In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

And This is the Post on Love

During the 2008 Democratic National Convention Joe Biden’s son told the story of the death of his mother and the way his family rebuilt itself after tragedy. Halfway through his speech he uttered a line that still plays in my heart, “And then we married Jill.”

I didn’t have the world’s best childhood. The first 13 years of my life were mirthless and often violent. It is with no sense of hyperbole that I say I am lucky to be alive and writing with you today.

But it wasn’t luck, honestly, it was my mother. My mother took me out of a bad situation; my mother literally saved my life. We left hell and we learned to live – on our own—together. She taught me how to be independent; she taught me how to be happy again.

And then, in time, we met Dennis.

My mother started dating Dennis when I was a teenager and their connection was instantaneous. Within months they were deeply in love and I had a father figure that would make Seth Cohn jealous. Like Jill Biden, when Dennis married my mother, he married into a family. The years between then and now are filled with beautiful moments of a family coming together, of a girl learning to trust a father figure and of a man learning to be a husband and father.

Dennis isn’t a white knight; he didn’t rescue us from a bad situation. My mother rescued herself and rescued me. I’d like to think of Dennis more as karmic retribution. We’d been through the worst, so the universe sent us the best.

I’ve written before about my history of abuse and even the dating violence I experienced. Through the lessons of my mother and my friends I’ve tried not to allow that victimization define me. I think it’s so easy to get so caught up in the aspects of hate and victimization — especially if that victimization happens at a young age — that we don’t trust or accept love and happiness when it presents itself to us.

But I’ve learned – and am continuing to learn – about love and how to appreciate it. And I have to credit a lot of that to the love found between my mother and Dennis.


12 thoughts on And This is the Post on Love

  1. Your situation was worse than my own, because yours persisted for as long as it did. Mine was a relatively limited period of trauma, but still left marks on me, but psychologically, not physically.

    I see the steps you have made and want to compliment you for your progress. I sense a lasting peace within yourself yet to come. I hope to learn from your example.

  2. The key is to dump a man as soon as he shows any sign of being abusive. But it takes being very attentive to that, and unfortunately many people have a large capacity for forgiveness and understand for the wrong people. But if you dump them early, you dodge the bullet before you surrender anything of yourself to him. I’ve had men on 3rd-5th dates become verbally abusive that I didn’t “give them what they want.” Well, well. See you later, alligator. I know people talk about expressing themselves sexually and all that bullshit, but if a man you barely know becomes abusive about sex, then imagine what he’ll be like if you are actually dating him. No thanks.

  3. Savvy: I agree that staying aware of the signs is important, but women should be really wary of romance, in general. Even if the boyfriend/husband isn’t abusive, loving someone makes a woman weak and vulnerable, and when a man’s economic circumstances change, they tend to resort to violence because they’re depressed. Love is a zero-sum game for women, and I wish more people realized that.

  4. Savvy, I’m very sincerely glad for you that you’re that attuned to the red flags for abusive behavior.
    But it takes being very attentive to that, and unfortunately many people have a large capacity for forgiveness and understand for the wrong people.
    Abuse exists as the extreme on a continuum of male entitlement behavior. You might find “Why Does He Do That?” By Lundy Bancroft a useful reference in unpacking how a patriarchal system creates the superstructure in which abuse thrives.

    Abuse is a behavior that is strictly controlled by the abuser. NOT the target. Your comment is dangerously close to victim-blaming, and as a survivor of abuse myself, I can assure you that smart, strong, capable women – like myself – get targeted all the time.

    Joy, your post made my morning and got me to de-lurk. I, too managed to get out of a hellish abusive marriage and, like your mom, eventually wound up with a wonderful, loving partner who is a fantastic role model to my son. Hearing about your experience gives me so much hope for the future, especially since the court system where I live granted my abusive ex joint custody of our son, and my son is continually exposed to abuse even now.

  5. loving someone makes a woman weak and vulnerable

    Huh? You seem to have a really low opinion of both women and men. The reason knowing the warning signs of DV is so effective, is because abusers behave differently than non-abusers. It’s also a myth that abuse comes from economic downturns. Economically healthy men abuse, too. Also, it’s not just straight women that have to deal with abuse; lesbians and bisexual women can also be abusers.

    I feel kind of strange responding; I don’t want to leave the impression I’m defending romantic love (which, IMO, has different definitions for different people)—I don’t have a dog in that fight (not in love, and hey, if it happens, it happens–if it don’t, it don’t)….but….

