So, Kevin over at Slant Truth has continued the discussion about appropriation off of nubian’s post at blackademic about one-night-stand links. (She develops her thoughts some more over here.)
Basically, the problem (part of the problem) is this: a “little” blogger will labor in relative obscurity. Then a “big” blogger will happen onto one of their posts and go, “Neat!” and take it over to their blog to write a post that will drive up and sustain their already-impressive traffic. The “little” blogger may or may not see a spike in traffic; when the “little” blogger does, it will tend to be extremely temporary and mostly silent. The “little” blogger almost never gets to host the discussion about their own post; that happens over at the “big” blogger’s house, and tends to occur in a way that loses most or all of the original topic. It can also occur in space that is hostile to the original blogger.
As you might intuit, marginalization of “little” bloggers and disproportionate audiences for “big” bloggers tends to track marginalization IRL. This discussion is about the invisibility of bloggers of color, particularly those who post candidly about the issues that are important to them.
In brief: Participation, good. Appropriation, not so good. Respect, good. Treating honest discussions like anthrax-filled envelopes, not so good.
Please go share your thoughts on that subject at blackademic or slanttruth.
Onto the specific subject of this post. I’ve been thinking without much success about ways to rework linking and writing so as to:
–Encourage participation in the original discussion on its original terms
–Discourage blog-mining
–Encourage long-term conversations between blogs and bloggers
–Make reading habitual rather than occasional
(I know that there’s no way to fix the problem unconsciously; I’m just wondering if there’s a way to work up a new standard.)
And I’d like to offer this as a little consumer survey about your blog habits, particularly as relates to this space. What gets you to stick around? When do you become engaged? When do you tune out? In the past, have your comments been narrowly focused? And did you go read the linked posts and their archives, or just refresh the leading page?
And finally, are there any structural remodels or frames that you think might mitigate these problems?
Jill’s solution was to link without comment.
KnifeGhost thought of this one:
I just thought of something.
Is there some way for different blogs to host the same comment page?
For example…. You write an interesting post, nubian likes it, she posts it in its entirety at her blog, and the comments from each blog go to the same page?
Think of each post as a plugin of sorts. The post exists in itself outside of any blog that displays it. Any number of blogs could host it and all comments from all blgos would appear together.
Is the technology available/simple to do that?