In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

book recs for children

One of the consequences of being the only literature person in a room full of doctors (parents’ friends, usually) is having to come up with endless recommended reading lists for their children. A lot of Indian parents, and I’m not sure if this happens elsewhere, seem to believe that there’s something inherently virtuous about the act of reading that raises it above ‘lower’ art forms like movies, videogames, comics (which aren’t real reading, apparently) and the like. They want their children to read, but they’re not sure what.

I love doing this. In bookshops I spend more time in the children’s section than I do in the adult’s; something most bookshop owners seem to find suspicious.

After my exams earlier this year my brain briefly rebelled and for a time I could only reread childrens books. I’ve come to love Tamora Pierce’s Tortall books – what a wonderful way to introduce children to issues of gender (and class, but mostly gender) and do it realistically and still be wonderful and entertaining.

I’ve also been recommending China Mieville’s book-for-young-adults Un Lun Dun to a number of people, for various reasons (none of which include making him feel lots of gratitude towards me, at which point we will get to talking and he’ll find out that we like all the same books and..no, it’s nothing to do with that. At all.)

Er. So what’s your favourite children’s book and why?


122 thoughts on book recs for children

  1. A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, Betty Smith. It’s one of my favorite books full stop, not just as a children’s book. Partially because it’s exquisitely written and is unashamed to face the full realities of living in poverty in 1900s Brooklyn, and partly because it feels like part of my family’s history (almost all of my family came through New York and lived in tenements at one time or another).

    Runner-up: Coraline, Neil Gaiman. Spooky and amazing.

    I notice that both of these feature strong female protagonists, and that wasn’t even on purpose.

  2. As to parents elevating reading above other entertainment pursuits, that is not a uniquely Indian thing, and I can’t disagree with it. Reading is active in a way that watching television is not: it requires a certain amount of effort and imagination.

    And I’m glad my parents had that view. It meant I could read anything as a child. Comic books weren’t excluded from “reading” in my childhood, so I went through an Archie phase. And later, a V.C. Andrews phase. Mmmmm, incest.

  3. Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH, which is odd, because the happy ending is the rats establishing a communist utopia away from human society, which, in general, is not my bag. But I was young and naive when I first read it, and now nostalgia overrides my instinct to red-bait. The first sequel was also quite good, I think it was called Rasco and the Rats of NIMH.

  4. As the mother of a reader, I can’t stop at one book. I appreciate any books that capture my daughter’s imagination, but a few stand out from the rest: Despereaux by Kate DiCamilio, The BFG by Roald Dahl, Charlie & the Great Glass Elevator (Roald Dahl again), Matilda (sense a Dahl pattern here?), Fudgemania by Judy Blume, and all the rest of the Fudge books.

    And finally, my all-time favorites: A Series of Unfortunate Events, which I’ve actually read but my daughter hasn’t finished.

    I don’t mention the obvious: the Harry Potter books. My daughter recommends them, but I reminded her that she’s never gotten around to finishing any of them, plus I hate reading them out loud (too much dialogue, and I hate reading dialogue). Same with The Hobbit–which is a joy to read to yourself, but torture to read out loud.

    Oh, and the Chronicles of Narnia of course.

  5. I just finished reading Watership Down and totally loved it. It’s filed in the children’s section but it’s such a good read for anyone.
    Also, I have to agree on Narnia. I read those over and over.
    My all time favortie book when I was a kid was Where the Red Fern Grows. It always made me cry….I don’t know how I would like it now though.

  6. Oh, a question I finally feel completely informed to answer! (polishes shiny new MLIS degree.)

    First, the American Library Association gives tons and tons of awards every year, and most people are probably familiar with ones like the Newbery and Caldecott. However, they also have awards for other things, like the Schneider Family Book Awards, which “honor an author or illustrator for a book that embodies an artistic expression of the disability experience for child and adolescent audiences.” Even more exciting (and less well known) is their Amelia Bloomer Project which is sponsored by the ALA’s Feminist Task Force. It’s an annual list that features books, as you can guess, that feature women and girls, both historical and contemporary, who challenge stereotypes and overcome obstacles on their own.

    So, those are two really good places to start looking for books that might slip by unnoticed. And there’s nothing better than bringing a girl a book with a really kick-ass female character! 🙂

    I also loved Paper Bag Princess and remember cheering so much at the end: they didn’t get married after all. Another picture book in that vein that makes me cheer is Stand Tall, Molly Lou Melon by Patty Lovell, about a strong little girl who doesn’t give in to bullies and is proud of who she is.

    And I have a special fondness for YA novels, especially those featuring GLBTQ protagonists because I think it’s heartening to see the numbers of those books soar. (that’s what I did my master’s coursework on.) And now I’ll stop babbling, heh.

  7. I second the Roald Dahl recommendation.

    I also loved Eva Ibbotson, particularly The Secret of Platform 13.

    Also, Philip Pullman and the young adult novels of Terry Partchett.

    For non-fiction, the Horrible History series by Terry Deary were my favourites.

  8. as a young person i loved “A Wrinkle in Time” and it’s sequels. more recently i fell in love with the “His Dark Materials” trilogy by phillip pullman.

  9. I’ll third the Roald Dahl (I adored Matilda). And although it has some weird religious/gender stuff that I thoroughly ignored as a child, I loved, Madeline L’Engle, A Wrinkle in Time and related books. And again, though they have some weird stuff about Native Americans and one horrifying scene with a minstrel show, I loved the Laura Ingalls Wilder books. They let me lose myself in my imagination about the past and have some great description, as well as an independent-minded little girl as the protagonist. For picture books, I can’t recommend Miss Rumphius highly enough (OMG – a girl/woman character who lives a rich and fulfilling life without getting married). As an early teen, I loved fantasy novels with strong female/lgbt characters, no matter how cringe-worthy the writing was in retrospect.

  10. “The Bartimaeus Trilogy” by Jonathan Stroud. It’s kind of like a very dark Harry Potter but with a demon as the main character. There are also many parallels to current events. I bought it for my nephew and ended up buying the series for myself, too.

  11. The Phantom Tollbooth by Norton Juster has long topped my children’s book list. It might be a little dated and weird, but there’s nothing quite like it.

    I’m also insanely fond of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz and even more of the followups, especially The Marvelous Land of Oz and The Patchwork Girl of Oz. I guess I’m just fond of magical otherworlds… I always liked Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass too.

    I’ll definitely second A Series of Unfortunate Events and Tamora Pierce’s books, and A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. How about the Dangerous Angels series by Francesca Block? Those are beautiful. And nobody has mentioned Shel Silverstein yet either: Where the Sidewalk Ends and The Light in the Attic etc. etc.

  12. a lot of excellent books i grew up reading have been mentioned.

    i’d like to add the “dealing with dragons” series by patricia wrede, which, like tamora pierce’s tortall series, is a fun way into gender issues at an early age. kick ass princess heroine!

  13. Truckers, the Snarkout Boys books, a lot of Beverly Cleary, Bruce Coville, Bunnicula, Figment, Your Dog, Speaking… My list goes on and on, but those are some at the top.

  14. Bridge to Teribithia is a really beautiful book. (You’d have to be a robot if it didn’t make you sob a little.)

    I loved the Narnia books as a child, and still do, although I felt a little cheated when I got older and realized that they were full of Christian propaganda. The Golden Compass and its sequels are great books, and are in some ways the exact opposite of the Narnia books.

    Ooh, and Holes.

  15. I’ll add my voice to the chorus loving Tamora Pierce. I was/am a complete bookworm, and grew up loving Laura Ingalls Wilder, Patricia C. Wrede’s Dealing with Dragons series, the complete Dangerous Angels series by Francesca Lia Block, Anne McCaffrey’s Dragon Singer trilogy (and almost all other McCaffrey books), Jane Yolen’s Sister Light Sister Dark trilogy, and Francis Hodgson Burnett’s A Little Princess and the Secret Garden.

    Top ten all-time favorite author is still L.M. Montgomery– Anne, Marigold, Emily, and Pat are all favorite heroines.

    Mercedes Lackey’s Arrows of the Queen trilogy was seriously a life-changing gift for me at eleven, turning me onto dozens of fantasy authors (McCaffrey, especially) with strong female protagonists.

    I just finished reading Phillip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy, and it made me go and reread my Harry Potter books. Pullman is a little darker, but Lyra is such a great character.

    I’m going to end up taking notes from all of your suggestions to read over the summer.

  16. I definitely recommend A Drowned Maiden’s Hair by Laura Amy Schlitz for kids aged 10 and up. It came out fairly recently, and it’s beautifully written with a fantastic female protagonist — a “bad girl”, but one who is not a tomboy — in fact, she’s delightfully prissy. It also features one of the best villains ever.

    Also, William’s Doll by Charlotte Zolotow is a great, classic picture book about a boy who wants a doll. There’s nothing about sexuality in there — he just wants a doll.

    And Totally Joe by James Howe is a great, non-didactic middle-grade read about a kid who is exuberantly gay. I recommend this essay by the author if you want to get a sense of the book. http://www.advocate.com/print_article_ektid20872.asp

  17. Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day.

