In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

As Indy Approaches

On Memorial Day weekend, I will watch the Indianapolis 500. Motorsports can be divided into a lot of types and series; Indy is the senior and signature race of the Indy Racing League series. Indy is an oval, the cars are open-wheel. I love open-wheel racing, but I much prefer road courses. I follow Formula One much more closely. More about that later. So Indy is not my favorite series or kind of racing, but I will watch anyway — because of Indy’s place in history, and because of Danica Patrick’s.

There have been pioneering women at the high levels of many forms of racing, but especially at Indy, I think because of its symbolic importance. First, there was Guthrie. She started out as an aerospace engineer who went racing full-time. She raced around the Sports Car Club of America for a while and turned to Nascar, where she was the first woman to race in their top series, then the Winston Cup. She drove the Daytona 500 and was Rookie of the Year, and she competed in 33 Winston Cup events, finishing as high as sixth. Starting in 1977 she raced in open-wheels at Indy, too. She qualified in 1977, ’78 and ’79. The first time, the car had problems and she did poorly. The last time, same thing. But in between, in 1978, she had a really good run, finishing in the top ten: ninth, after starting 15th. With a good car, she could drive with the best in the sport. (Guthrie has a well-regarded autobiography, “A Life at Full Throttle.”)

I have a soft spot for Lyn St. James because, while I was too young to remember Guthrie, I watched St. James’ debut with rapt attention. She was already a road-racing veteran when I first saw her, and in her career she drove twice at the 24 Hours of Le Mans, won the 24 Hours of Daytona twice, and won the 12 Hours of Sebring once. I saw her qualify at the back of the pack in 1992 for Indy. The cars were powerful and twitchy and the track was slick that year; the polesitter crashed on the formation lap! Lyn St. James finished a heroic eleventh, keeping the car on the track when thirteen cars crashed and most of the field did not finish, and was Rookie of the Year — the only rookie to even finish a nerve-shattering 500 miles. Lyn made seven trips to the Brickyard (As Indy is called for the three-foot strip of bricks at the start-finish line), but never again had a really competetive car and never managed a top-ten finish. With a lifetime of top-flight racing, she has not retired to catch up on her reading. Instead, she now runs the nonprofit Winner’s Circle Foundation.

Sarah Fisher started at Indy at just nineteen years of age. When she and St. James started together, it was the first Indy with two women racing. The traditional “Gentlemen, Start your Engines!” has been “Lady and Gentlemen …,” at least since St. James (I don’t recall if they acknowledged Guthrie) but that year, for the first time and not the last, it was “Ladies and Gentlemen …” Sarah Fisher has her own team now, but she’s never had a very good ride. In a half-dozen trips, she has crashed several times and never finished better than 18th. However, elsewhere in the series she managed a pole position, the first woman to start an Indy race from the pole.

Everyone who followed racing and some who don’t saw Patrick coming. She moved to Europe at 16, alone, to race in the brutally competetive Formula Ford series there. She was second at the English Formula Ford festival, the best ever finish by an American. Motorsports journalists started reporting on her after that, seeing her move through the Formula Atlantics towards the big show.

Qualifying for the 2005 Indy, her car’s rear slid in the first turn. It was a disastrous moment; most drivers would have been in the wall, and she shocked everyone by keeping it on the track and then, icewater in her veins, staying fast despite the scare to start fourth, the best starting position by a woman. She led nineteen laps (first woman to lead at Indy), overcoming two key mistakes to finish fouth, the highest by a woman, and to be named Rookie of the Year. (Two out of five women to face the Indianapolis 500 have been Rookie of the Year. That’s 40%. Just sayin’.)

She took three poles her rookie season, but did not win a race. Everyone knew she could, everyone waited to see when she would.

In 2006 at Indy, with a less competetive car and still a bit shaken by the death of teammate Paul Dana, she started and finished Eighth — two top ten finishes in two tries.

In 2007, she was in the hunt and ran as high as second, but finished eight when Scotsman of Italian descent (and Ashley Judd’s husband) Dario Franchitti won the rain-shortened race. Three top ten finishes in three consecutive years. In the season as a whole, she had three podium finishes.

