In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

So Much For Rick Warren Being a Warm-and-Fuzzy Evangelical

Mr. Purpose-Driven Life is involved with the production of a videogame based on Tim LaHaye’s Left Behind books that rewards players for killing those who resist becoming Christians. From Talk2Action’s piece, The Purpose Driven Life Takers (also up as a DKos diary):

Imagine: you are a foot soldier in a paramilitary group whose purpose is to remake America as a Christian theocracy, and establish its worldly vision of the dominion of Christ over all aspects of life. You are issued high-tech military weaponry, and instructed to engage the infidel on the streets of New York City. You are on a mission – both a religious mission and a military mission — to convert or kill Catholics, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, gays, and anyone who advocates the separation of church and state – especially moderate, mainstream Christians. Your mission is “to conduct physical and spiritual warfare”; all who resist must be taken out with extreme prejudice. You have never felt so powerful, so driven by a purpose: you are 13 years old. You are playing a real-time strategy video game whose creators are linked to the empire of mega-church pastor Rick Warren, best selling author of The Purpose Driven Life.

(Emphasis mine.)

Note to conservative Catholics who’ve been cozying up to the Christian Right and the Dominionists on issues of abortion and gay marriage: this is what they think of you. Come the theocratic revolution, you’re going to have to convert or die.

Note also that simply changing “Christian” to “Muslim” in the above-quoted paragraph would have pundits and lawmakers and a hell of a lot of other people up in arms. Theocracy is scary and only something to get upset about when it’s Muslims who are doing it, right? Christian Dominionists are good Americans, and the only interesting thing to Newsweek about the game is its chance for success because of its high production values, violent content, and megachurch distribution network:

The game revolves around New Yorkers who are “left behind” after the rapture. Players scour the streets for converts, training them into a work force to feed, shelter and join a paramilitary resistance against the growing forces of the Antichrist.

Left Behind Games CEO Troy Lyndon, whose company went public in February, says the game’s Christian themes will grab the audience that didn’t mind gore in “The Passion of the Christ.” “We’ve thought through how the Christian right and the liberal left will slam us,” says Lyndon. “But megachurches are very likely to embrace this game.” Though it will be marketed directly to congregations, Forces will also have a secular ad campaign in gaming magazines.

Nowhere does this Newsweek piece mention that the “growing forces of the Antichrist” are those New Yorkers who didn’t convert, and that the goal is to forcibly convert them or kill them. The Newsweek writeup sounds so benign, as if the players are just being community-minded in the face of an alien invasion instead of killing their fellow Americans for not being the right kind of Christian.

Where is the outrage? I can guarantee the tone of Newsweek’s piece would be far different if this were an Al Qaeda-funded videogame being distributed in the Arab world and advocating the murder of Christians as infidels. Just imagine the outrage at a game just like this one, but with a Muslim rather than Christian focus:

This game immerses children in present-day New York City — 500 square blocks, stretching from Wall Street to Chinatown, Greenwich Village, the United Nations headquarters, and Harlem. The game rewards children for how effectively they role play the killing of those who resist becoming a born again Christian. The game also offers players the opportunity to switch sides and fight for the army of the AntiChrist, releasing cloven-hoofed demons who feast on conservative Christians and their panicked proselytes (who taste a lot like Christian).

Is this paramilitary mission simulator for children anything other than prejudice and bigotry using religion as an organizing tool to get people in a violent frame of mind? The dialogue includes people saying, “Praise the Lord,” as they blow infidels away.

This would not pass the media’s smell test if the dialogue included people saying “Praise Allah.” But because it involves Christian themes, it’s being marketed to teenagers, with high hopes that it will be a mainstream hit and a big Christmas-season seller.

Interestingly, some conservative Christians have been critical of the game because of the violence (James Dobson, who has been outspoken about the evils of videogame violence, has not publicly stated whether he will make an exception for killing infidels). Others are fine with the violence because it’s not “gratuitous”:

“There’s an audience here,” said A. Larry Ross, president of a Dallas-based Christian public relations firm that helped to market Gibson’s “Passion” and three movie adaptations of the “Left Behind” books.

“In addition to the youth audience — that’s the primary target — there are parents who are concerned about what their children are exposed to and are encouraged by products that are biblically based,” Ross said. “I would assume, if there is violence, it’s the cosmic struggle of good versus evil, not gratuitous violence.”