    Definitely not The Velveteen Rabbit. I still cry when I read that story.

  18. I love love love Where the Wild Things Are and Goodnight Moon.

    But newer books have a lot of gender and race awareness, which is awesome. I highly recommend Do Princesses Wear Hiking Boots? (when they go hiking, of course) and Ballerino Nate.

  19. Another vote for A Wrinkle in Time. The main character is a wonderful, smart, somewhat insecure and gawky fourteen year old girl with whom I strongly identified when I was 10-12. Ok. Honestly? I still do.

    And there is a fabulous book, hard to find, out of print I suspect, by Ruth A. Arthur called Requiem for a Princess. I won’t say anything about it because it’s too wonderful a little secret…if you can find the book, I leave you to discover it yourself.

    Those were my two favorites. The other book I loved is called Silver Pennies, and it’s a collection of poetry, mostly aimed at the younger set. Lovely stuff.

  20. Alright… are you ready? I have a list:

    Charlotte’s Web
    The True Story of Three Little Pigs
    From the Mixed Up Files…
    If You Give A Mouse a Cookie
    Define Normal
    Walk Two Moons
    The Giving Tree (omg it still makes me cry)
    Where the Wild Things Are
    Flowers for Algernon
    To Kill a Mockingbird (also moves me)
    Bridge to Terabithia
    the Wrinkle in Time series.
    Keeping You a Secret
    The Secret Garden
    Where the Red Fern Grows (I remember reading this as a child. It never left me)
    The entire Harry Potter series.

    I’m sure I could find more if I thought about it. These were just off the top of my head. I loved series books when I was a kid, R.L. Stein, The Boxcar Children, Baby-Sitters Club. Loved them all! But I loved to read as a child. Like, a lot.

  21. Ack! I blew both the italics in that post, and the name of the author of Requiem for a Princess – It’s Ruth M. Arthur…and Amazon has several old copies available. It’s a real treat.

  22. Apart from Tamora Pierce, I’m particularly fond of a Swedish children’s book called Ronja Rövardotter (Ronia the Robber’s Daughter in English, apparently) by Astrid Lindgren, the same woman who wrote Pippi Longstocking and The Brothers Lionheart, another favourite of mine.

    Just to add some Scandivian flavour to the recs. 😉

  23. I’m shocked that no one yet has mentioned The Little Prince by Antoine De Saint-Exupery. I missed it when I was a kid, but a girlfriend of mine talked me into reading it two or three years ago, and parts of it were so touching that I ended up bawling like a baby.

    Of course, I’m going to agree with A Wrinkle In Time, as I read that about four billion times throughout elementary school. And for a while in 5th grade To Kill a Mockingbird was my favorite, but analyzing it to death in high school just about destroyed that.

  24. Oooo…Flowers for Algernon is one of the most moving books I’ve ever read. Very poignant.

    Did anyone here ever read any of the Miss Pickerell series? I liked a few of those.

  25. Last year I read “Zen Shorts” by John Muth and it blew my fucking mind. It is possibly the most perfect children’s book I’ve ever seen. Wonderful art, great lessons, realistic characters with a touch of fantasy.

    I also think that every straight ally should give their kid a copy of “And Tango Makes Three”. You can’t underestimate the importance of actually showing gay parenting to kids, especially those in urban areas that will later encounter gay kids and gay parents.

    “Kitten’s First Full Moon” by Kevin Henkes is great for infants because of the stark black and white drawings. Children under 2 don’t have very developed eyes and too many bright colors can actually confuse them but numerous studies have shown that the more children are read to, the better they do in school, so you can start the day after they are born with this book. This story also fulfills the psychological need for preschoolers to go away into the scary world and come back to a safe warm home.

    For older kids (13+) I adore Susan Campbell Bartoletti’s “Hitler Youth: Growing Up in Hitler’s Shadow”. It is a very complex book about WWII, Nazis, and the Holocaust, but because it focuses on the children whose lives were changed by Hitler, I think it is a valuable teaching tool.

    For the 11-15 age group, I really like a graphic novel called “Lone and Level Sands”. It is a retelling of the Moses out of Egypt story, using the Bible, the Quaran, and the Talmud as sources to give a more balanced and well rounded view of what actually happened between Moses and Ramses.

    For YA’s, I love “Kissing the Witch” by Emma Donaghue. It is various retellings of famous European fairy tales, focusing on the relationships between the women in the stories – and it includes some lesbian content. I am really convinced that children need fairy tales, and as an adult I love my worn copy of “Don’t bet on the Prince” by Jack Zipes, a collection of tales where the girl doesn’t always need a prince, doesn’t get judged based only on beauty, and the Prince doesn’t always need to be rugged, violent, and manly. While some of these stories might be difficult for young children to read, as a feminist, I plan to read these stories to my kids as soon as they are able to listen.

  26. So I’m not the only one who fancies China Mieville, then. I met him once… phwoarr.

    In a strictly comradely way, obviously.

  27. “Watership Down” remains my favorite book. EVER. “The primroses were over…” I read it every few years.

    I read “Flowers for Algernon” in 4th grade and it utterly broke my heart (learned to read by age 4; my eldest was reading “Harry Potter” by age 6). So many wonderful books in this thread!

    Same daughter started a book club in her 6th grade based on the “Warriors” series; she has every book memorized. Kinda like “Watership Down” with cats.

  28. There’s a far-future dystopian fantasy book by Sherryl Jordan called Winter of Fire that I picked up at a book fair as a kid and haven’t stopped rereading since. It’s one of those books that I can start reading again at the beginning as soon as I finish it, and that gives me chills even now thinking about it; oddly enough, I was searching online for a copy (my childhood one got lost and the book seems to be out of print now) and I found several other people saying the same thing about it. It’s both an amazing coming-of-age story and an incredible indictment of slavery. If you or anyone you love can get your hands on this book, read it.

    Otherwise, I agree with most other people’s lists, but would like to add Louis Sachar’s Wayside School books and anything else he’s written – I still get uneasy on the 19th floor of anywhere.

  29. As much as everyone hates the company and dismisses them as capitalists (which I won’t deny) the American Girl line is what really got me interested in history when I was younger. Not just a passive interest – but an, “Oh-my-God-Mom-can-we-PLEASE-go-to-the-history-museum” interest. They had that effect on a couple of my friends growing up, too.

    I loved “Ella Enchanted” by Gail Carson Levine, even though the movie was terrible. It’s one of the better “redone fairytale” books I’ve read.

    And I still read the books by L.M. Montgomery.

  30. I heartily second recommendations for Dianna Wynne Jones. Her books are still among my favorites (and I’m past 30 now), esp Howl’s Moving Castle, Eight Days of Luke, and Archer’s Goon, in addition to the Chrestomanci books. And Harriet the Spy. There’s one I haven’t thought about in years.

    Patricia McKillip also has some good books out there, too; I don’t know if they get filed as Children’s or Young Adults, but the Riddle Master of Hed trilogy is good stuff. Also Robin McKinley – The Hero and the Crown and The Blue Sword. Oh, Lloyd Alexander’s Prydain books. And Susan Cooper’s The Dark is Rising. And Jane Yolen. Andre Norton’s written some novels for younger people, too. (I got into the fantasy/SF stuff early.)

    When I was a lot younger, I really got into John Bellairs’ creepy series of books – The House With a Clock in its Walls is the first of those. (I recently reread one of those, and it is definitely written for a younger audience. Not as enjoyable now as it was back then. grump)

  31. I fail at reading comprehension.

    I like those books I listed because a lot of them are really, really funny (Jones’ novels have a lot of humor in them). And they’re (mostly) well written enough that I still enjoy them (except Bellairs, sigh). Many of them have strong female characters, and the relationship between the two main characters in McKillip’s Riddlemaster books is really just lovely – not at all the traditional sort of “we must be married and live together and foresake our individual destinies.” Come to think of it, most of the characters in my favorite books aren’t stereotypic characters, unlike some of those in a certain popular British author’s books. They’re interseting characters, and interesting things happen to them in worlds that have some fundamental differences from the real world. But I really like make-believe worlds, whether magical or science fictional.

    Oh – another favorite: H.M Hoover. She writes SF, mostly stories set on alien worlds with really fascinating alien critters and goings-on. I am bitterly disappointed that my local library barely has any of her books!

  32. Most of my recommendations have already been made. I especially second Diana Wynne Jones.

    I thought The Giving Tree was awfully, terribly, horribly sad.

  33. Harry Cat’s Pet Puppy by George Seldon and The Ordinary Princess by M.M. Kaye were two of my faves. For the more pre-teen set I liked And Both Were Young by Madeleine L’Engle (which led me to read her adult novel A Severed Wasp).

    I also remember liking Amelia Bedelia and Ramona books and books by Tommy Depaola way back in the day. But I haven’t read any of them for a long time.

  34. The Jungle Book–both of ’em, hands down [or should that be trunks up?] And Dr. Seuss, of course.
    The White Panther, by T.J. Waldeck.
    Carbonel, King of the Cats, by Barbara Sleigh, and a sequel, the Kingdom of Carbonel.
    Don’t forget Pippi Longstocking!

