In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Peeling the sticky tape away from sex ed

I went to a Christian girls’ school. Now, not to say that all Christian girls’ schools are run like this, but I’m sure you can guess what the sex ed was like. No sex before marriage for you, girls! (Because you’re getting married, and to men, don’t you know.) You are like a piece of sticky tape: every time you stick yourself to someone, you get more bits of dirt on you until you find you can’t stick to the person you want to spend the rest of your life with! Look at these gross pictures of gross sex diseases, eww!

Suffice it to say, we were taught about uteri and fallopian tubes, but not about what this mysterious clitoris was. We weren’t taught about masturbation, or any sort of non-PIV sex, and we only got a hushed ‘and use a condom!’ at the end of the course. We were too embarrassed to look at each other, let alone discuss our fears or excitement or the gaps in our knowledge.

When we were in Year 11, we had a personal development day together with a boys’ school and another girls’ school. We all trooped into the boys’ school and prepared for a day of speeches, much like those we’d been given through school. But part way through, we got a rather unusual speaker who I’d encountered once before, have met once since and have never, ever forgotten. I’ll call her Mary. Mary was a very loud, enthusiastic woman: enthusiastic about teaching us, enthusiastic about being a Christian, enthusiastic about sex. Her manner was pretty full on, going from joyful shouting to (somewhat) hushed prayers. On this particular day, one of these prayers contained, ‘and I thank the Lord for my clitoris!’ Not a Christian myself, I wasn’t in head bowing mode at the time, so I had the opportunity to look around the hall – once I got over the shock that someone actually said that word out loud, that is. Half of my classmates were tensely frozen – particularly the ones sitting near boys – and half of them were whispering to their neighbours. Even though I couldn’t hear any of them, I knew exactly what they were saying. ‘What’s a clitoris?’

Looking back, I shift between describing this moment as hilarious and horrifying. From ‘I thank the Lord for my clitoris’ on through the rest of high school, I made it very clear to my classmates that they could come to me for any information or resource recommendations they might want and I wouldn’t shame them.

What’s a clitoris? It’s a question I’ve had to answer many times since that day, but every time it makes me very sad that I’m the one answering it. It should have been told these young people by their parents and their teachers, not that oddball feminist they know. It should have been taught along with all the other information they were given, through education formal and informal, about their bodies, and relating to people, and information about how the world works. Because whether they’re waiting for marriage or not wanting to have sex ever or already starting out on their sexual lives, young people have the right to information that will allow healthy, informed decisions about their own selves. And it’s terribly sad that young people are so often left to glean this information as best they can.

I think about this kind of sex education and how damaging it can be, causing anxiety and shame where there shouldn’t be, for a start. What kind of educator wouldn’t want their charges to have proper information so they can make up their own minds and run their own lives well? Mine, apparently.

Recommended related reading: Recently I rather enjoyed Que(e)rying Sex Ed by WildlyParenthetical, who teaches a university gender and sexuality course.

[Cross-posted at Zero at the Bone]


11 thoughts on Peeling the sticky tape away from sex ed

  1. I went to a fairly liberal public school and our sex-ed was about the same, though maybe without the focus on “wait for marriage” but there was nothing beyond the dry biological stuff that you describe, in fact, I think it would’ve been better to at least be told “wait for marriage” becuase that’s at least an admission that sex was a physical act. I didn’t get any of that from sex-ed, sex-ed was basically a “menstruation” tutorial, probably to avoid having to deal with us one-on-one if we had questions about it.

    But the “relating to people, and information about how the world works” stuff was never taught, it never is and the lack of it sets a lot of us up for trouble…

    credit too, woulda been nice to learn about how credit ratings work too…. oh well, maybe next time… 🙂

  2. hurrah internet today…. except many schools ban many informative websites up to and including things like scarleteen. It’s insane. Not only do they not teach right, but they deny students access to people who DO want to dismiss information. Schoolchildren are living in the era before Comstock, because we adults are too skeeved out by the truth to share it.