And others are offended that the game allows you to switch sides, so that you can turn the tables on Christians:

Not surprisingly, Left Behind Games’ attempt to make Christianity accessible to youngsters through the use of lethal firepower has its critics. Thompson, for instance, said he severed ties with Tyndale House in a dispute over “Eternal Forces.”

“It’s absurd,” the video game critic said. “You can be the Christians blowing away the infidels, and if that doesn’t hit your hot button, you can be the Antichrist blowing away all the Christians.”

Yes, payback’s a bitch, ain’t it?

The real forces behind the creation, marketing and distribution of these games are the same megachurches that make Dominionism palatable by stripping it of the scary language and sacrifice, and have gathered huge followings:

Christian-themed games historically have had limited appeal. Developer Digital Praise has sold a reported 30,000 copies of its most popular product, a Christian title called “Dance Praise.” By contrast, “Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas” has sold 5.1 million copies worldwide.

” ‘Left Behind’ has the Antichrist, the end of the world, the apocalypse,” said co-creator Jeffrey S. Frichner. “It’s got all the Christian stuff, and it’s still got all the cool stuff.”

That’s why industry watchers predict that titles like “Eternal Forces” will find a broader audience in the same way Christian houses of worship like Pastor Rick Warren’s Saddleback Church in Lake Forest have attracted followers — in part by not being overly doctrinaire.

“The reason that I think this game has a chance is that it’s not particularly preachy,” said Michael Pachter, an analyst at Wedbush Morgan Securities. “I will say some of the dialogue is pretty lame — people saying, ‘Praise the Lord’ after they blow away the bad guys. I think they’re overdoing it a bit. But the message is OK.”

It’s OK to kill non-Christians. Good to know.

We’re on our way to Gilead.


26 thoughts on So Much For Rick Warren Being a Warm-and-Fuzzy Evangelical

  1. No Christian left behind. Sounds like that other BushCo program…that didn’t work…either.

  2. That’s hideous. I am a Christian (although, I think I would be targeted here too because I think I fall more into the moderate, mainstream category, whatever that means) and this makes me want to throw up. I really can’t believe they are marketing this and pretending like it’s a good, wholesome Christian game. It’s people like this that give normal, non wingnut Christians a bad name.

  3. I think the most frightening thing about this is that the video games will be put into the hands that are most likely to act the game out.

    I have no more a problem with the fantasy violence in this Left Behind game than I do with Grand Theft Auto. What concerns me is the social structure behind the game. For example, putting Grand Theft Auto in the hands of a population of rural kids is probably going to have a different result than putting it in the hands of kids who are raised in an environment that glorifies violence and respects criminals.

    This game is going to be in the hands of kids whose parents think that infidels are second-class citizens, and violence against these infidels can be justified. That’s trouble brewing.

    (I also agree that there is a double standard when it comes to Islam and Christianity. Good job showing it.)

  4. I don’t want to lump them all in together or anything, but this kind of thing makes me think that we just can’t trust Christian nations with nuclear weapons. Even the “secular” ones. I mean, they preach the virtues of a secular culture and a constitution and all that, but their leaders are, you know … believers. I mean, I respect their right to practice their faith and everything, but this is too important. We’re talking about something that could get us all killed.

    /sarcasm

  5. Let’s see. You live in an alternate reality where *you* are one of those Left Behind after the Rapture took the real Christians, so you weren’t such sterling material to begin with…and you presume that all you need do to make up for that is run around with armaments killing others also left behind…because good works mean nothing and saying a magic rite is all that’s necessary to be *spared* in the next pick up by the Powers…who didn’t actually leave you a “ten hot tips for Rapture the Sequel” manual…because you were factory repaired and left at the outlet store.

    Check.

    It’s just so darn refreshing to see the Peasants’ Crusade come out of the closet. Muscular Christians proving they are manly men locusting their way across the landscape, because nothing says “for the love of Christ” like a hiking body count.

    And how do they tell who is “their sort of” Christian? Would it be the individual putting his or her body in the way of massacreing unarmed others, babbling something about thou shalt not kill? No, wait., that would be a Jainist, or a Buddhist, or a…

    “Neca eos omnes. Deus suos agnoscet.” (“Kill them all. God will know his own.” )Papal Legate to the Crusaders, Arnaud-Amaury, the Abbot of Citeaux, over what to do when attacking Albigensian heretics.