  35. So You Want to Be a Wizard, Deep Wizardry, and High Wizardry by Diane Duane (there are other children’s books in that series, but not as good, and then there are two adult novels in the same universe)

    Truth be told, I never read much in the way of children’s literature – I just read whatever sci-fi/fantasy I could get my hands on.

  36. I also think reading is far better for the brain than any other type of media. Here are some books I loved as a child/young adult (I was an early reader so most of these are really young adult books):

    Anything by Cynthia Voight – Homecoming and Dicey’s Song are my favorites.

    Neverending Story by Michael Ende (also Momo by the same author) – these were read to me out loud by my mother when I was pretty young – LOVED them

    Once and Future King by TH White is still my favorite book of all time – it’s the Arthurian legend and a really thick book. I ruined my eyes reading this one by the lightbulb that shone out of the bottom of my alarm clock late at night when I was supposed to be sleeping.

    The Last Unicorn by Peter Beagle – a classic.

  37. I just bought my little niece the following books:

    The Best Bee-Keeper of Lalibela

    Of Numbers and Stars

    Sally Jean, The Bicycle Queen

    and Once Upon a Time When The Princess Rescued The Prince

    I actually read them all myself (sheesh, I know), and they were wonderful.

    Growing up though, my tastes were really varied, from horror to Indian mythology to campy teen potboilers and the like. My Indian mythology pick has to be K.M. Munshi’s Krishnavatara series, because he wrote it like a romance and made Krishna intensely human, which was refreshing, to say the least.

    Oh and I loved, loved Where The Wild Things Are and the Jenny Linsky books when I was littler.

  38. I’d like to second a lot of what’s been put up here, especially the Narnia, Rohald Dahl and Tamora Pierce love. Also to add that if kids enjoy Lewis, it’s often worth trying them on Lord of the Rings as early as possible – it seems as though all the people I know who grew up to be real Tolkien fans were the ones who read LOTR before puberty. (I read it at ten and loved it, and thus was horribly disappointed by The Hobbit when I finally came across it at around fifteen – like riding on a kiddy carousel after jumping off a rollercoaster!).

    Terry Pratchett’s children’s books are also really good, particularly for kids (and adults!) who enjoy/ed Dahl and/or Pierce. The Wee Free Men and its two sequels have a really solid central character – Tiffany, a highly intelligent, not-especially-pretty, fiercely practical farmgirl who’s learning to be a witch. She’s occasionally-helped-and-mostly-hindered by a tribe of psychotic six-inch-tall blue pictsies who’ve made her their temporary Queen, and learns most of the important stuff from several older women, including other witches and her memories of her grandmother. (There’s also a fabulous dig at Rowling in the first book when Tiffany fantasises about going off to have all sorts of fun and frolics at a magical school for witches – which doesn’t turn out quite the way she expects…).

    His adult stuff, sadly, often turns out to be less good from a feminist perspective, although there’s still enough fun and sly references to everything from pop culture to technology that I’m willing to suspend judgement, at least for the time it takes to read one.

  39. for picture books: can’t go past Mem Fox’s Possum Magic

    for the older set, Elyne Mitchell’s Silver Brumby series was a favourite of mine, as were the Phillip Pullman books

  40. The Westing Game.
    Cold Sassy Tree.
    The Egypt Game.
    The Lloyd Alexander books, and the Susan Cooper Dark is Rising books.

    Gordon Korman for humour — my favourite was No Coins, Please, but lots of the others are great.

    I was a big fan of Jacob have I loved, but it’s quite dated.

    Pretty much everything by Dahl, and teens and above should go ahead and read all his (creepy) adult books.

  41. Goodnight Mr. Tom and A little love song by Michelle Magorian were both hits with me at 14

    I also have to rec the Trilogy: Daughter/Servant/Mistress of the Empire by Raymond E. Feist and Janny Wurts :hearts:

  42. We’re still in picturebook territory, mostly, at our house — though we’re working our way through the Narnia books, kind of fitfully. A few random recommendations, as they pop into my head:

    Two Little Trains by Margaret Wise Brown (of Goodnight Moon fame) is a gorgeous, wistful text, and it’s recently been reissued with beautiful new illustrations. Makes me itch to take a road trip every time I read it.

    Mo Willems’ Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus is funny and snarky and great to read aloud. I may like it more than the kid does, tho.

    An oldie from my youth that I’ve fallen back in love with is Hand, Hand, Fingers, Thumb, a jazzy, snappy book with great drawings of hepcat simians.

    I haven’t seen our family’s copy of Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House in months, and I’m jonesing. It’s the story of a big-city super who turns his tenement, apartment by apartment, into a farm. Again, gorgeously illustrated.

    Ezra Jack Keats’ stuff makes me swoon, and as a New York City kid raised in the seventies, his The Snowy Day is like a madeleine to me. It’s like watching Summer of Sam, except … you know, different.

    Marvin K. Mooney, Will You Please Go Now! is my favorite Seuss book. Really.

    I have no idea whether Who Needs Donuts? by Mark Alan Stamaty (of the “Washingtoon” strip) is still in print, but it’s a lush, deranged fable about love and greed and donuts.

    And you know what? Spike Lee’s Please, Baby Please is actually pretty damn good.

    (I wrote about Two Little Trains at greater length here a few months ago. It’s really a fabulous book.)

  43. Scott Westerfield is entertaining. (Peeps, Uglies, So Yesterday, etc.)

    There’s also a very good book coming out next summer from Harper Collins called _Magic Thief_ by Sarah Prineas.

  44. Oh, and how could I forget The View From Saturday? That book is simply perfect, no ifs, ands, or buts. I love it.

    Mercedes Lackey’s Arrows of the Queen trilogy was seriously a life-changing gift for me at eleven

    Oh, me toooooooo. From about 11-17 I gobbled up every Lackey book I could get my hands on, and a lot of others besides. It made me a little embarrassed later in life, but they were so important for me at the time.

  45. Holes, A Wrinkle In Time & sequels, All of A Kind Family & sequels, every Beverly Cleary book ever written, every Judy Blume book ever written, anything by Edward Eager, anything by John Bellairs, The Mystery of the Witches’ Bridge, all the Series of Unfortunate Events books, Laura Ingalls Wilder’s books (cringe-worthy scenes grudgingly forgiven because she was a product of her time and a great storyteller), To Kill a Mockingbird, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, Harriet the Spy (BANNED???), The Long Secret, Lord Loss, Nobody’s Family’s Going to Change, Small Steps, Mr. and Mrs. Bo Jo Jones (for older kids/teens), While Mrs. Coverlet Was Away, From the Mixed up Files…, Sport, Jane-Emily, Murder, My Dear!, Haldane Station, Miss Happiness and Miss Flower, Little Plum,The Silver Spoon Mystery(great kid-age feminist issues in that one!), Mystery by Moonlight, The Ghostly Trio, Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus, Piggies in a Polka, The Dancing Skeleton, Skeleton Hiccups, any Skippyjon Jones book, and of course most of the Seusses.

    Well, you asked.

    Also, I HATED The Giving Tree because it was so symbolic of the idea of the sacrificial mother who gives and gives and gives and gives until she dies, and then STILL has to GIVE SOME MORE (yeah, I may be projecting).

  46. Well . . . my favorite book that I read as a child was The Clan of the Cave Bear by Jean M. Auel, and its sequels. Most people would disagree that that’s a children’s book, either due to content or length. However, if one believes there’s nothing wrong or shameful about sex and is not phobic about their child learning that it exists and can be fun, the former problem vanishes; the success of Harry Potter casts enough doubt on the latter to make it worth a shot, and I have never in my life read anything with such wonderful characterization, or so rich in description and (pre)historical accuracy.

    It is a truly wonderful study in human nature; it features a strong female character overcoming the limitations placed on her by a patriarchal society and the harassment and abuse rained down on her by another character. The antagonists are human and believable and made understandable—the things I learned about how bullies function, written realistically from their point of view, were both interesting to read and helpful in dealing with my own—and the protagonists realistic, with flaws and internal conflicts and everything, and every character fitting so perfectly in the niche made for them by their culture, their experiences, and the part they were to play in the story, this is astonishingly helpful for anyone who wants to learn to write about people, as well.

    I don’t know what age was meant by “books for children,” but I pulled this off my mother’s bookshelf and read it when I was in fifth grade. I am immensely glad I did, so my recommendation for this question has got to be this.

  47. I’m happy to see a few people pushing His Dark Materials. I love love love love love that trilogy to pieces, and have read my copies so many times they’re probably going to fall apart. The movie looks like it’s going to kind of suck, though…

  48. I would like to champion L.M. Montgomery (I want to write my thesis on her) and her classic and fiesty heroines!

    Also:
    Swallows and Amazons (and the rest of the series) by Arthur Ransome (about a bunch of kids who go sailling and get in to adventures on Coneston Waters. Two families, one: Susan, Titty [yes, Titty], Roger and John are the Swallows and their neighbours: Nancy and Peggy who are the Amazons and pirates!).

    anything by Gordon Kormon especially the Macdonald Hall [as in Sir John A] series (I can only vouch for his earlier stuff, baut apparently his newer stuff including the series “The Island” is really good)

    Nancy Drew!!! and Encyclopedia Brown (I would’ve gotten away with it if it weren’t for those meddling kids!)

