In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Birthing Nightmare for African Women

The horror of obstetric fistulas is finally getting some attention — hopefully this will result in increased aid to reproductive health for women in developing nations.

What brings the girls to Dr. Waaldijk – and him to Nigeria – is the obstetric nightmare of fistulas, unknown in the West for nearly a century. Mostly teenagers who tried to deliver their first child at home, the girls failed at labor. Their babies were lodged in their narrow birth canals, and the resulting pressure cut off blood to vital tissues and ripped holes in their bowels or urethras, or both.

Now their babies were dead. And the would-be mothers, their insides wrecked, were utterly incontinent. Many had become outcasts in their own communities – rejected by their husbands, shunned by neighbors, too ashamed even to step out of their huts.

(…)

Dr. Waaldijk remembers one patient well. She managed to push out only her baby’s head before collapsing from exhaustion in her hut, he said. Her brother carried her, balanced on a donkey, to a road, where a bus driver demanded 10 times the usual fare to take her to a hospital. She half-stood, half-sat for the trip, her dead baby’s head between her legs, her urethra ripped open.

“This is what is happening,” the doctor said. “Nobody will believe it.” The fistulas point to the broader plight of millions of African women: poverty; early marriage; maternal deaths; a lack of rights, independence and education; a generally low standing. One in 18 Nigerian women dies during childbirth, compared with one in 2,400 in Europe, the Population Fund says. A larger share of African women die in childbirth than anywhere else in the world.

And the problem, as the Times shows, affects women young and old:

Nearly 600 women showed up, some arriving in busloads, when international and Nigerian officials staged a 14-day treatment campaign at Babbar Ruga and three other hospitals in February. Three hospitals ran out of beds. The youngest patient was 12.

The oldest, more than 70, had been incontinent for a half-century.

Part of the problem is that these girls are being married off as children, and having children at a very young age — according to the doctor, about a third of his patients are under the age of 15. They don’t have the right to refuse sex, to refuse early marriage, to divorce, and in some countries to own their own land. They don’t have access to birth control or sexual health information. They certainly don’t have access to the basic medical care that would prevent most of these injuries. And U.S. international aid packages require that we just tell African women, “Be abstinent until marriage.”

The UNFPA has a comprehensive campaign to end fistula in Africa (as a sidenote, the Bush administration has again cut funding to the UNFPA this year). Contribute if you can.


14 thoughts on Birthing Nightmare for African Women

  1. I was about to post, “I blame the right for this – that may sound snarky, but it isn’t.”

    Then I read: And U.S. international aid packages require that we just tell African women, “Be abstinent until marriage.”

    I blame the right for this – full stop.

  2. That’s scary! And I really don’t see how abstinence til marriage (but good luck trying that over there anyway… it doesn’t seem like the type of society where men are just like “oh, you don’t want to have sex? ok, let’s just hold hands”) would solve these problems at all. These women desperately need family planning tools and it is mind boggling to me that we continue to deny them.

  3. These women desperately need family planning tools and it is mind boggling to me that we continue to deny them.

    They belong to themselves and it is not for us to give or deny them anything either way.

  4. Actually, it seems that the rightwing’s baby–“waiting till marriage”– is 99% of these girls’ problem. When your society forces you to get married at 12, and of course not use birth control, then the sexual part of the marriage is deadly, whether you saved yourself or not.

    Isn’t infibulation (full circumcision) also a factor in fistulas? I read somewhere that it is.

  5. You’re welcome Jill 🙂 It really opened my eyes a lot at the time, I was fairly naive and came out of of the whole experience more knowledgeable but somewhat disillusioned.

  6. Except for we are already supplying them with aid, just ridiculously ineffective aid. We are talking about women in third world countries who desperately need help, try to keep that in mind. You can’t say “Oh, here we are to help” and then give them ridiculously ineffective help. I firmly believe that those countries with great wealth have an obligation to help those without. Feel free to disagree, but when women are getting sick and babies are dying, they need help. (And this is coming from someone who actually likes the idea of abstinence until marriage. I’m just realistic to know it’s not gong to happen most of the time)

  7. Meh, I don’t know about blaming the right for this one. But I’m just cranky and disillusioned with all freakin’ aid organizations after reading We Wish To Inform You That Tomorrow We Will Be Killed With Our Families. (Anyone who hasn’t read it, should.) Those organizations displayed appalling incompetence under Clinton in Rwanda. Why shouldn’t they continue to be incompetent under Bush?