    Same tribal xenophobia inciting mob mentality, different day.

    Yay us humans. No wonder the chimps broke up with us.

  6. he paramilitary aspect surprises me, as I believe that the general interpretation of premillennialists is that after the rapture, Christians’ main goal is witnessing (and, perhaps, protecting each other in passive ways), but that deadly force is not to be used (“he who lives by the sword will die by the sword).

    However, before worrying that this is encouraging theocracy and the killing of “infidels,” it should be pointed out that if the premillennialist Christians (I am one, btw) are correct, then after the Rapture the forces of the government will be dedicatedheart and soul to wiping out the Christians. And I get the impression that msot of the non-Christians will join them. I doubt the game involves killing non-Christians who are minding their own business. Presumably, the ones being killed are ones who are trying to help the Antichrist’s government to eradicate Christianity.

  7. And I get the impression that msot of the non-Christians will join them. I doubt the game involves killing non-Christians who are minding their own business.

    Apparently you haven’t read the screamsheets on it then. I’ll be sure to let all those horrible Buddists trying to wipe out Christians know that it’s ok to kill them in pixelated effigy.

    I find amusing the idea that the government would attempt to wipe out the single largest political group in the country. Especially since the right wing Dominionists are still the in the process of taking over. I have no problems with the left and moderate Christians out there who just want to live their lives unhindered in accordance to their faith. I have plenty of problem with the right wing Dominionist types who only seem to take joy in forcing others to step in line through legislation.

  8. Glaivester, if you premillenialist folks stay premillenialist, we have no problem. If you’re right, you get your rapture and if you’re wrong you keep waiting for an event that never comes. The problem is if a bunch of you folks arm and train and then go dominionist on us (I mean to invoke the way people become infected with the zombie virus in Romero movies), because they will try to build Gilead to set the stage. Once Protestant evangelicals start accepting that killing the infidels is something they’ll have to do someday, it’s a loaded gun hanging around.

  9. I think it’s good that some more moderate Christians are offended by this. But it’s important to remember, I think, that most Christian doctrines, these days, teach that for the mere sin of failing to believe the right things, most of us non-Christians deserve to be punished rather severely after we die. I think most moderate Christians don’t like to hear it put that way, but if you believe we face what most people would call tourture if the wrong person did it, and if you believe that treatment for non-believers is just, then you believe that non-Christians deserve to be tourtured, after they’re dead, for the sin of not being Christians. Even most moderate Christians believe these things, and surely the seeds of some kind of bigotry and intolerance are within this doctrine, already.

    So, while I’m glad some moderate Christians are offended by this game, I wish more moderate Christians would search their own doctrine for such unhealthy attitudes, even when those attitudes are not as over-the-top as those behind this game.

    AdrianG

  10. then you believe that non-Christians deserve to be tourtured, after they’re dead, for the sin of not being Christians. Even most moderate Christians believe these things, and surely the seeds of some kind of bigotry and intolerance are within this doctrine, already.

    It’s unfortunate that the loudest Christian voices have so skewed non-Christian perceptions of what Christians believe. Because the fact is that most moderate Christians don’t believe that non-Christians are all going to be tortured in Hell for all eternity. Quakers don’t believe this. The United Church of Christ doesn’t believe this. Episcopalians don’t believe this. Even the Roman Catholic Church is, since Vatican II, on record as saying that you don’t need to be Christian to be saved (Nostra Aetate, one of the official documents of Vatican II).

    And yeah, as a Quaker I’m grossly offended by that game, and by the attitudes it represents.

  11. Actually, evangelicals (like myself) believe that everyone, Christian or not, deserves to go to Hell. The reason why Christians do not go to Hell is because they have accepted God’s forgiveness (Jesus’ death was the payment for our sins rather than going to Hell, and by believing in Jesus’ death as the source of your redemption, you acept that redemption), not because they do not deserve it.

    And listen, I see no Biblical support for the idea that during the Tribulation Christians ought to be doing physical battle with the forces of the Antichrist. So this game may very well be un-Biblical (to tell the truth, I haven’t read any of the Left Behind novels).

