In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

In which I indulge myself in brief admiration of Helen Mirren

I kind of love Helen Mirren. I just think that for the most part, she’s a classy dame. I like that she takes no shit. I like that it looks like she knows how to have fun. I like how outspoken she is about the dangers of gender stereotyping, and the importance of mentors and role models, and the irrelevance of looks, (all of which really make her toxic comments about date rape and bitchy, jealous women all the more confounding. If anyone here can sort that out, let me know). I like seeing a thoroughly adult woman who’s fully content with the less-traditional choices she’s made in life. I like that she appears to have welcomed age without screwing with her face. Whenever my mom is panicking about not knowing what to wear for some event, I always tell her, “Just ask yourself what Helen Mirren would wear.” I’m pretty sure I’d like to hang out with her.

I also like her judgment in picking roles. She tends to pick good ones, and then play them well. Victoria was probably my favorite character in Red, because of the contradiction evidenced in the scene where she pulled an assault rifle out of a flower arrangement. Of course, that role was written to be played by a woman–the whole point of Victoria was that she was that unexpected combination of old-school/feminine and tough and fearless. A well-developed character in and of herself, she was also a bit of a mascot. To really change it up, we look over to NPR’s Monkey See, where Linda Holmes has a list of Twenty Iconic Male Movie Roles in Which Helen Mirren Would Have Ruled.

Of course, she’s already played a couple of gender-swapped roles, playing Hobson to Russell Brand’s Arthur in Arthur and turning Prospero into Prospera for The Tempest. But Holmes has a great list of major male roles that Mirren would have, in fact, ruled. Dame Helen (because she is one of those) would definitely do a great job as Colonel Jessup in A Few Good Men. She’d be a fantastic replacement for Henry Fonda in 12 Angry Men (although you’d need a bit of a title change there). I’m not sure about Bond, Jane Bond, probably because I really like the way the series has rebooted with a rougher-edged Bond as played by Daniel Craig. It’s an interesting thought, though.

For me, I’d love to see her swap roles with John Malkovich in just about anything he’s done. Ditto Clive Owen. For reasons even I don’t understand, I’d like to see her approach to the captain in Cool Hand Luke, but she’d definitely need to take care of Holmes’s number 14 first.

14. Michael Clayton, Michael Clayton. She’s a fixer! She’s a lawyer! Also, I want to see her and Tilda Swinton have a confrontation.

Helen Mirren in a stony face-off with Tilda Swinton, and then the two of them hanging out together at press junkets, PLEASE SOMEBODY MAKE THIS HAPPEN.

(h/t Go Fug Yourself)


13 thoughts on In which I indulge myself in brief admiration of Helen Mirren

  1. Ah, Helen Mirren. I do love her, particularly in Calendar Girls (chiefly for the bogus tai chi and the loud proclamation of her hatred of plum jam). I hadn’t known about the less-than-stellar comments that were pointed out here: I’m extremely puzzled by them, but I think I’d still love to have tea with her.

  2. I could be wrong, but I think correct usage in England is “Dame Helen,” not “Dame Mirren.” A knight’s title is used with first and last name, or only first name, not generally only last name. Sir Elton (John), Dame Agatha (Christie), etc.

  3. And I really should have appended that to a more substantive comment, but it’s late and I’m tired and hungover and have already taken my sleeping pills. Sorry.

    Dame Helen Mirren ROCKS.

  4. Helen Mirren in a stony face-off with Tilda Swinton, and then the two of them hanging out together at press junkets, PLEASE SOMEBODY MAKE THIS HAPPEN.

    OH DEAR GODS YES!!

    (Mind you, I’m the man who keeps writing the BBC every time there is mention of the lead leaving Doctor Who to remind them that Tilda Swinton needs to be the next Doctor.)

  5. Great post! She is awesome in “The Debt” too! She plays the older Jessica Chastain (gorgeous) as a Mossad operative in East Germany circa 1964. Her opening scenes are so skillful that you totally believe her a tough-as-nails Israeli smoking cigs and kicking Nazi ass.

    I don’t like the whole “Dame” “Sir” thing, too much royalty for my Irish blood to handle, but you do make great points. Can’t wait for Meryl Streep playing Margaret Thatcher in “The Iron Lady”.

  6. A remarkable talent, indeed. Real people, of course, are highly problematic, but I’d love to see her cast as Oscar Wilde.

    The bit about women reporters reminded me a little of how some people go off bisexuals after dating one or two and getting the perception of being dumped for someone of the opposite gender. Some such people end up somewhere on a tricky scale between making a personal decision to avoid repeating such a risk and universalizing the experience into oft-repeated biphobic stereotypes. Unfortunate, but not that many humans are perfectly consistent.

    Lastly, a trivial point, but is “Dame Mirren” correct usage? I thought it was like Sir in requiring a first name – one doesn’t, for instance, see “Sir McKellan” (Ian). I remember this being noted once on a college paper of mine.

  7. MadGastronomer:
    I could be wrong, but I think correct usage in England is “Dame Helen,” not “Dame Mirren.” A knight’s title is used with first and last name, or only first name, not generally only last name. Sir Elton (John), Dame Agatha (Christie), etc.

    Well, I just call her Dame Mirren ’cause we’re tight, so I’ll be all, “Hey, Dame Mirren!” and she’s all, “Hey, CG! How’s the Bentley?” And we laugh, because that’s our inside joke we have that you don’t know. But for the sake of all y’all who’ve never played paintball with her, I’ll change it.

  8. @Caperton Hee! Next time you’re playing paintball with her, get her a good one for me!

    I don’t like the whole “Dame” “Sir” thing, too much royalty for my Irish blood to handle, but you do make great points.

    A knight is not royalty. A knight is not even necessarily nobility these days. A knight is a peer of the realm. You’re still welcome to dislike them, of course, but these days a knighthood is used to honor artists instead of fighters, which I think is pretty damn rad.

    I know, I know, I keep being terribly nitpicky, but these things really bug me.

  9. MadGastronomer:
    @Caperton Hee! Next time you’re playing paintball with her, get her a good one for me!

    A knight is not royalty. A knight is not even necessarily nobility these days. A knight is a peer of the realm. You’re still welcome to dislike them, of course, but these days a knighthood is used to honor artists instead of fighters, which I think is pretty damn rad.

    OK, I admit defeat! You are right and I was being a jerk. I should have realized that and I apologize for my ignorance.

  10. I never said you were a jerk, Rich. You were simply misinformed on something I happen to geek about, that’s all.

Comments are currently closed.