    The Hobbit (pure gold) and anything by Roald Dahl, he got my through my nerdy nerdy childhood.

    The Bones series (I suppose these don’t fit the ‘real’ book category as they’re graphic novels/comic books but they’re amazing).

    For the older kids try Marion Zimmer Bradley (I prefer her to Mercedes Lackey).

    And a childhood staple, intelligent, imaginative and heart-warming: Calvin and Hobbes by Bill Watterson

  49. A Wrinkle In Time, as has been pointed out, is utterly fantastic. Another that I can’t recommend highly enough is Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry.

  50. Ronia The Robber’s Daughter by Astrid Lindgren, author of Pippi Longstocking!! It has a strong-girl protagonist, a nice boy, beautiful northern nature, conflict resolution, natural and supernatural creatures, wild horses, robber bands…what more could anyone want? If I were ever in the horrible situation of only being able to have one book in life, as long as I lived, it would be that one, even though it’s short.

    Emily of New Moon, The Blue Castle (though it’s not strictly children), and Jane of Lantern Hill by L.M. Montgomery are also wonderful.

  51. I love reading and so do my kids so this is a favorite subject!

    For younger readers: If You Give a Mouse a Cookie, Jamberry, Snuggle Piggy and the Magic Blanket, and Nora’s Stars.

    As read alouds: books by E. Nesbit and Edward Eager, Narnia, Phantom Tollbooth, Michael Ende’s Momo, A Wrinkle in Time, Wind in the Willows, Steel Magic by Andre Norton, the Paddington books, and the Redwall books.

    For older readers: Dragonsong and its sequels by Anne McCaffrey, Beauty by Robin McKinley, anything by Patricia McKillip, the Dealing with Dragons books by Patricia Wrede, Whalesong, and the Secret Country by Pamela Dean.

    And the Moomintroll books which inspired my blog name (I recently wrote a post on books with strong female characters, The Mystery of the Missing Readers).

  52. Those books I seemed to re-read the most were the ones that focused on the magic of the imagination…books like Michael Ende’s The Neverending Story, or The Phantom Tollbooth, or (especially) Bridge to Terabithia. I have to admit that I didn’t pay particularly close attention to gender in my younger years, though I did consider what’s-her-name from Bridge to Terabithia to be the awesomest female character I’d ever encountered because of her superior athletic abilities, her courage, and her…je ne sais quois…

  53. I HATED The Giving Tree because it was so symbolic of the idea of the sacrificial mother who gives and gives and gives and gives until she dies, and then STILL has to GIVE SOME MORE (yeah, I may be projecting).

    We had a great conversation about The Giving Tree over at my blog last fall, in the course of which I stumbled across an amazing quote. In an ethics roundtable on the book, one ethicist wrote that the tree is “a terrible mother — a masochist who, quite predictably, has raised a sociopath.”

    That line gives me chills.

  54. I don’t know if L.M. Montgomery is good for kids. I loved the books as a kid, definitely, but they also imprinted on me some really screwed up ideas about relationships. I don’t know why I believed that they held The Truth of how romance works, but for some reason, for the longest time, I was convinced that love was some magical thing that happened to you with One Man And One Man Only and if you did anything to screw that up, well, you were just SOL. It made it a lot harder for me to move on from crushes and relationships than it really should have been.

  55. For a fun, silly read, Bunnicula. Its about a vampire rabbit who sucks the life out of vegatables. Its a smart alternative to ‘Captain Underpants’ and introduces puns and such.

  56. Someone mentioned Dicey’s Song, so I have to mention Solitary Blue. I love how Jeff appears so cool and together in Dicey’s Song, and then you get to see how it all appeared from his perspective in Solitary Blue.

    I was thinking more about Bridge to Teribithia this evening.That book made me sob like a baby when I was ten; I reread it when I was 25, and figured, “OK, I’m older now, things well be different,” but the effect was pretty much the same. When I read it as an adult, I just loved it when the young atheist learns about Christ and the crucifixion for the first time, and exclaims “Oh, what a beautiful story! It’s just like the story of Aslan!” Some of these jokes are put info for the adults, I think, because that went totally over my head when I was a kid.

    Oh, and The Watson’s go to Birmingham is brilliant; a wonderful mixture of hilarious and sad. Out of the Dust is so poignant, as is Dear Mr. Henshaw.

    I loved the Wrinkle in Time trilogy as a kid, and still do. But when I went back and read the third one, A Swiftly Tilting Planet, I was sort of “Wait a minute. What’s this shit about the the good, blue-eyed Indians?”

    Which brings me to a question. Can we also nominate the worst, or most problematic book? If so, I nominate “Amos Fortune, Free Man,” a 1950’s Newbery Medal winner about a black slave in the U.S. who realizes that he just needs to work hard, and not complain about unfairness. He’s offered his freedom by his masters, but he says “No ma’am! I want to earn my freedom. I don’t want anything handed to me.” A good runner-up is The Matchlock Gun, a 1940’s Newbery Medal winner that tells the heart-warming story of a boy who kills three Indians.

  57. Wow–this thread reminded me of so many things. I haven’t thought about Lloyd Alexander in years!

    My favorite kid’s book, which I stil love as an adult, is Knight’s Castle by Edward Eager. I love it because it’s a fun page-turner, and mostly because the characters all learn and grow. The protagonist learns to not be dismissive of his little sister because she is younger and “just a girl,” she learns to stand up for herself, and so on.
    It’s also a very amusing parody of Ivanhoe–unfortunately, I had quite a strong prejudice against poor Rowena when I later read that book.
    Eager absolutely idolized E. Nesbit, who’s a pretty cool kids author in her own right, and I recently learned was a feminist and a founder of the Fabian Society.

  58. There are tonnes of progressive books to start kids off young, these are just some of the few that I’ve gotten my nieces and nephews:

    Skin Again [Hardcover] by Hooks, Bell; Raschka, Chris

    Keep Climbing, Girls [Hardcover] by Richards, Beah E.; Christie, R. Gregory…

    The Skin You Live in [Hardcover] by Tyler, Michael

    The Sissy Duckling [Paperback] by Fierstein, Harvey; Cole, Henry

    Girls Will Be Boys Will Be Girls [Paperback] by Bunnell, J.T.

    Everything to do with genderbending and racism from the getgo…. why not?

  59. Susan Cooper’s The Dark is Rising series and Lloyd Alexander’s Chronicles of Prydain series. Both oldies but goodies, and the Prydain books are extremely funny in places.

  60. Many good recs that I have to second (I brought my copy of “Where the Sidewalk Ends” to college and grad school, it’s a security blanket, and the same with my Complete Works of Lewis Carroll, and of course Madeleine L’Engle, especially “A Ring of Endless Light,” and Patricia C. Wrede’s Enchanted Forest Chronicles, and and and….).

    Also: Number the Stars and The Giver, both by Lois Lowry. The first one is exciting, touching and emotional, and the second breaks me into a million tiny pieces every time. Ooh, and anything by Nancy Hope Wilson (I’m biased, as I’ve known her since I was a kid, but her work really is great).

    I will probably have a million more recommendations this weekend when I go home and have access to all my books.

  61. The President’s Daughter and the two sequels by Ellen Emerson White. You’ve got a female President, a mouthy heroine, and a lot of 80’s references. They’re out of print but a new sequel is coming out so they’ll be coming out again. The Saturdays.

  62. Some old favourites here. I read Bridge to Terebithia in school one day when I was sick and in the nurses office. I think the crying made me worse. I love His Dark Materials, the Diana Wynne-Jones books and the Bartimaeus trilogy (has anyone read the Percy Jackson books by Rick Riordan? Not as good as the others I mention, but really funny anyway), and the Earthsea books (I’m a fantasy person). And I recently read Jane Yolen’s Briar Rose and thought it was brilliant. Also only read Where The Wild Things Are as an adult, but loved it anyway.

    The Horrible Histories series is one of my favourites – and taught me far more effectively than history classes in school.

    Scarlett – I agree that Pratchett’s Tiffany Aching books are great from a feminist perspective, but I think quite a few of the adult ones deal with gender wonderfully as well. Equal Rites has its moments, Monstrous Regiment is great, and I think Granny Weatherwax, Angua, Sybil and Susan are all wonderful characters.

    Palau – You’ve met him? I don’t think I ever will, since he’s unlikely to do a book tour in India. (sigh). In a way, this is probably a good thing, or I’d embarrass myself.

