Spoilers below!
All I can say to last night’s episode the Variable is a big fat wow. After a few episodes that I thought were a bit mediocre — and yeah, I know, others have disagreed — last night kicked some major ass. Inner-group conflict, gun fights, mind-bending quandaries, flashback reveals and more!
RECAP
Rather than a full-on recap this week (let me know if you prefer it this way), because I’ve got a lot of questions and such, just a basic run down of everything that happened:
After scaring the shit out of us by making us think he might not, Desmond lived. Hooray!
We learned that before arriving on the island, something bad had happened to Daniel. He had severe short-term memory loss, though his long-term memory seems to be in tact. We learned that on the same day that Faraday saw the fake Oceanic 815 wreckage at the bottom of the ocean, Widmore, who was funding his research, came to visit him. He asked Faraday to go to the island to continue his research, and explained to him that the island would cure him. After some hesitance on Faraday’s part, his mother also encouraged him to go.
We got 100% official confirmation that the Ellie who was escorting Faraday around the island with a gun in the 50s is his mom Eloise Hawking. We also got confirmation of my long-held suspicion that Widmore is in fact Daniel’s father.
Back on the island, Sawyer and Juliet tried to figure out what to do with tied up Phil, and decided that it was time to split. It was either try to steal the submarine, or go back to square one and live on the beach/in the jungle. They seemed to decide that square one is the best idea.
But Daniel wasn’t having any of that. After arriving back on the island, Faraday was a man on a mission. He knew that on this day, “the Incident” that causes the button to be installed into the hatch is going to happen, and had decided to prevent it.
After trying and failing to convince Dr. Chang that he’s from the future by outing Miles as his son, he took matters into his own hands and tried to go find Eloise. After a bad ass gun battle between Faraday, Jack and Kate, and Radzinsky and two random Dharma dudes, they escaped and went to find the Others.
Meanwhile, Radzinsky et al came in and found that Sawyer and Juliet have Phil locked up in their closet. Oops.
Faraday explained to Jack and Kate about the Incident, and that he thinks he can stop it. After spending so much time focusing on the constant in time travel, he realized that he was forgetting about the variable, which is them and their free will. And so, he realized he could prevent the Incident, thereby preventing the plane from crashing, the freighter from landing on the island, Desmond from pushing the button — basically the whole show. He can negate the energy from the Swan station accident. How? By detonating a hydrogen bomb, of course.
They found the Others and, being rather reckless for someone who doesn’t know how to use a gun properly, Faraday went parading into the camp demanding to see Eloise. Saying that he was going to shoot Alpert in the head unless he took him to her, Faraday started a countdown, and just as he neared one, a shot came through his back. He fell to the ground, and saw Eloise, his mother, standing above him. Faraday told her that she knew all along. She knew what? Who is this man bleeding before her? As seemingly parting words, Faraday said “I’m your son.”
QUESTIONS/THEORIES/ANALYSIS
So, is Faraday dead? I know, you’re all going to say yes. He looked pretty damn dead to me, too. But Mini-Ben also looked pretty dead! Right? I’d almost believe that therefore Faraday could still be alive if I didn’t think they wouldn’t pull the “he’s dead — wait!!! no he’s not!!!” trick on us twice in the span of a few episodes. Sigh. I liked him a lot. Though I guess that if they had to kill someone, it’s about time they picked a white dude.
Who ever thought that Miles and Lapidus would be the last Freighter folks standing?
What happened to Faraday before he went to the island? It seems to have been one of his experiments gone wrong, but I feel like the specifics of what the experiment was and why it affected him in terms of memory loss might be important.
What happened between Eloise and Widmore? Obviously they were together at some point, and now they aren’t. But this doesn’t seem like your basic break up. Before, I thought that Eloise might be a double-agent, playing either Ben or Widmore, but not knowing which. Now, it seems like Widmore and Eloise are actually enemies and aren’t exactly in contact. Did you read the exchange between them differently? Which “side” is Eloise on?
One of my biggest questions: when talking to Penny in the hospital, Eloise said that for the first time in a long time, she doesn’t know what’s going to happen. Why? What has changed? Why did she know before and no longer does? Seriously, the answer to that question has to be a key to something.
Is Daniel right? Does the variable exist?
His own death would seem to indicate otherwise. He tried to change things, but instead what happened is what happened all along. I mean, the fact that Faraday still told Charlotte what he promised not to tell her also bears this out. He always tried to change it. Eloise always shot him. Based on what she said to Widmore (and statements to him as a child about him not having enough time, the inscription to him in the journal, etc.), she knew that this would happen.
So, if it could be changed, why would Eloise send him back? She may be cold, but she does seem to love her son, and surely she didn’t want to kill him. Granted her line has always been that certain things are supposed to happen, and therefore they must, no matter how much they suck. But her sending Faraday back pretty strongly indicates that she wasn’t playing around or hiding something from us in that regard. If things can be changed, it seems that she doesn’t know about it.
And yet, judging from the preview, it seems that Jack is going to attempt to try to change things anyway. But then again, Jack is pigheaded and has really bad ideas. Here’s the thing, though: how could Faraday be right? I don’t know a non-confusing way to phrase it, but: if one of them who has time-traveled to the past prevents the Incident from happening, then none of the stuff on the island that we’ve seen with our main characters ever happens at all — and therefore they never would have gone to the past to prevent it. Do you see what I’m saying? The only way that it could be prevented is if, well, it wasn’t.
Granted I’m new to this time-travel stuff, but what I’ve outlined above is what makes sense to me. Please, if I’m missing something, clue me in. But it seems to me that you can’t change something in the past if what you change is what caused you to go to the past in the first place. The fact that you didn’t go to the past would invalidate the fact that you changed it!
What’s going to happen to Sawyer and Juliet? What’s going to happen to Hurley, Miles and Jin? What is going to happen if they’re on the island when the Incident occurs?
And the most probing question of all. Surely you didn’t miss the fact that the 100th episode of LOST last night just “happened” to coincide with Obama’s 100th day in office. We all know there’s no coincidences in LOST.
So: is Obama really Jacob?????