    Man, reading depressing books on the Metro in the morning is probably not the best way to start the day. Must remember this.

  8. They belong to themselves”

    and if this were really true, do you think they’d be choosing to marry and have babies at twelve?

    it must be so comfortable to never have to try to sympathize with anyone who isn’t exactly like you.

  9. Why shouldn’t they continue to be incompetent under Bush?

    In the ideal world, they would have ruthlessly critiqued themselves to discover what went wrong and formulated plans to change their policies to make themselves more effective when future crises arise. Then Bush would have implimented these plans, after verifying their credibility via evaluation from outside sources. Kofi Amin would do the same for the UN based agencies. Yeah, you’re right. It didn’t happen. But that’s what should happen when aid agencies fail miserably in their job of protecting and helping those in need.

  10. Dianne, I suppose you’re right. The problem is, at least from this journalist’s view of it, was that they *didn’t even see how harmful what they were doing was*. Regardless of which party is in power, you have to figure the type of people who sign up to work in dangerous places for an aid org have got to be somewhat idealistic and invested in the idea of helping the less fortunate. So for the actual aid workers to be so willfully oblivious was shocking and almost painful to me.

    I mean, the Western countries kept throwing money at a problem, but that money was actually making things worse because no one wanted to exercise any damn judgement about the situation–they were “impartial.” It definitely makes me wonder now when I read stories about the U.S. giving aid of any sort–is this making things better?

    To clarify–not that I think we should, say, let these women suffer from fistula and say, “Oh, that’s not my problem.” But the whole paradigm of “impartial” aid organizations that “don’t get involved” seems lacking to me. If all we’re doing is sending doctors in there to sew up 12-year-old girls, so that they can get sent back to their husbands for another round of babymaking, that gives me pause. I’m not sure what the answer is.

  11. One more thought, then I’ll stop. Seeing how fistula is caused/correlated with teenagers giving birth–

    Mostly teenagers who tried to deliver their first child at home, the girls failed at labor. Their babies were lodged in their narrow birth canals, and the resulting pressure cut off blood to vital tissues and ripped holes in their bowels or urethras, or both.

    –to send in doctors to sew them up without tackling the larger problem of little girls being married off and not having the ability to delay childbearing is, in my mind, similar to if we sent doctors in to “treat” young girls who had undergone FGM and make sure they don’t die of infection. Do I think it would be right to deny sick girls and women medical treatment? Hell no. But at some point, just mopping up a mess over and over without trying to stop what caused it in the first place becomes tacitly condoning the cause, ya know?

    Alright, end rant. Sorry.

  12. To add to the mix of things people can find about fistula, I wanted to let you know about a grassroots effort to raise awareness and funding for the prevention and treatment of obstetric fistula.

    I am the co-founder of a volunteer initiative, One By One, that is raising awareness and funds for the UN Population Fund’s Campaign to End Fistula. $300 is all it costs to bring a woman suffering from this tragic and debilitating condition back to life.

    And we raise money for prevention too because we agree that putting a band-aid on the problem is required for the short term but should not be mistaken for a long-term solution.

    NY Representative Carolyn Maloney wrote a wonderful letter to the NY Times editor about the work she is doing to get congress to put money back into the campaign to end fistula.

    For our part, One By One uses a giving circle model, where one leader gives $30 and then asks nine friends, family members, neighbors or co-workers to do the same. Together the circle raises $300 – enough money to cover the care for one woman with fistula. It is our hope that we can generate long-term caring donors who will return to learn and work with us on issues of reproductive health, child marriage, poverty and education.

    For now, we grow and do what we can. Since our launch in April we have raised well over $20,000, enough money to care for 65 women with fistula and in the last couple of days we have been inundated which is great news!

    You can learn more about fistula and One By One at http://www.onebyoneproject.net.

Comments are currently closed.