In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

My Own Private Schiavo

I disappeared fromthe guest-blogging on Friday. At first, the reason was work. Then in the middle of the day, I got a call from my wife. My wife’s aunt (and God-mother) had a massive aneurism. She’s in a hospital far away.

She’s on a respirator. Her body will not regulate fluids, her blood pressure is all over the place — and the doctors are doing all they can to keep the heart beating. Medical science is so advanced that this balancing act could work indefinately, preserving life, under only the broadest definition, for a woman who will never again be a mother to her children, a friend to her friends, hold an opinion or see a movie. It remains unclear what the husband will do. It is all too clear that the neurologist is interested in the professional challenge of treating a brain this badly damaged, and will give an honest assessment of the patient’s chance of meaningful recovery when cornered (the answer apparently is no chance — she has a 50-50 chance of “living,” but this woman will likely never regain consciousness, and will be vegetative if she does).

I’ve been annoyed for a long time at the fetishization of the mere fact of biological life. I’ve buried several relatives after long, grueling terminal illnesses, not least my mother. These events merely remind me, again, how angry it makes me that we attach some importance to the bodily processes of those that have, in every meaningful way, left us.


8 thoughts on My Own Private Schiavo

  1. Thomas, I wish your family strength in coping with this crisis.

    On a more cynical bent: I believe that the reason why the Pope did not allow himself to be taken to the hospital is that he would have found himself in a Schiavo situation. Who would have removed his feeding tube if he’d fallen into a persistant vegetative state?

  2. Joel, I think you’re right. A pope in PVS would have been a crisis for the Church — no replacement permitted, potentially for years, while the body survived, and unplugging him would have been a major climb-down on theology.

  3. Thomas and Joel, that is the most horribly cynical thing I’ve ever heard. And probably dead-on accurate. Thomas-my best wishes for you and your family. I know how difficult such and times and decisions can be. When my uncle with brain cancer, fell into a coma, there was no feeding tube, and he quickly passed on from dehydration without suffering. To suggest that my aunt’s decision to let him do so, was somehow “murderous” or disrespectful of life on her part is something that infuriates me to end.

  4. (o)

    (That’s a stone, placed to let you know that someone stopped by and thought about you, in the absence of anything particular to say.)

Comments are currently closed.