In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Drafting Hollywood

I couldn’t figure out if this article was serious or not. Sadly, I think it is.

There has never been an age without war, not ever. Mass violence is a continual aspect of the human condition. Peace, like good weather, is always local and temporary — and what is peace anyway but the result of past victories in war and the effective threat of future war against would-be aggressors?

We play with our children, read books, go to work and enjoy recreations only because people with guns stand ready, willing and able to kill other people with guns who would kill us if they could.

…really? I’d hate to walk around all day with this guy’s world view.

We need some films celebrating the war against Islamo-fascism in Afghanistan and Iraq — and in Iran as well, if and when that becomes necessary. We need films like those that were made during World War II, films such as 1943’s “Sahara” and “Action in the North Atlantic,” or “The Fighting Seabees” and “Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo,” which were released in 1944.

Not all of these were great films, or even good ones, but their patriotic tributes to our fighting forces inspired the nation.

More than that, they reminded the country what exactly it was that those forces were fighting to defend. Though many of these pictures now seem almost hilariously free with racist tirades against “sauerkrauts,” and “eyeties” and “Tojo and his bug-eyed monkeys,” they were also carefully constructed to display American life at its open-minded and inclusive best.

Sure, they used racial slurs like “bug-eyed monkeys,” but that’s American open-mindedness and inclusiveness at its best! Now if we just start using Hollywood to call Arabs camel-jockeys, they’ll see how great our way of life is.

As early as 1947, we had “Crossfire,” about an American GI who commits an anti-Semitic murder. In 1949, “Home of the Brave” depicted a heroic African American soldier dealing with prejudice. And by 1955, there was the classic “Bad Day at Black Rock,” in which a veteran uncovers homicidal anti-Japanese bigotry when he tries to deliver a medal to the father of a Japanese American killed on the battlefields of Italy.

Such self-examination and reform are part of the measure of our greatness. But there’s a difference between a humble nation confessing its sins and a country of flagellants whipping themselves for every impure thought. Since the ’60s, we have had, it seems, an endless string of war movies, from “Dr. Strangelove” to “Syriana,” in which the United States is depicted as wildly aggressive and endlessly corrupt — which, in fact, it’s not; which, in fact, it never has been.

Pssh, why talk about racism and imperialism when we can talk about winning?

Read the whole article. It’s… something else.


13 thoughts on Drafting Hollywood

  1. Lauren, if you can’t stick to the topic at hand, we’re going to have to ban you.

    That said, I have that song on my iTunes, and I’m a big fan.

  2. Though many of these pictures now seem almost hilariously free with racist tirades against “sauerkrauts,” and “eyeties” and “Tojo and his bug-eyed monkeys,” they were also carefully constructed to display American life at its open-minded and inclusive best.

    How does he write that without his head exploding? I mean, the cognitive dissonance behind that is just … incredible.

  3. His framing requires that we all buy into some great movement of Islamo-fascism that is as great a threat as the nation state movement of Germany and Japan. There is an Islamic jihadists movement, that is a fact. It has a few thousand adherent world wide out of a religion that includes a billion people and it is non-state related, even though Iran has been a big supporter. Let’s put it this way, there are more rapists and child molesters in the US then there are genuine jihaists world wide. Should we make movies that celebrate the daily struggle of the police and health care professionals that are fighting this domestic scrunge? If not why not. The right’s chicken-little paranoia combined with eliminationism is showing. There are bad people doing bad thing as there have always been; the fringe American right, in a rather unhinged way is trying to focus only on one threat to our national well being and is doing so to the detriment of the diverting resources from the bigger picture. We’re spending about 1.6 billion a week in Iraq, certainly those kinds of resources could go a long way in tracking down real terrorists, prosecuting domestic criminals, rebuilding our cities, curing disease and educationing our children. Rational clear thinking Americans have a huge job on their hands, fighting terrorists, solving the same criminal, social justice, and health problems that have plaqued the nation for years, but also fighting against the shrill paranoia of the far right who are squandering our material and human resources against a boogie man that is far smaller then their imaginations will allow.

  4. You know, I’ve been thinking about this, and we’re every bit as recist toward our depictions of modern Islam as we were toward WWII-era Germans and Japanese. The message is the same: Funny-looking, backward people of laughable cultural heritage seek to kill us all based on an inferiority complex. Now, people are ignorant, and I can accept that, but the U.S.? Not corrupt? Never was, never will?

    The only people I know who can lie to themselves like that usually hide bottles of Night Train and Thunderbird under their kitchen sinks. By the caseload.

  5. Well, actually, there has been a recent war film where American forces used racial epithets. But that was ‘Three Kings’ and it was hilarious and ironic.

    And anyway, all the action/thriller movies are busy turning what would have been evil soviets into evil Islamists, so why not let them do the dirty work?

  6. One of the best WWII movies was “The Best Years of Our Lives.” It told a more real story of what happened when Johnny came marching home. Rebuilding lives, reconnecting with family and friends, coping with devastating injuries, emotional trauma from battle, dealing with the results of an ill-advised wartime wedding, etc. Myrna Loy, Theresa Wright, Virgina Mayo, Frederick March, Dana Andrews – lots of retro screen goodness. Won Best Picture of 1946.

  7. In short, we need war movies now even more than in the ’40s. So why aren’t we getting them?

    WWII: Just war.

    Iraq: Unjust war.

    Questions?

Comments are currently closed.