    Dr Confused, Jayo – I think it’s completely possible to, for example, watch a movie in an active, involved way that can be quite as beneficial as reading a book. If people aren’t watching movies that way, maybe we need to make more good ones. (I’m still going to aspend most of my time reading books though.:))

  63. I LOVE Watership Down and the Redwall series for talking-animal fantasy stuff, and although I was never much of a hardcore fantasy person, The Hobbit is very good (much better-written than the other Tolkein books). Be careful not to rule out the Harry Potter series just because of the “everybody’s doing it” syndrome – they’re good books! I’m actually a bit of a childrens’ literature buff, so check out the Newbury and Caldecott winners every year to see what you find. “Bridge to Terabithia” has got to be one of my all-time favorites in that category. And there are a few fun and beautiful books that I still remember when I was a kid, aimed at younger children: “One Morning in Maine” and “Bread and Jam For Francis” (great if you have a little picky eater who needs a new book), and “Grandfather Twilight” for some of the most exquisite illustrations I’ve ever seen.

    As for more contemporary books, my niece was into her Disney princess phase recently so I got her a copy of “Do Princesses Wear Hiking Boots?” to try and offset the damage. “And Tango Makes Three” has very sweet illustrations and good inclusive subject matter that I think all small children should get a taste of in childrens’ books. And I just read a really cool new book called “The Green Glass Sea”, which is a fictitious account of two ten-year-old girls, daughters of scientists, who grew up in Los Alomos during WWII while their parents worked on the Manhattan Project – it’s fantastic.

    These cover a pretty wide age range but they’re all excellent regardless.

  64. Here are my favorites, the descriptions don’t do them justice but you’ll get a feel I hope. Some old, some new.

    Picture Books:
    *Where the Sidewalk Ends by Shel Silverstein (a collection of funny poems with neat illustrations)
    *Lon Po Po: A Red-Riding Hood Story from China by Ed Young (a young girl saves her sisters from an evil wolf … kinda violent-prescreen and make sure you’re comfortable with it)
    *Rosa by Nikki Giovanni (a picture book about Rosa parks)
    *The Fairy-Tale Detectives by Michael Buckley (the Sisters Grimm meet giants, pixies, fairies, and witches in thier adventures)

    Easier Chapter Books:
    *Because of Winn-Dixie by Kate Dicamillo (a young girl finds a dog who enables her to meet a few folks: a librarian who fought off a bear with a copy of War and Peace, an ex-con pet-store clerk who plays sweet music to his animal charges, and the neighborhood “witch,” a nearly blind woman who sees with her heart)
    *Summer of the Monkeys by Wilson Rawls (a boy spends a summer trying to catch monkeys that have escaped from the circus)
    *The Giver by Lois Lowry (a coming of age story where a young boy comes to understand the price one pays for order, complacency, and a pain-free utopia)
    *Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred D. Taylor ( a young girl’s family experiences racism, violence, and poverty in the 1930’s Deep South)
    *Bridge to Terabithia by Katherine Paterson (a story about friendship, loss, and the imagination)

    Harder Chapter Books:
    *To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee (Not sure if this qualifies as YA lit, but I think it’s pretty readable. In my opinion, this is probably the greatest book written in the last hundred years.)
    *Wrinkle In Time Series by Madeleine L’Engle (okay, I think I’m the fifteenth person to say this. It’s a fascinating fantasmical read.)
    *Shabanu: Daughter of the Wind by Suzanne Fisher Staples (the coming of age story of a young Pakistani girl who defies the expectations set out for her)

  65. And wow – I just read the rest of the comments and it was a giant nostalgia whack. I second:
    William’s Doll, Harriet the Spy, Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH, Beverly Cleary, Judy Blume, Roald Dahl, Miss Rumphius, Louis Sachar (Wayside Stories from Wayside School is his best, in my opinion), To Kill A Mockingbird.

    Another excellent one that I haven’t seen in a skim of the comments: The Pushcart Wars. Another fascinating book to check out for the illustrations is “The Snowman”

    And it’s difficult subject matter for children, but I read it fairly young and learned a lot: I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings.

    Okay, I’ll go away now. Children’s literature is fantastic (definitely better than adult literature in many respects), and I get easily carried away! Back to my paper…

  66. well as said Tamora Pierce’s Tortall books are great I also loved Galax-Arena by Gillian Rubinstein and Cats of Serosta by Robert Westall were also big in my childhood

  67. Marcyfight & Louise: Doesn’t it bother you how sexist Watership Down is? Female rabbits are basically treated as breeding stock to be looted from neighbouring warrens. Our heros escape their doomed home, set up a new bunny utopia, and then go “we forgot to bring any does” (I believe it actually says that; like “oops, we forgot the crackers”).

    Ditto for The Little Prince. This book infuriates me because everyone seems to go gaga over it, but it’s one of those books where all characters are male until the central character needs a female ‘other’, and what we get is the heartless rose. Talk about stereotypes.

    Shankar: re. Rats of NIMH, I bet you had a crush on Justin.

    A wonderful series for teenagers, which is recent, and so the word might not have got out yet, is the Dark Ground Trilogy by Gillian Cross (The Dark Ground, The Black Room and The Nightmare Game). It’s SO clever, because it reads just like an adventure thriller, but then you realise it’s all about perspective and empathy and all sorts of metaphysical things.

  68. Aside from Harry Potter, and a couple of Terry Pratchett’s children’s books, I can’t say I’ve kept up with children’s literature.

    I’ll second Holly’s suggestion of the Oz series. It’s light and fluffy, but modestly good fantasy – written in an era before horrors like Terry Goodkind existed)

    I’ll add to that:

    – Anything by Dr. Seuss (just too much whimsical fun)
    – A Christmas Carol by Dickens (I have such fond memories of my father reading us that story over the weeks leading up to Christmas)
    – Wind in the Willows {author?}

    and:

    – Asterix and Obelix comics (early graphic novels really) – Insanely fun, but for adults they also actually did a pretty decent job of portraying the Roman Empire – events and locales especially. They came back into print a couple of years ago.

    (* I discovered them in the library when I was all of 5, and comics were still somewhat verboten in my home – Mom even liked them! *)

  69. I HATED The Giving Tree because it was so symbolic of the idea of the sacrificial mother who gives and gives and gives and gives until she dies, and then STILL has to GIVE SOME MORE (yeah, I may be projecting).

    Me three, or four. And that was back when I vowed never to even be a mommy.

    Love Robin McKinley, especially Beauty. It’s not in your face feminism, but I loved that: Beauty was a strong character; that she and her sisters were friends; and that the Beast wasn’t a jerk. Obviously the author loves the theme as much as I do, because she wrote another version, Rose Daughter, but with a different ending, also quite good.

    I also loved her Damar series, and would even recommend Deerskin, another great favorite, for older teens, despite the rape and incest. For the Westerfield crowd, her take on the vampire story, Sunshine, has a strong female protagonist and a sort of real-life-you’re hanging resolution to the love triangle.

    Otoh, I have a harder time seconding the McCaffrey, particularly the first dragon trilogy, because though Lessa is a strong character, the stories are kind of icky when you start thinking about the forced rape and male entitlement that runs through them. The dragonsinger trilogy, particularly the first two books featuring Menolly, are better. But really, that slot (put-upon misunderstood teen) is better filled by Mercedes Lackey—like some previous posters, I couldn’t read that stuff now, but loved it when I was younger, and it’s far more feminist and LGBT friendly.

    For older teens/Tamora Pierce fans, Lois McMaster Bujold’s Young Miles is something to try. Though obstensibly military sf, the 17 yo protagonist is a lot of fun, and there are strong feminist themes throughout her work. Her fantasy The Curse of Chalion features an older protagonist, but there are strong secondary female characters in that for the fantasy crowd.

    And for younger readers, oh yes on The Snowy Day. What a brilliant, beautiful book, and the only picture book I recall from then with black protagonists.
    That and Millions of Cats are practically the only ones I remember having read to me.

  70. The President’s Daughter and the two sequels by Ellen Emerson White. You’ve got a female President, a mouthy heroine, and a lot of 80’s references. They’re out of print but a new sequel is coming out so they’ll be coming out again.

    !!! There were sequels? Oh, I LOVED the first one when I was a teenager!

    And Redwall! How did I forget Redwall? It was my first internets fandom (followed by the write-by-numbers DragonLance books). My absolute favorite to this day is Mariel of Redwall, because she kicks ass.

    For picture books – Miss Nelson is Missing, The Stupids, Santa Cows at Christmastime, the breathtaking artistry of Graeme Base in books like Animalia and The Eleventh Hour, anything by Chris Van Allsburg (the movies of “Jumanji” and “The Polar Express” may blow, but the books are fantastic, along with the others he’s written). Owl Moon.

    I am spamming this thread, I’m sorry. I was one of those kids who would go over to friends’ houses for playdates and then spend the entire time reading their books.

  71. Something no one has mentioned yet, Ursula K. Le Guin’s Catwings books are very nice for elementary school children. She also tends to be one of the more racially inclusive fantasy authors. Her Earthsea books made me happy because almost none of the protagonists are white, and the stories aren’t just another set of stories set in some approximation of England.

  72. I’ve read so many of the books mentioned (plus found a couple to purchase, thanks!) but haven’t seen this one: Monster Blood Tattoo. It’s fairly new, very detailed, captures the interest immediately. I can’t wait for the next in the series.

    I love YA books.