As Jill reported, in late April, 2008, she won the Japan 300 at Motegi. She is the first woman to win an Indy race. That should put her head in the right place as she heads into this year’s Indianapolis 500.

There have certainly been women racers of distinction in other series. In drag racing, both dragsters and pro stock bikes have women legends in their history (Shirley Muldowney and Angelle Sampey, respectively). (Bonnie Bedelia, one of the better actors of her generation I think, played Muldowney in a now-dated but very watchable movie, Heart Like a Wheel.)

Michele Mouton very nearly won the World Rally Championship in an Audi Quattro that lacked the reliability to match her skills, and did win both one of the series events and a prestigious non-series event, the Pike’s Peak hill-climb. When the governing body decided that the “killer B” Group B rally cars were too fast and powerful, Mouton retired rather than race in less powerful Group A cars. Ha!

However, there is a lot of room for improvement at the top. NASCAR has not had much in the way of women; Formula One has had only five women drive and only one had what anyone would call a career (Lella Lombardi finished as high as Sixth, the other four women had just a handful of races each and never earned a championship point).

There are some women coming up in sports car racing; Liz Halliday does well in American Le Mans, and I think Milka Duno (the third woman, with Patrick and Fisher, in the 2007 Indy) may be less out of her depth in sports cars than she is in Indy cars. Simone De Silvestro got a win in Atlantics in April, and with Katherine Legge is the only woman to win in Atlantics. Legge also tested an F1 car, though she races the German Touring Car series for Audi now. But the groundswell of women at the lower levels of racing is not yet fairly reflected at the upper levels. There should be women in F1 cars, WRC cars, sports cars at ALMS and at the 24 Hours of Le Mans, and in NASCAR’s top series every year, not just a few times a decade. I hope we’re getting there.

When my daughter is old enough to watch it with me, I hope that as the starter says, “Ladies and Gentlemen, start your engines,” eight, ten, twelve women fire the engines and pull out on the formation lap, each hoping to have her name inscribed on the Borg-Warner Trophy, and little girls in karts around the country can root for any woman, not just the woman.

I don’t pretend to have exhautive knowledge of the women in the pipeline for the top series; if anybody knows of women we should keep an eye on, leave them in comments.


20 thoughts on As Indy Approaches

  1. Teeny little nitpick – Indy is actually called “The Brickyard” because it used to be paved entirely in bricks. the three foot strip is there now as a memento, as it were: when they paved it, they sold all the bricks to fans. I’ve actually known families to break into feuds when grandma died and there was a debate over who got The Brick.

    This could well be Dani’s year. We all hope so, anyways. I had hoped 2007 would be it, but Dario’s team made a better calculation of the rain and made a smarter gamble on the fuel. It was a bit disappointing, but from out seats we got to see Ashley Judd throw off her hat and shoes and go running down the track to tackle him as he got out of the car. THAT was pretty damned awesome, too.

  2. The karting ranks are filled with young women, ages 5-15, right now. I don’t have any names but there should be some ready for the racing minor leagues in 3-5 years.

    Keep an eye on the marketing. If Danica continues to make the waves (as in $$$$), you’ll see the race teams actively seeking women and putting them into their developmental programs. No marketing = status quo (and few to no new women drivers).

  3. Thanks for that, Elizabeth Anne. Ashley and Dario will stick in my mind forever for another reason: my dad is from the same part of Scotland as Jimmy Clark, the other Scotsman to win Indy (Stewart led but did not win). Clark died tragically in 1968; on the way to the winner’s circle, a reporter asked Ashley Judd what Dario was thinking. She said he was thinking of Jimmy Clark.

  4. I hate to be such a sourpuss– Yes it’s good women are getting recognized and being successful doing what they love. BUT I find this post interesting when taken into consideration with the “Story of Stuff” above. The ability to burn through massive amounts of fuel purely for the sake of entertainment– when there are so many alternative entertainments, when we’re fighting over fuel, when we’re also worried about emissions– seems… off.

