very interesting.

Comments are currently closed.