  73. Aishwarya: Yup, I met him a couple of times when he stood for councillor for the Socialist Alliance in London a few years ago and again at at an SF awards thingy. I’ve met Pratchett too at cons and I second, third and fourth all the recommendations for all his books (my sons loved them, especially The Bromeliad Trilogy and Johnny and The Bomb – but, although he’s a very nice man, he’s no Mieville. He hasn’t got the sexy piercings for a start :).

  74. I third the crush on China Miéville. He’s fantastic. I fell in love with his adult writing and Un Lun Dun was marvelous.

    I can’t believe no one’s brought up Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland/Through the Looking Glass. It’s the precursor to my favourite subgenre of children’s lit: Bookish little girl (or occasionally, little boy) falls into a magical world. Most of my childhood favourites: Narnia, The Neverending Story, A Wrinkle in Time, and so on, follow that pattern—right up to Coraline, which I’d have loved if it had been around back then.

    As a kid, I loved Dahl for his morbid humour. For younger kids: Anything by Dr. Seuss, The Paperbag Princess, and the Madeleine books.

  75. We have a local author, Bruce Coville who wrote a bunch of kids books. His most well known is the “My teacher is an alien” series, but he has a whole set of magic shop books that I loved as a kid. Stuff like Jeremy Thatcher, Dragon Hatcher and Jennifer Murdley’s toad. I also really loved the Boxcar Children series. My favorite books were the Anne of Green Gables series and I still love them now. I also read the Little House on the Prarie series and I loved pretty much anything Roald Dahl wrote, but my my favorites of his were Fantastic Mr. Fox and James and the Giant Peach I was also a big fan of Where the Sidewalk ends by Shel Silverstein, but you have to have a certain kind of humor to enjoy it. I could really go on and on, I read anything I could get my hands on as a child. I really loved Encylopedia Brown, Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys too, and Christopher Pike too. Even as an adult, I still love some of his stuff, I thought The Midnight Club and The Last Vampire were fantastic. I’ll aslo second the recommendation of Bunnicula, it’s such a fun and easy read.

  76. For YA books . . . I’m surprised no one has mentioned Francesca Lia Block and the Weetzie Bat books yet (which I still read).

  77. Palai, Sabotabby – I have this theory that talking about my love for him all over the internet will mean that he sees it at some point and takes pity on me. Sigh.

  78. Scarlett- What do you think is not so good about Pratchett from a feminist perspective?

    There are things which are definately make for interesting feminist discussion, like the whole female dwarf issue, but I’m not sure there’s any thing that makes them ‘less good’ from a feminist perspective. And as Aishwarya mentioned some of his books do interesting things with gender, and there are tons of strong female characters.

    To get back on topic, for young adults I’d recommend Noughts and Crosses by Malorie Blackman- original look at racism. And also Rosa Guy.

  79. I’m just so glad people have already mentioned Lloyd Alexander’s Prydain books.
    Seriously. They pull no punches, so be aware. There’s a lot of puncturing the oh-man-royalty-is-super-and-war-against-evil-solves-everything fantasy stereotypes, and one of the ways that happens is that, by the end of the last book, a lot of beloved characters die. A lot of illusions get pretty brutally shattered. And while I grew up on these books, reading them continuously from around first grade (I know, I know. They’re aimed at “young adults” or whatever) through my teens, I’ve had friend tell me they thought they were a bit overwrought.

    That said? One of the hallmarks of these oldies-but-goodies is an author who sat down with the statement that girls would read a story about boys, but boys wouldn’t read a story with female characters as readily, and promptly decided it was ridiculous. So while the female lead is a romantic interest for the primary male lead, and technically a princess, more importantly she’s complex, smart, competent, headstrong, brave, and often more on top of things than everyone else, if only they’d listen to her. And every time some moron tries to protect her ust because she’s a girl, she tends to hand out whuppings shoulder-to-shoulder with her friends. The one time she behaves like a typical fantasy princess, it’s because she’s not herself and it’s the clue that something is terribly wrong.

    Anyway, though. They’re good stuff. When Mr. Alexander died last month, I found myself, unexpectedly, in tears.

  80. Perhaps that was why Hazel and Hyzenthlay were my favorite characters- she organized the female rabbits and he needed her as a partner to get them all out safely. He valued her intelligence highly and saw her as an equal, versus General Woundwart et al saw her and the other females simply as breeding stock.

  81. Thinking over it, no, the Prydain books aren’t a femiist wonderland. There’s very, very few female characters, on balance, and a lot of them end up washing the dishes at some point. Still. Nostalgia tells me they’re worth it.

    I also second the Susan Cooper, Patricia C. Wrede, and Diana Wynne Jones recs. Ms. Jones also had a book called Dogsbody, about a celestial being trapped in the body of a British dog, that I very much enjoyed as a child.
    I honestly don’t know if I’d recommend the McCaffrey books to kids, especially if you don’t want them reading sex scenes just yet. But. I read ’em, so I can’t say much.

  82. Ditto for The Little Prince. This book infuriates me because everyone seems to go gaga over it, but it’s one of those books where all characters are male until the central character needs a female ‘other’, and what we get is the heartless rose. Talk about stereotypes.

    I actually reread The Little Prince this morning after having mentioned it yesterday, and I really disagree with what you said. Yeah, most of the characters were male, but most of the characters were also worthless idiots. Most of the book describes how miserable and pompous those men are.

    And maybe this was just my reading of it, but despite being called a “her,” I didn’t really associate a sex with the rose (even the Prince seemed fairly asexual, perhaps because of his childishness), and even if I had, ultimately the story wasn’t about a man needing a female ‘other;’ it was about finding pleasure in life by devoting yourself to something, regardless of whether it’s another person or a job or hobby or really anything.

  83. again on the Roald Dahl and C.S. Lewis love. Malorie Blackman’s Noughts and Crosses, anything by Melvin Burgess, David Eddings, Janny Wurts, Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett. Daddy Long Legs was a favourite of mine, but I can’t remember for the life of me who wrote it. Recently, I’ve enjoyed Trudi Canarvan’s Black Magician Trilogy and Stephanie Meyer’s Twighlight, neither of which I realised were in the YA section. The Worst Witch books too.

    On the really young children’s books, Spot, Where the Wild Things Are, Winne The Witch, The Very Hungry Caterpilar, The Jolly Postman, and everything by Mick Inkpen must have done something to me, because I still remember them now. Oh, and despite being decidedly childless, I recently bought Neil Gaiman’s Wolves In The Wall.

    I don’t know why, but I loathed the Dr Seuss books as a kid – and Enid Blyton made me want to scream. I still can’t put my finger on exactly what made me hate them so much.

  84. Aishwarya and Kirsten,

    First off, I do agree that Pratchett has a lot of awesome female characters in his adult books – I especially love the Witches and their interactions with each other! (Although I always wonder what happened to Esk…).

    The dwarfs do worry me – I think it’s the idea that performative femininity *necessarily* equals self-expression, and the fact that he never seems to question the notion that being ‘free’ to wear high heels and make-up is a value-neutral choice.

    Angua troubles me too. Especially in Men At Arms – it’s the idea (articulated, IIRC, by Gaspode) that Carrot is her ‘master’, and that when he calls, she has to follow. Pratchett plays around with this a bit in The Fifth Elephant (when it’s Carrot who follows Angua, and nearly gets himself killed in the process), but doesn’t really take anywhere, and as far as the latest book (Thud) she’s still seen trailing around after him in an aimless sort of way, despite the fact that she’s a highly successful cop and a great character in her own right.

    I also couldn’t stand either of the female characters in Mort – while I could see where he was trying to go with subverting the ‘beautiful lovely princess’ ideal, I think he overshoots in the other direction, creating these stereotypically ‘shrewish’ girls that the sweet, put-upon hero helplessly falls in love with because he’s such a Nice Guy(tm).

    Finally, you can also compare the social power and status held by Granny Weatherwax and Lord Vetinari – two characters of roughly similar intelligence and authority, albeit in two different societies – and get a quite realistic, but also quite depressing, picture of the rewards that get meted out to talented men and talented women…

  85. Another problem of The Little Prince is also due to the French, I think; “rose” is a feminine noun, but it doesn’t necessarily have to be translated as a female being. Likewise, the fox is a masculine noun, “le renard,” but it can be “it” in translation. I mean – yes, it’s a good point that there are no female characters, but I don’t know that the rose has to be seen as the only female and negatively portrayed. It could just as easily be a vain male in English, or a neuter flower with an ego. Is it worse to have the one female be a haughty idiot, or to have no female characters at all?

    [I’m actually translating a chapter of Le Petit Prince for my summer French course, so it’s on my mind. XD L’essentiel est invisible pour les yeuxs…]

  86. I haven’t seen anyone talk about M. T. Anderson yet. The first one I read by him was Feed and I was floored. It’s YA science fiction about a future society where the earth is dying and the internet (so to speak) is beamed directly into people’s minds via their “feed,” a device implanted in their heads at birth. His most recent book is Octavian Nothing: Traitor to the Nation. It’s set in the Revolutionary War era, narrated by a boy who begins the book not realizing that he and his mother are slaves.

