In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Greetings from Western Mass and an offering of Sagan

Hey folks, I’m Brigid. You may remember me from last year. I’m a queer femme writer, sometime environmental researcher, and anthropologist at heart. I recently relocated from Washington, DC to Western Massachusetts, where the beer is crafty and the humor is always self-referential. I enjoy science fiction, political art, and arguing amicably about things I love. I believe asking the right questions is at least as important as knowing the right answers. I’d like to be a romancer of reality. My mission is to drop truth and beauty bombs.

I don’t have a regular longform, original-content blog of my own at the moment, but you can follow me on Twitter (@whatmakesitgo), Tumblr (ordinarymachines), or Goodreads (ordinarymachines).

No long treatises or important insights just now, but I thought I’d share with you that I’m reading Contact by Carl Sagan (1985). It is an absolute joy — solid writing full of interesting science and compelling characters and meaning of life stuff. It also has tidbits like this:

[Ellie] set out to broaden her education, to take as many courses as possible apart from her central interests in mathematics, physics, and engineering. But there was a problem with her central interests. She found it difficult to discuss physics, much less debate it, with her predominantly male classmates. At first they paid a kind of selective inattention to her remarks. There would be a slight pause, and then they would go on as if she had not spoken. Occasionally they would acknowledge her remark, even praise it, and then again continue undeflected. She was reasonably sure her remarks were not entirely foolish, and did not wish to be ignored, much less ignored and patronized alternately. Part of it—but only a part—she knew was due to the softness of her voice. So she developed a physics voice: clear, competent, and many decibels above conversational. With such a voice it was important to be right. She had to pick her moments. It was hard to continue long in such a voice, because she was sometimes in danger of bursting out laughing. So she found herself leaning towards quick, sometimes cutting, interventions, usually enough to capture their attention; then she could go on for a while in a more usual tone of voice. Every time she found herself in a new group she would have to fight her way through again, just to dip her oar into the discussion. The boys were uniformly unaware even that there was a problem.

Sagan isn’t making a revolutionary observation here. But I find it particularly refreshing that as he introduces important male characters throughout the novel, he continues to remark on their willingness or reluctance to listen to Dr. Ellie Arroway when she speaks. He doesn’t soapbox about it, just includes it among the details he chooses to reveal about a person. Kind of like … the way I log whether people ignore me among other characteristics when I meet them in real life. Truth in fiction!

And I grinned a little to myself at “physics voice.” I know that voice; I’ve been refining my own since third grade. It’s not the only way to respond to Privileged Selective Hearing Syndrome, certainly, and it doesn’t make the problem go away (see also: “shrill,” “strident,” “know-it-all,” “bitchy”). Still, for what it’s worth, that voice is a part of me. I’ll bet I’m not the only one here for whom that’s the case.


6 thoughts on Greetings from Western Mass and an offering of Sagan

  1. Wow! I just relocated from Western Mass to Washington DC! Do you have any suggestions for places to go/stuff to do? It’s all a bit overwhelming after ten years of living in small college towns.

    And on topic to the post, my “physics voice” is actually deeper than my regular voice…I think I actually picked it up from a female professor as an undergrad, because everyone seemed to listen to her, even when she was in the Boys Club.

  2. Thanks, ellid!

    theLaplaceDemon, welcome to DC! Go to museums. Go to all the museums. It is unlikely that you will ever have such a great opportunity to see so much material culture for free, so take advantage of it. I especially recommend the Museum of the American Indian, for its conscious efforts to engage indigenous people in the telling of their own stories and to represent indigenous cultures as dynamic and three-dimensional.

    Go to the Tidal Basin and see the memorials. Do the touristy stuff. It’s easy, it’ll help ground you in the city, and if you eventually leave DC you’ll probably want to have done it at least once.

    Go to Eastern Market. Look out for neighborhood festivals (Columbia Heights Day, H Street Festival, etc.) and go to them. If you like those neighborhoods, go back and explore them. My graphic designer friend Torie made this illustrated guide to farmer’s markets for Edible DC. Check them out.

    Go to happy hours. Go with your coworkers, go with your friends. Find the best happy hour spot in your home or work neighborhood and keep going back there. Find a bar in your neighborhood that serves brunch on the weekends and go to it. Invite your neighbors or friends from work or OkCupid.

    Keep an eye on Free in DC. Stay in some nights and cook for yourself. Talk to your neighbors. Good luck.

  3. How funny – I just relocated to Western Mass too! (From a suburb just outside NYC though, not DC.) Thanks for this – you’ve made me want to run out and buy Contact (my partner will be thrilled, he loves Sagan) after that excerpt.

    I feel so lucky to work in feminist circles mostly, where I haven’t need to employ my “commanding tone” very often… but as a short, young looking, woman I definitely HAVE one and can identify. Knowing that Sagan was observant/empathetic enough to work that experience into his writing of a female character says a lot about him as a writer… you’ve made me much more interested in reading his work!

Comments are currently closed.