    As for Dominionists, I thought they were mostly postmillennialists, not premillennialists, so Left Behind would not be “their bag,” so to speak.

  12. I have serious doubts that this game is going to indoctrinate anyone.

    However, I think it has the real potential to make “praise the lord” into a kitschy catch-phrase. Cop shows, action movies, etc could just swim in it. Use it enough and the real losers, as sadly this always seems to be the case whenever right-wing christian language takes over, will be earnest mainline protestants clinging to just using the words “praise the lord” to praise the lord.

    It could be the next “Hasta la vista, baby” and be about as effective at creating Christians as the Terminator was at creating Spanish speakers.

    Shoddy evangelism is a one-way ticket to rampant, entertaining blasphemy.

  13. Glaivester, it is my understanding that dominionism is inherently postmillenialist, depending on their jack-booted forces to bring on the second coming. However, as I said, I’m concerned that people could make that doctrinal jump from waiting for the rapture to bringing on the kingdom — which of course would happen over, literally, my dead body and those of my family.

  14. On one hand, I want to point out that Warren’s involvement in this project is hardly direct. On the other, even the more ostensibly moderate evangelicals like Warren have to walk the fine line, especially where book sales depend on LaHaye’s readers.

  15. Pingback: Larvatus Prodeo
  16. Thomas, as I understand it premillennialism is divided into Dispensationalist a la LaHaye and historical premillennialists:

    Dispensationalist PreMs expect first the Rapture, then the rise of the AntiChrist through seven years of Tribulation, then Armageddon before Christ returns and brings on the millennium of peace for the born-again before the final judgement. Historical PreMs go for first the Tribulation, with a secret Rapture during the seven years of the Anti-Christ’s rule, with the raptured returning to Earth with Christ to share in the thousand year rule of Heaven.

    Postmillennialists believe that the Kingdom of God on Earth has to be established by believers for a thousand years before Christ will return. It’s also split, between Revivalist PostMs (evangelicals) and Reconstructionist PostMs (theocrats).

    There seems to be a worrying convergence of theocratic tendencies between the Dispensationalist PreMs and the Reconstructionist PostMs – I guess they figure that whether the Second Coming is before or after the thousand-year Kingdom of Heaven, the theocracy will be the right thing to do for Christ’s return.

  17. As a conservative Christian myself (I know, horrors! :D) your description of this game struck me as somewhat unbelievable. So I went and read all the primary documents I could find concerning this game, and have concluded that it is not quite as bad as you make it out to be. Although I’m not so sure it is good, either.

    The story behind the game seems to be that two forces are fighting (the Christians vs. the minions of the anti-Christ) and the people you are trying to “win to Jesus” are neutral. I.e., you don’t kill them simply because they don’t convert. The people you fight are the evil minions of the Anti-Christ, who are both trying to kill you and take over the world/subjugate everyone to their sinister yoke. So if you are allowed to fight against anyone, the minions seem like worthy opponents.

    That said, I’ve never been much of a fan of apocalyptic fiction, or even trying to figure out what Daniel or the author of Revelation was on about. I figure we’ll see it when it gets here, and wild guesses or fictionalization of the end times will only serve to mislead and confuse.

    This is the first I’ve heard of this game, but the hysteria I’ve read about it here, at Pandagon, etc. seems way overblown. In the milieu of the game, the protagonists are fighting against the minions of Darkness, not their intransigent next-door neighbors. Kill the daemonic minions, convert your neighbors. Not exactly a game I’d buy for my kids, but hardly the offense against civilization that some here are making it out to be.

  18. The report is very inaccurate, especially the reference to Talk2Action. The game does not have the player try to establish a theocracy or kill people who don’t convert. In fact, you are penalized for killing people, even though Christian forces are fighting against the anti-Christ’s army.

    See more about the nature of the game, with quotes from secular reviewers who have actually played it:

    http://christiancadre.blogspot.com/2006/06/truth-about-left-behind-video-game.html

  19. More lies from those who hate Christianity for whatever reason. Your description of this game is absolutely inaccurate. Well- of you don’t have to be concerned with “Thou Shalt Not Lie” I guess the truth really does not matter. Another fine example of the “open mindedness” of the left…

Comments are currently closed.