  3. I have come to realize that I was EXTREMLY lucky in my sex-ed classes, or atleast in high school.
    Our sex-ed classes were under the general subject of ‘health’ and were a mandatory part of our mandatory gym classes. This meant that our sex-ed was taught to us by our gym teachers. Thankfully, my gym teacher was pretty awesome. Yes, we did learn anatomy and disease and the standard stuff. But our teacher was also on the ball with teaching reality. She answered pretty much any question we had, and told stories about her twin sons playing with their penises as babies.
    Some of the people in the class were uncomfortable, but I have to say I’d rather be a little uncomofortable than left out entirely in the dark. (Also, we have to acknowledge that they were probably uncomfortable since you know, we aren’t supposed to talk about these things. ever!)

  4. I went to a number of public and private schools over the years, and (surprisingly) the best sex ed I got was in the private christian one. They had had a rash of pregnancies in the preceding years and were now making sure they covered every possible form of contraception. The one I had at a (very good) public school essentially boiled down to “don’t get AIDS”, with no information on how one would accomplish that.

    OK, no one ever told us what a clitoris is, or the marvelous things it does. Even as a guy, I’ve said numerous times that I wish they had told us about that, since I someday hoped to have a partner and it would have been nice to know how to pleasure her. I can’t remember now if I finally learned of its existence from a purloined Cosmo or from a friend who possessed one (a clitoris, not a Cosmo).

  5. So i got the comprehensive sex ed here in nz (we’re second highest in teen pregnancy rates and clymidia next to america so maybe ours isn’t the best either).
    there’s no requirement to teach anything to kids in primary school, but some do and we got seperated into boys and girls. We got info on periods. They were helpful enough to actually hand out samples of pads and tampons, which was nicely informative, except at 12, when this was, i already had my period (probably a lot of my class did too). The boys came back joking about masturbation so i’m guessing someone told them that that was alright and normal in their group.
    When i got too highschool the first year of health was puberty. It was useless. Practically everyone in the class had already gone through a lot of it. Yes, we know you get pubic and underarm hair because we already have it. sigh.
    The next year (14 going on 15) we got the sex ed. I was amused by the ‘they only way you can be absolutely certain not to get pregnant/stds is by not having sex’ i was thinking nah-duh, why else would they call them stds. They talked through various forms of contraception and put most emphasis on condoms (which we put on wooden penis’s). We watched an awful 80s video on this gay guy dying of HIV (it did bring up that HIV was not just something that happened to gay people, so could have been worse). Plan B was never mentioned, abortion was mentioned once when we were asked ‘what methods of contraception do you know of?’ annoying disruptive kid ‘a punch in the stomach’ ‘no, that’s an abortion’. And it ended there, when someone should have mentioned that that wasn’t safe and there were safe ways to abort. Bet they weren’t allowed to mention it.
    We got diagrams of genitalia. They were awful, abosultely awful. I didn’t really know what foreskin looked like until i saw it, and i thought balls hung down seperately as two of them. The female one was even worse. It had some scribbles for the labia, and then little cirlcles for clitoris, urethal opening, vagina (a slightly bigger circle) and anus. They once showed us a video of a man becoming erect. We never saw any photos of vulvas, or anything better than those diagrams. We never talked about what a clitoris did.
    Overall it felt like they were just feeding us information, carefully avoiding the no-go zones.
    The only time it was any good was when we invited someone from planned parenthood to come talk to us. She rambled on whatever subject she felt like. Told us about cervical smears (which also hadn’t been mentioned) and menopause and other random stuff. She mentioned female masturbation (though i still didn’t realise that most females masturbated like me, rubbing arounf their clits rather than sticking fingers into themselves).
    Its taken till 20 till i knew that my body is normal, that most women don’t orgasm from penetration alone, that i don’t smell or taste disgusting… I learnt a lot of these things the hard way with tears and shame. An open discussion at 14 or so would have made it a bit easier.

