In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

SOTU 2015 Thread

Requested in the Open Thread: a thread just for discussing this years State Of The Union speech.

Whitney Plantation: Memorial to those who were Enslaved

Content note: slavery, racism

When I saw a news story about the Whitney Plantation, I was reminded of the conversation we had here about Ani DiFranco’s obnoxious and ill-conceived idea to have a retreat at a plantation, about how, if at all, a plantation could be used as a proper memorial to the black slaves on whose suffering such places depended upon. It seems that John Cummings has spent years in an effort to do just that. The website has not only pictures but links to various news articles about the restoration and Cummings’s decision to make this museum as a memorial/tribute to those who were enslaved.

From what I can tell, the museum’s admission and tours are free–no fees are listed on the website, and apparently Cummings’s is wealthy enough that he wouldn’t need to charge admission anyway. The articles are a little over-focused on the heroism of the white man in charge and not as much on the black scholars whose work inspired him and with whom he worked for my taste, but I’m guessing that’s not the museum’s fault.

What do you all think? Did Cummings do well? I was quite moved by many of the photographs, particularly those of the infants’ memorial and the wall dedicated to memorializing the slaves by name and I think that incorporating recordings of slaves’ own narratives of their lives was a vital step, to allow people so often silenced to speak for themselves. Apparently Cummings is also working with scholars to produce a database that would aid African-Americans in genealogy research. But I’ve been wrong before. I’m interested to hear the opinions of others here.

Quick News Hit to File Under: You have got to be fucking kidding me

Content note: the Holocaust; anti-immigrant sentiment

So, apparently some German authorities have had a brilliant idea!  What to do with all these asylum seekers?  Where can we house them?  What to do, what to do…

Oh, hey, look, we have these empty barracks over here?  They haven’t been used since 1945!  (Do you have a sinking feeling yet?)  Why don’t we just put these people in a former satellite camp for Buchenwald, which used to house–by which I mean imprison–around 700 people the Nazis used for slave labor?  What could possibly go horribly wrong?

I personally cannot leave aside the utter disrespect for genocidal suffering that was not even a full lifetime ago.  And in light of Germany’s increasing racist anti-immigration sentiment, this is a horrible idea.

I have little more to say except this: some history can’t be rehabilitated.  Some structures cannot be repurposed.  Slave quarters.  Concentration camps.  Some things either have to serve as memorials or be obliterated and replaced.  But storing people–actual human beings with hearts and souls and imaginations–in a place of immense suffering while other people decide if they have rights is unacceptable.  How could they possible feel with those echoes all around them?