  87. Yeah, Nomie, White House Autumn and long live the queen are the sequels, and the next book is coming out in October, it’s called Long May She Reign, I think, and it’s supposedly written about the same characters during the Presidential administration, but it’s basically an adult, not YA, novel (who’s a dorky fangirl? lol).

  88. OK, these will have a definite Australian/Scandinavian bent – but I can reread these over and over (and I’m 26)…

    The Muddle Headed Wombat (series of books)
    The Magic Pudding
    When Hitler Stole Pink Rabbit
    Pippi Longstocking Books
    The Moomin books

    And for young adults, my favourite series of all time – the “Tomorrow When the War Began” series.

  89. he Clan of the Cave Bear by Jean M. Auel, and its sequels. Most people would disagree that that’s a children’s book, either due to content or length. However, if one believes there’s nothing wrong or shameful about sex and is not phobic about their child learning that it exists and can be fun, the former problem vanishes;

    I’m not so sure about Clan of the Cave Bear proper, for children. Particularly because of the rape, and the rule that women had to obey when the men wanted sex. The latter books don’t have that problem, but they really need the backstory of the first to make sense. At the very least, a few equally explicit fiction books that have a more positive sexual example first.

    In Jr. High and High school, I loved my father’s Analog magazines (read them before he did). That’s where I was introduced to Bujold and the Vorkosigans, whom I still love, and recommend.

    I remember reading Lloyd Alexander in jr. high, but for some reason, I don’t remember the stories. I’ll have to look them up again.

    From elementary school, again, Beverly Cleary and the Ramona stories, as well as her other stories. (I like Cleary better than Judy Blume, although the two sometimes get confused in my mind, because I remember titles and where a book was on the shelves in my public library better than I remember authors.)

  90. Scarlett- I do understand your discomfort with the female dwarves. On the one hand, I love the idea of them rebelling and demanding the right to be female, and not be ashamed of their sex, but the fact that they do it through adopting the femine beauty practices of another species is far from perfect.

    With regards to Angua, I always connected her submissiveness in her relationship to Carrot to the fact that she’s a werewolf, and also his royal qualities that make everyone want to follow him. Part of what’s interesting about Angua is her internal conflict over the role she takes in that relationship and her more dominant personality the rest of the time. But thinking about it now, gender probably does play a part in it which I hadn’t picked up on before.

    I don’t remember Mort particularly welland to be honest I have very little recollection of the female characters in it.

    Pratchett’s treatment of gender isn’t perfect, but it’s not anti-feminist, and much of it is different enough to be an aspect of the Discworld books that I enjoy.

    (Also I’ve created a Terry Pratchett/feminism discussion post over at my blog, if you’re interested, because I realised that it’s something I could rant about for a very long time.)

  91. So many good books-
    I’m so glad people mentioned “Dealing With Dragons”, and also Ronia the Robber’s Daughter (I named my dog Ronia when I was little). I also have to say that “The Westing Game” was, and is, one of my favorite books ever. I loved that there was a smart mystery book, written just for kids.

  92. All my favorites have been mentioned, except Arrrg Spider! which is one of my favorites for the little, littles. Teaches them to look at both sides of the story.

    oh, and…

    I really liked Harriet the Spy. I especially like it now because it’s banned. It encourages kids to think and outside of the norm.

    banned? what? where ? WHY?
    that is so…lame.

  93. Pippi Longstocking was my favorite in elementary school. I even requested more books for the school library. Ramona Quimby was my second favorite.

  94. …and somehow I managed to forget The Owl Service by Alan Garner. (It’s magnificent, get it if you can). Also, Joan Aiken – I love my old copy of The Last Slice of the Rainbow.

    Kirsten, I think I’m with you on the Pratchett issue, but I’m looking forward to the discussion at your blog.

  95. Books that I loved that have not yet been mentioned:

    Noel Streafied’s “Shoes” books; my favorites were Ballet Shoes and Theatre Shoes.

    E.L. Konisberg’s Jennifer, Hecate, MacBeth, William McKinley, and Me, Elizabeth

    Anything by Ellen Conford. I inhaled Ellen Conford novels when I was in sixth grade. Most of her main characters were smart dorky-ish girls totally confused by the social scene around them, and I seem to remember a far amount of reward for intelligence and inventiveness (though the reward was usually in the form of male attention).

    The Sisters Impossible by J.D. Landis. It’s another ballet book (I loved ballet books) but it talks (in interesting ways) about how women suffer to attain that physical ideal, and questions whether it’s worth it. Plus it’s set in NYC and the girls take public transportation everywhere and their dad’s a lawyer and their mom’s a judge (and that’s presented as if it confuses everyone outside the family that the mom has a higher-ranking job than the dad, but the dad loves it) and it just seemed so totally uber-sophisticated to me as I was growing up in the suburbs. I loved it.

    I also always loved (and still love) Agatha Christie novels. They’re not the most challenging prose, but everyone always seemed to glamorously foreign and interesting, and women were always just as likely to be smart and insightful as the men. Christie’s autobiography is also fascinating, as she talks a lot about not only her own work but also traveling around the world with her husband, who was an archaeologist. You start to realize how much she picked up in those travels for her writing; there was something neat about being able to make those connections for me, to see how “following your husband around for a job” could be personally enriching in unique ways. (I think I read it in eighth grade.)

  96. The President’s Daughter and the two sequels by Ellen Emerson White. You’ve got a female President, a mouthy heroine, and a lot of 80’s references. They’re out of print but a new sequel is coming out so they’ll be coming out again. The Saturdays.

    You just made my day. I loved these books– the covers on mine are falling off.

    Beauty by Robin McKinley

    Anything, actually, by Robin McKinley– The Hero and the Sword and The Blue Crown both were wonderful, with lots of humor and great female role model.

    Otoh, I have a harder time seconding the McCaffrey, particularly the first dragon trilogy, because though Lessa is a strong character, the stories are kind of icky when you start thinking about the forced rape and male entitlement that runs through them. The dragonsinger trilogy, particularly the first two books featuring Menolly, are better. But really, that slot (put-upon misunderstood teen) is better filled by Mercedes Lackey—like some previous posters, I couldn’t read that stuff now, but loved it when I was younger, and it’s far more feminist and LGBT friendly

    I started reading these when I was 11 or 12, and didn’t really think on the whole male entitlement/rape thing, but now it squicks me out a bit. Her Tower books are pretty good, and a little more straight-ahead scifi.

    I have to admit, I still read Lackey, but she’s definitely a bit more of a guilty pleasure for me. Her writing has gotten much better as she’s gone along, but now I only purchase the Valdemar books new and turn to the library or used bookstores for the other series. But when she came to town last summer to speak at the library, I took the night off to go and play fangirl, it was great.

    Anything by Ellen Conford.

    I still check out A Royal Pain from the library! I loved that book SO MUCH, thus explaining my deep guilty love of ‘The Princess Diaries’.

    I used to read the Baby-Sitter’s Club series and Sweet Valley Twins like they were going out of style (and they did, I think), but they were great– ok, BSC was great, and SVT set me up for trashy beach reading. Someone mentioned Beagle’s The Last Unicorn, I would also suggest The Unicorn Sonata, it came out in the 90s and the hardcover edition had beautiful illustrations.

    Someone mentioned MZB instead of Lackey, I’ve been meaning to read the Darkover novels for years, which one should I start with?

    I am loving this thread, you all are giving me a huge reading list for the summer!

  97. Ah, to try and limit the list …

    The Ship Who Sang (Anne McCaffrey, great book!)
    Jane Eyre (Charlotte Bronte)
    Little Women (Louisa May Alcott)
    Just about anything by Andre Norton 🙂
    Rumblefish
    That Was Then, This Is Now
    Red Badge of Courage (should be at least 13, I think)
    Peter Pan
    My Friend Flicka
    Lad, A Dog
    The Wizard of Oz
    Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass
    Johnny Tremaine
    The Black Stallion (Walter Farley)
    The Island Stallion (Walter Farley)
    West of the Pecos (Zane Grey)
    The Nancy Drew Books (Personal favorite: Sign of the Twisted Candle)
    The Hardy Boys Books
    The Trixie Belden Books (I don’t know if these are still in print)

    Well, that should get you started… 🙂

  98. Ipomoea: on MZB, I was never able to get many of the Darkover novels because my public library didn’t stock them, but those I read were interesting and melded magic and scifi. The Mists of Avalon is incredible and well-written. I wouldn’t recommend it for anyone younger than high school. How she elaborates some of the themes in the Arthurian legend and how she treats fate in the book aren’t great for younger children. But, who knows, a particularly mature middle schooler could get a lot out the book. I’d preview it first though.

    As an alternative for middle schoolers, I remember enjoying Mary Stewart’s Merlin trilogy while I was in middle school.

  99. I only skimmed through this but I think, in terms of kid’s books, we’re neglecting Beatrix Potter. I loved her to death when I was a child and I still cherish my boxed set of her tiny illustrated books.

  100. The Hero and the Crown
    The Blue Sword
    Deerskin
    Beauty
    Rose Daughter

    All by Robin Mckinley, all wonderful, beautiful books that are my version of comfort food.

    I also back up the many people who love Patricia Wrede, Tamora Pierce, and Madeline L’Engle.

