In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Round and Round We Go

This is yet another post on the reclamation post from earlbecke.

A chicken-and-egg discussion has developed–or devolved–in comments about whether the unisexing of “bitch” and the verb form of “bitch” indicate that its misogynist connotations are becoming diluted or not. I think not.

When used to describe a woman, “bitch” means that the woman is a nasty, shrewish, loudmouthed, uppity, coldhearted, grasping virago.

When used to describe a man–excluding its use within gay male circles–“bitch” usually means something completely different: an emasculated, penetrated, powerless little faggot. It has nothing to do with being overbearing or domineering; in fact, it implies that the target isn’t aggressive enough.

“Bitch” is an insult to men to the extent that it is connected with women, with effeminacy, with being the bottom, the bitch. When we apply it in unisex ways, we’re still using it as a gendered insult.

Nor is the verb form of “bitch” distinct in connotation from the noun. “Bitch” is just one on a long list of insults for women who won’t shut up. Shrew, virago, harpy, harridan, termagant, scold, fishwife, and on and on and on. When you “bitch,” you don’t just complain. You complain constantly about insignificant things. You nag. That’s what the verb and the noun have in common, and that’s why they’re still gendered.


8 thoughts on Round and Round We Go

  1. according to Miriam Webster online, virago has two meanings

    Main Entry: vi·ra·go
    Pronunciation: v&-‘rä-(“)gO, -‘rA-; ‘vir-&-“gO
    Function: noun
    Inflected Form(s): plural -goes or -gos
    Etymology: Middle English, from Latin viragin-, virago, from vir man — more at VIRILE
    1 : a loud overbearing woman : TERMAGANT
    2 : a woman of great stature, strength, and courage
    – vi·rag·i·nous /v&-‘ra-j&-n&s/ adjective

    cool, huh? If I weren’t already frumious I would be viraginous.

  2. Related/ Not Related, having grown up on a farm that also raised pure bred collies, my grandmother always referred to a Bitch as one of her female dogs. “That Bitch is a good breeder” or ” This Bitch will win best of show”. This completely defined my view of the word, and I do cringe when I hear it used in a derogative context.

    Walk around a dog show sometime, and you will see what I mean. This I no way infers anything regarding how it is used otherwise just posting my two cents regarding it’s intended usage is all.

    Marty

  3. Does anybody else get pissed off when people whine that they don’t mean ‘pussy’ or whatever in a derogitory way? “Oh, I meant scared as a pussy cat.” Sure, that works if you’re twelve and you’ve never been in a locker room or a bar.

    Argh, I’ve struggled with the notion of sexist language. On the one hand, I don’t feel anti-feminist women deserve the care you’d take with feminists, who fought for freedom from that kind of thing. On the other hand, it’s problematical. Where’s the good, vicious insults you can throw when necessary? What accurately refers to a guy who whines that women do TOO lie about rape? What about the guy who’s already ready with the PHMT? We’re facing a crying shortage of adjectives and insults.

  4. But those don’t specifically target the vicious, sex-specific nature of the effect.

    Argh, and it should have said ‘always’ in my previous comment.

    I mean, you can’t say SOB without realizing, wait, it’s calling the guy’s mom a whore. Son of a……son of a…..wife beater? Son of a child molester? Son of a anti-choice hypocrite?

  5. “A load that should have been swallowed” is my particular favorite term for those people, but I never really thought of the implications.

  6. Ahhh, I have had many conversations about this word lately with the guy I have choosen to be my mate for now. He was using in generic ways like, “My mom keeps on bitchin'” and stuff. After a few times around, he understood why the word is a no-no around me.

    Because it is indeed still gendered.

  7. One thing about slang (and therefore most insults) is that they mean different things to different people. For example, I use the word “bitch” to mean the same thing for both sexes and would be confused if I heard it used otherwise. For either guys or girls, I use it to mean “whiny” or “an unfair person”. E.g., “Stop being a little bitch and just choose a movie already” (whiny) or “Stop being a bitch and share the puck with teammates!” (playing unfairly).

    My friends and I actually had a conversation about this last night. One used “gay” as an insult, and I snapped at him. Another friend then suggested “lame”, and we thought about it for a moment and we realized that that word, too, mocks a group of people. The only neutral word we could come up with was “jerk.”

Comments are currently closed.