    I guess what really rubs me the wrong way about this blanket statement is the way women (again, IME, where I’m from) are constantly told that anything enjoyable makes us weak and vulnerable. That we should disregard pleasure. That pleasure is something other people get to have; we should keep our nose to the grindstone and remind ourselves that life is pain. Fuck that. Love doesn’t make women (why women? not men too?) any more weak and vulnerable than any other pleasurable experience in life.

  6. I disagree; love that is one-sided is zero-sum, but a person who actually loves someone else does not start acting like an asshole when their economic circumstances change.

    Mostly just wanted to comment on how cool this post was, and how much I agree. It’s funny how often good things have happened to me *after* I decided not to let anyone save me but made my own moves for myself. The exact opposite narrative of what women are told.

  7. First, I want to thank Joy for this wonderfully honest and impressive post. Not every childhood horor can be met with such an overpowering triumph of human decency, but its always heartening to see that people can overcome the negative lots they can get in childhood.

    That said, cycles of abuse are both learned and perpetuated by our family lives and our experiences surrounding them. I don’t think that people who’ve grown up in environments that normalize abuse and violence will invariably be time bombs, but there is likely an increased possibility of perpetuating that cycle.

    Beyond that I don’t know if its a “win” to shut down love as a zero sum game. Granted patriarchal societies being what they are, and gender socialization being the force that it is, women are socialized to become the expressive, the passive, and …some could argue, the emotional dormat. Loving someoneone doesn’t make a woman weak, as much as the expectations attached to what loving someone as a woman is supposed to mean in our society. From childhood on, our society teaches girls to be dependant and suffer it with a smile. Whenever a maladaptive relationship is entered into, its often the habit for the woman to internalize the psychological damage and those outside the relationship to somehow turn a blind eye. Its all awful and frustrating and painful to watch. But ultimitley I think more of the answer lies in breaking down the old, patriarchial paradigms that disempower young women and girls and create conditions where this sort of maladaptivity in relationships isn’t either silently approved of, or reinforced.

  8. My father wasn’t abusive, but living with him was like living inside of a vacuum, a black hole. The depths of his self-centeredness just sucked love in and left nothing but suffocation. I’m very, very glad that my mother left him and took me with her (and I deeply wish my sister had come too), because it still terrifies me to think about where and how I was at 13, and what it would have meant to keep living with him. I spent the rest of my adolescence angry with him until I finally began grieving for all of the time and energy I lost to him. As part of my grieving and healing, I accepted that no one is entitled to my feelings – he doesn’t deserve love just for being a biological benefactor to me. And recently I’ve realized the flipside; that I am also not entitled to his love, for the same reasons. This also hurt, but it was freeing. I find it tragic sometimes, because he seems genuinely interested in being a loving and loved parent, but he inevitably demonstrates that he does not know how to love anyone except himself and I cannot invest in him without risking my own health and stability.

    My mother, on the other hand, taught me everything I know about the kind of person I want to be. It was living with her that I first began to realize how crappy a parent my dad actually was, because she treated me like a human being and he treated me like a prop. She has not met a “Dennis”, sadly. But also not so sadly, as she is at peace with that, and is comfortable and happy in her life. It was also through her that I learned that living without a romantic partner is not a horrible, life-ending prospect (young me was convinced that unless a prince came along to ‘fix’ me through loving me, I was doomed – thanks, Disney). Instead we developed that quirky “old married couple” vibe that any two people living (mostly) alone together for 10 years will get, which taught me more about loving partnerships than living with her and my father ever did.

    (re: Savvy and politicalguineapig… I actually guessed that the latter was using somewhat unsuccessful satire as a reponse to the creepy victim-blaming vibe of the former’s comment. Or I hope, at least? Either way, derailing comments are derailing.)

  9. I wanted a white knight (dame, I guess) to rescue me, and eventually I found one. Our marriage was successful — on the terms she set. Eventually, I figured out that I had to rescue myself, and I did. I moved out and started considering my options, and wound up starting a whole new relationship. It happened to be with my still-wife, but I came back as a different person.

    Anyone who feels a need to be rescued definitely needs to get to work learning the things they need to become their own rescuer.

  10. Joy, I found this article very uplifting and insightful. Thanks for sharing the lovely story and thoughts behind it.

Comments are currently closed.