    Maybe I’m the only one who feels this way, though…

  5. Speaking of female firsts in racing, Ashley Force became the first women to win in the NHRA Funny Car division two weekends ago. (She beat her dad, drag racing legend John Force.) Given the equipment she’s in, she stands a real good chance of becoming the first woman to win a championship in a major division in American motorsports history, if not ever.

    As an avid racing fan, especially NASCAR, I’m wondering what your thoughts are on the relative lack of gender and racial diversity in that series.

  6. Kelsey, you’re probably not the only one, and I find the juxtaposition interesting also. That said, the public policy choices we have made in the US to privilege cars over mass transit and develop an endless sprawl along highways and to refuse to seriously impose efficiency standards on fossil-fuel burning vehicles make more of a difference to world energy policy than all the karts and cars that race everywhere. I’m not saying it’s purely symbolic, but I am saying that to fix the mess we’re in we need solutions to the big issues as well.

    I keep hoping we’ll just get cold fusion, but short of that, solutions will be uncomfortable for all concerned.

  7. Kelsey:

    The Indy cars run on ethanol. Which brings up the whole corn-for-ethanol issue, but still it’s not fossil fuel.

    Chris:

    Shirley Muldowney won the NHRA Top Fuel Dragster championship three times.

  8. Thlayli– I did not know that. Still, though, I find them symbolic of the car-dependent culture we’ve created, which Thomas describes. Maybe I’m nit-picking, though.

  9. Kelsey, I think the point is well taken; and I don’t think there’s anything contradictory about both discussing what happens within problematic aspects of our culture, and having the larger discussion of why things are the way they are.

  10. Hm, true. I just wanted to point out that a love of cars (and I, personally, LOVE cars, so I know this first hand) as they currently and commonly exist (gas engines) sometimes conflicts with a love of the environment and a concern about the frivolous use of limited resources.

    It’s a little philosophically contradictory for me, being a passionate member of the Environmental Science club, living in a city and talking about how more people should use bikes and how the rail system needs to be better, and then going home to torrent Top Gear episodes. *sheepish grin*

  11. Kelsey—another car lover here, asking what’s wrong with entertainment?

    By which I mean, I think our priorities regarding where to cut down on emissions could use some rethinking. Entertainment has value; it’s important, and we do ourselves a disservice when we automatically slate it to be the first thing cut when resource availability comes into play.

    What I think should be done first to conserve fossil fuels is to deal with the commuters who complain about their daily commute, the hours spent crawling in traffic, the people who don’t give a damn what their car runs on, so long as it is affordable and runs conveniently. This should always be done, for any problem: arrange for people to give up something they don’t care much about before you ask people for something they care deeply about; get the sacrifice from people for whom it’s a small sacrifice, before you go after the ones for whom it’s a large one.

    Thus, I think auto racing should stay. I think performance cars are lovely and I would like to continue seeing them, and flat-out oppose any attempts to get them toned down or removed from production in the name of greater average fuel efficiency. I think that it’s flat-out ridiculous to take away something that is loved from the small percentage of people who love it, when there are loads of people who really don’t care what they drive, don’t like driving, wouldn’t miss unleaded petroleum fuel or V-8 engines in the slightest, who can give up the same thing without shedding a single tear—and in greater numbers besides. What I want to see is all the Honda Accords and the Toyota Camrys and the Chevy Cavaliers driven by the type of people who complain about the length of their commutes to all run on hydrogen fuel cells or some kind of decent electric/gas hybrid or whatever else the world’s innovative minds can come up with, and leave the gasoline to Mustangs and Camaros and classic ‘Cudas and GTOs and Ferarris and Lamborghinis—to the people who get the most out of what it has to offer.

    One problem with conservative philosophy is that it attempts give the same treatment to people in different circumstances, with little or no regard for individual wants or needs. I’ve had people argue to me that banning gay marriage isn’t discriminatory because gay men have the same right as straight men to marry a woman, and that straight men and gay men alike are forbidden to marry men; the same logic is at work when people suggest that automobile fanciers, racers, and commuter drones alike exchange their engines for something smaller. The “one size fits all” approach is foolish when people are different sizes.