    I love, love, love, The Once and Future King.

    Outside the Fantasy/Sci Fi genre, anything by S.E. Hinton but especially The Outsiders.

    Kyra – I also read The Clan of the Cave Bear novels at a fairly young age and really enjoyed them. They sparked an interest in herblore and medicinal plants that has lasted ever since.

    I love this post and I will have to get to the book store and pick up a few of the titles I am unfamiliar with.

  101. Many of my first loves have been mentioned, but of those that have not, I still love Gerald Durrell’s “My Family and Other Animals”, the narnia series,a whole gob of enid blyton (yeah,I know) and the Last Unicorn. Wept like a river. Peter Beagle (who’s just a wonderful guy) just won another Hugo for the coda short story, “Two Hearts”.
    Also Vonnegut’s Cat’s Cradle and Elie Wiesel’s Night, and John Irving’s “World According to Garp.”
    I also love Charles DeLint and lots of early Stephen King.

    My fave that’s survived the test of time has been ‘Mockingbird’, which I still love.

  102. I still check out A Royal Pain from the library! I loved that book SO MUCH, thus explaining my deep guilty love of ‘The Princess Diaries’.

    Ha! Me too, on both counts!

  103. Late to the party, but couldn’t help joining in. Most of my list is suitable for teens, rather than kids, and I haven’t really thought much about the feminist principles of the novels I’m recommending!

    Anything by Diana Wynne-Jones – Fire and Hemlock is a firm favourite of mine for the Tam Lynn retelling, but I recommend all of them. Howl’s Moving Castle (I *love* Sophie!), Eight Days of Luke, Charmed Life
    Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry has already been mentioned.
    Anything by Robert Westall, especially The Wind-Eye and The Devil on the Road
    Dodie Smith – I Capture The Castle. Very old now (written in 1948) but a great young female narrator and brilliant opening lines (“I write this sitting in the kitchen sink.”). I like the waspish eccentric British books.
    Stella Gibbon – Cold Comfort Farm. If you’ve ever wondered where “something nasty in the woodshed” came from…
    So Far From the Bamboo Grove – can’t remember the author, but it’s the story of a Korean mother and two daughters fleeing the Japanese invasion in WWII and I’ve always remembered it.
    Susan Cooper – The Dark is Rising series. Just wonderful, mythological books.
    The Brothers Lionheart and Pippi Longstocking – already mentioned before, but I love Astrid Lindgren.
    Johnny and the Dead, Only You Can Save Mankind, Maurice and his Amazing Educated Rodents, The Carpet People – Terry Pratchett.
    Rosemary Sutcliffe, particularly The Eagle of the Ninth, Simon, and Frontier Wolf, Song for a Dark Queen is about Boudicca and is a great depiction of a matriarchal tribal society.
    Anything by Roald Dahl.
    Dick King-Smith – The Sheep-Pig (the book that Babe is based on) and The Fox-Busters
    Laura Ingalls-Wilder
    Beverly Cleary – I loved the Ramona stories when I was growing up. First I identified with Ramona, then as my little sister got older, I found myself identifying more and more with Beezus!
    It All Began With Jane Eyre by Shelia Greenwald – a very, very funny novel in which a girl is given some modern teen fiction by her mother in an attempt to stop her believing that her life is like a Victorian novel. Unfortunately the teen books are just as havoc-inducing…
    Three wonderfully funny classic books that should be read at any early age:
    Three Men in a Boat by Jerome K. Jerome
    My Family and Other Animals – Gerald Durrell
    Any Jeeves and Wooster stories – P.G. Wodehouse

  104. Late to the party, but couldn’t help joining in. Most of my list is suitable for teens, rather than kids, and I haven’t really thought much about the feminist principles of the novels I’m recommending!

    Anything by Diana Wynne-Jones – Fire and Hemlock is a firm favourite of mine for the Tam Lynn retelling, but I recommend all of them. Howl’s Moving Castle (I *love* Sophie!), Eight Days of Luke, Charmed Life
    Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry has already been mentioned.
    Anything by Robert Westall, especially The Wind-Eye and The Devil on the Road
    Dodie Smith – I Capture The Castle. Very old now (written in 1948) but a great young female narrator and brilliant opening lines (“I write this sitting in the kitchen sink.”). I like the waspish eccentric British books.
    Stella Gibbon – Cold Comfort Farm. If you’ve ever wondered where “something nasty in the woodshed” came from…
    So Far From the Bamboo Grove – can’t remember the author, but it’s the story of a Korean mother and two daughters fleeing the Japanese invasion in WWII and I’ve always remembered it.
    Susan Cooper – The Dark is Rising series. Just wonderful, mythological books.
    The Brothers Lionheart and Pippi Longstocking – already mentioned before, but I love Astrid Lindgren.
    Johnny and the Dead, Only You Can Save Mankind, Maurice and his Amazing Educated Rodents, The Carpet People – Terry Pratchett.
    Rosemary Sutcliffe, particularly The Eagle of the Ninth, Simon, and Frontier Wolf, Song for a Dark Queen is about Boudicca and is a great depiction of a matriarchal tribal society.
    Anything by Roald Dahl.
    Dick King-Smith – The Sheep-Pig (the book that Babe is based on) and The Fox-Busters
    Laura Ingalls-Wilder
    Beverly Cleary – I loved the Ramona stories when I was growing up. First I identified with Ramona, then as my little sister got older, I found myself identifying more and more with Beezus!
    It All Began With Jane Eyre by Shelia Greenwald – a very, very funny novel in which a girl is given some modern teen fiction by her mother in an attempt to stop her believing that her life is like a Victorian novel. Unfortunately the teen books are just as havoc-inducing…
    Three wonderfully funny classic books that should be read at any early age:
    Three Men in a Boat by Jerome K. Jerome
    My Family and Other Animals – Gerald Durrell
    Any Jeeves and Wooster stories – P.G. Wodehouse

  105. Apologies for the triple post – Firefox was playing up on me! Since they’re in moderation at the moment, any chance you could just put one of them through? Thanks!

  106. It occurred to me as I sat in class yesterday evening that no one had mentioned Paula Danziger, as far as I can tell. For shame!!! The Cat Ate My Gymsuit (about an overweight girl who hated gym), This Place Has No Atmosphere (popular girl has to go live on the moon with her family, learns limits of popularity and develops other skills), and It’s an Aardvark Eat Turtle World (cross-cultural blended family from divorce, if I’m remembering correctly) were my favorites.

  107. My son and I really loved His Dark Materials and Un Lun Dun. I appreciate them for their morality, their sense of the literary, and their narrative intricacy. And so, I think, does the 6-year-old, in his way.

    He didn’t go for the Wizard of Earthsea, though, to my dismay — perhaps for the same reason as with Treasure Island, the rhetorical style too far from what he’s used to.

    L’Engle, Wynne Jones, Pratchett, and Terabithia may be the next directions to explore.I would really like to know meaty things he can read himself — Nate the Great reading level.

  108. Haven’t made it all the way through the replies yet, but I wanted to toss out that while the Pullman series His Dark Materials is great, his Sally Lockheart books (there are 4 of them) are also totally fantastic, with a strong, unconventional female lead. I LOVE those books and can’t wait until my kid is old enough to read them. Pullman also has a couple other books for kids, Springheel Jack and I Was a Rat!.

    Picture books we like around ehre are:

    King and King, a sweet, queer book,

    Araboolies of Liberty Street, a book supporting nonconformity,

    Playing War, a book about a group of kids playing war who find out one of their pals was in a real war,

    the Wild Washerwomen, about a bunch of washerwomen running amok,

    Freedom Summer, about a friendship between a white kid and a black kid at the time of federally enforced desegregation in the south

    Skin Again, by bell hooks

    and

    Click clack moo, about cows on strike

    My kid also loves the olivia books, which i read to ehr but do not particularly like.

    we also recently read aloud Charlottes Web, Trumpet of the Swan, and Stuart Little, all of which were big hits. We tend to switch up the genders in the books to remedy the fact that they’re all centered on male characters.

    current chapter book is through the looking glass.

  109. I’m surprised no one has yet mentioned Joan Aiken and her books, particularly the Mortimer and Arabel series and the Wolves of Willowby Chase series. (I was reading one of the Mortimer books in the library and laughing so hard tears were running down my cheeks. If you like Dahl, you’ll love these books.) The Wolves of Willowby Chase are set in a slightly dotty alternate history where James III came to the throne. All of Aiken’s books are very good–especially her fairy tales.

    I remember devouring Andre Norton when I was young–also Agatha Christie (which I still use for learning foreign languages.) Nancy Drew, Chitty-Chitty Bang Bang–the original by Ian Fleming (much better than the movie.)

    Also not good from a feminist point of view, but The Mad Scientists Club and its sequels I have always enjoyed, partly because of the wacky projects, partly because the author is very good at describing young boys and how they interact with each other.

    Oh, I have to mention James Schmidt–he is fantastic at breaking stereotypes. I especially like The Demon Breed, with Nile and the otters: “Kill the waddlefeet?” And who won’t like the Witches of Karres….

Comments are currently closed.