  6. I didn’t go to private school even, and that sex education sounds exactly like mine except that we weren’t told to to use condoms, even in a hushed voice (because apparently they don’t work).

  7. My sex ed (in a public high school in relatively liberal Chicago) consisted of our jarhead gym teacher barking at us like a drill sergeant about what we were and were not allowed to call genitals, bursting into a fit when someone giggles at some the ridiculous slang on his list of verboten terms, and then making us watch graphic Vietnam-era videos about VD (complete with pictures of the dreaded, and fictitious, black syphilis). He lasted all of 30 seconds into the questions-and-answers portion before someone asked him about condoms and he turned the kind of red one is only able to achieve through a combination of Catholic upbringing and military service. The rest of our health and sex-ed block was taken up by inspirational sports videos.

    About a year and a half later he was caught having sex with a student.

  8. I went to an all-girls catholic school and I come away from that very grateful that we had a wonderful (seemingly feminist!) principal. It was quite funny because we did get conflicting messages. In our religion classes sex was definitely discussed in an “only-when-you’re-married!” way. And we once got a handout with a lot of outdated false information about HIV/AIDS that I had to correct. My religion teacher sure did not appreciate my, you know, thinking for myself! Thankfully, we only did a brief unit on sexuality in grade 12 religion and sex education took place in realy classes like science and health.
    However, our mandatory grade 9 health class was very informative. We spent a lot of time going over the anatomy of both men and women as well as the function of every organ. Our teacher was very honest and open with answering our questions. I’ll never forget a good friend of mine asking, “What’s an orgasm?”, followed by giggles from the mean girls. Our teacher appeared caught off guard with that one, but she answered it honestly nonetheless (something about a “release” if I remember correctly). That class was a huge realtiy check on how ignorant young women were about their own sexuality. I took for granted how lucky I was to come from a home where these questions had been answered years ago. I thought surely everyone had experienced an orgasm at some point.
    Then when I was in grade 11, our principal brought in nurses from Toronto Public Health to give us very detailed information on STIs. Granted, the poor woman had to keep saying, “This information is useful for your FRIENDS who don’t go to catholic school *wink wink*.” I guess that was so some of the old school teachers and nuns wouldn’t have a heart attack. This nurse also spent A LOT of time telling us how fun touching ourselves and our partners can be. It was refreshing to hear an adult encourage holding off on sex until you’re ready to face the risks while still advocating for exploring your sexuality.
    Our wonderful principal also brought in some people (I don’t recall what organization they were from) to discuss relationships with us in a series of workshops covering emotional, physical and sexual abuse as well as consent.

  9. My sex-ed teacher spent most her time lecturing us on how smoking shouldn’t be allowed in film, since it was BAD. I told her that as an artist and as an American, her views disgusted me.

    She also had a speaker come in and lecture us about what shitty moms teenage moms were. I told him my mother was a teenager mother and a wonderful mother. His response? “Well, thats YOU’RE mother.” No shit, that’s MY mother.

    And I wished, in the name of God, that stupid teacher had covered valuable information–like UTIs, and how to prevent them, and yeast infections, and how to prevent them.

  10. I received a 1950’s sex-ed that I believe should be a model for public schools. Although the subject matter needs to be updated, I found the format excellent. One evening while a six-grader in my Elementary School, my father took me to a class hosted by a local Doctor, who with help from charts and a blackboard, went over the “everything you wanted to know about sex” lesson. Having my Father there left open the doors of communications for years to come. That experience afforded me to not be afraid to broach a subject that between Sons and Fathers can be a bit “sticky.” Of course, the Female Clitoris was never discussed, as I’m sure many of the Fathers hadn’t a clue as well! “To be fore-warned is to be fore-armed!”

Comments are currently closed.