    I’m sick of feeling that I should apologize for wanting a sports car that gets nineteen miles to the gallon, or for spending entire days driving for no other reason than that I love it, and I’m sick of seeing gallons and gallons of gas burned up by drivers who get no joy from it. To me, that is what’s wasteful, more wasteful by far than the Indy 500 or the Saleen fan club.

  12. RE: posts above…

    It’s a lot like the space program. Yes, we may spend ridiculous amounts of fuel to get to the moon. But the space program also gave us Ultrasound, velcro, freeze dried food…

    Many of the advancements in auto safety for the rest of us came out of the racing leagues. Airbags, for example, were originally designed for racing. Our understanding of crumple zones, as well, came from racing research. The truth is, we rarely get to tech advancements by a direct approach: we find it by accident, through sideways venues.
    The truth is, with so much riding on the safety of race drivers, and massive financial benefits for tiny advantages in fuel economy (again, Franchitti won last year’s Indy based on a 2 lap advantage in fuel equations), massive improvements in engineering happen. We all wish they could happen for altruistic reasons, but lets face it: the big cash prizes make a big difference.

  13. Hmm, points taken.

    Personally, I think car lovers are going to be the people pushing for breakthroughs in things like hydrogen power.

    When my brother came home from a long trip in rural India, though, he could do little but gawk in shame at the way we CAN use precious resources as “entertainment”. I took it very seriously into consideration.

  14. Aaah, thanks for the Formula One plug. To read any newspaper in the U.S., you’d think there were two kinds of car racing: NASCAR, and the Indy 500.

    Also thanks for mentioning Shirley Muldowney, above commenter! Sadly, when I was watching her at age 17 (in the late 70s), I took it for granted she was just going to be the first in a long line of women car racers. Because, you know, we were equal back then. Finally.

  15. Tinfoil Hattie, I’m with you on the sports pages. I don’t follow the big American sports but I do follow F1, boxing, mixed martial arts, the football team from my dad’s hometown in Scotland, and I used to follow rally when Colin MacRae was active. With the exception of a few fights a year, all of the above are absent from the newspaper and broadcast sports news.

    F1 is in some ways better and in some ways worse. Because of the global following, there are Indian and East Asian drivers and last year’s rookie sensation is biracial, from the UK with a black Guyanese dad (I’m a huge Lewis Hamilton fan, as I have a Hamilton connection on my father’s side and wear Hamilton tartan). So F1 looks more like the world than the American racing scene (I’ll note an exception in drag racing, which I don’t follow, but I seem to recall a decent latino representation).

    I also hear you about thinking Muldowney was just the first of many. I’m younger than you, but my mom was a second-waver and she taught my sister and I that the world was changing and those barriers were falling and that women could do anything. And here I am, thirty years later, hoping that when I teach my daughter that those barriers are falling, it will be true.

    When I took my first women’s studies class in high school in the 1980s, the teacher had a Pirelli ad up on the bulletin board that was a cringeworthy double-entendre with tires and women’s bodies and I shook my head at the sexism of it; and twenty years later I’m criticizing orange juice ads that prompt other people to say, “do they want me to buy it or fuck it?”

    Yeah, racing is just entertainment. But women’s place in it is not just entertainment.

  16. I just want to say, sort of OT, that Jim H in Indiana is the go-to guy for this information. He needs to regale us with the stories of his experiences on the racing curcuit with his family. 🙂

  17. It’s a little philosophically contradictory for me, being a passionate member of the Environmental Science club, living in a city and talking about how more people should use bikes and how the rail system needs to be better, and then going home to torrent Top Gear episodes. *sheepish grin*

    You describe most environmentalists. Actual lifestyle changes are always for other people.

  18. Actually, Lauren, some of my stories aren’t fit for printing! Or workplace consumption, for that matter. 🙂

    Until Janet Guthrie, Indy didn’t allow women in the pit area, let alone to compete. I remember in my early days in racing (I’m an “old guy”) at the local level, the only women in the pit area (where the cars are and separate from the grandstands) were “sluts.” Wives or girlfriends wouldn’t dare come to pits until after the races were over.

    My how things change (and for the better)!

    (sorry for replying late to this thread)

Comments are currently closed.