In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Uh, hmm.

Cover of Iman's book, "The Beauty of Color." Includes the image of three models of color, including Iman.

The New York Times offers an “of color” gift guide, for making the holidays special for that non-white person in your life. Now, I’m all for supporting the art and work of traditionally marginalized groups. And I’m all for including gift suggestions that aren’t centered on the experiences of white people. And if I were Latina, I would totally wear that last t-shirt!

But some of the descriptions are… hmm. For example:

We live in a multitextural world, especially when it comes to hair. Anthony Dickey is to women with “problem hair” what Batman is to Gotham City. With his out-of-the box approach, innovative products (including his new travel kits for kinky, wavy and curly hair), Mr. Dickey has been a hair hero to Michelle Obama, Kelis, Alicia Keys and others.

So, I’m white, but I also have wavy hair that tends to be dry and sort of difficult to manage, and I am quite partial to Mixed Chicks deep conditioner. So yay for a diversity of hair products for people whose hair is not straight! But… “problem hair”? Really? We’re still defining certain hair as problematic?

Also, the intro to the piece generally:

Somali fashion, do-it-yourself henna kits, children’s books that draw inspiration from the lives of Barack Obama and Sonia Sotomayor: it’s not hard to find gifts created for and by people of color this holiday season. Here are some possibilities.

Again, totally good with promoting the work of people of color, and for not centering whiteness in everything. But… why not just put this all in the general holiday shopping guide? Sure, “The Mocha Manual to Military Life: A Savvy Guide for Wives, Girlfriends and Female Service Members” isn’t going to appeal to every reader, but neither is the Bjorn Borg Men’s Underwear and Sock Set (which was in the “Chic and Cheerful” guide). Frédéric Fekkai Advanced Brilliant Glossing Products go in the “Cosmetic Enhancements” guide while “Hair Rules,” as I quoted above, is in the Of Color guide. All the other guides are divided up by interest — cosmetics, travel, food, etc. Except the Of Color guide.

Maybe I’m being silly, but would it have killed the Times to integrate the really beautiful designs by Mataano into their Chic and Stylish gift guide? Or put the Obama or Sotomayor children’s books on their Notable lists?

Of course, there is something to be said for highlighting the work of traditionally marginalized groups and for recognizing that they are traditionally excluded; I’m not trying to suggest that we all play the colorblind game. But I do think this could have been better executed.

Lady Gaga, I love you.

I mean, how could you not?

I especially love the nods to MJ and Madonna. Lady Gaga is just so weird — and, yeah, she’s half naked, but I like a lady who makes a video that is visually striking, incredibly creative and totally bizarre over just plain hot n sexy. There’s lots of booty, but at least it’s highly-stylized booty. If I were a pop star, this is what I would want to do — just whateverthefuck I want. “I would like people in white latex to crawl out of futuristic coffins and imitate Thriller.” “I would like to dilate my pupils and wear shoes that make no sense.” “I would like a really pointy hat.” “I somehow want to bring in one of those creepy hairless cats.” “I would like to dress up like a giant sparkly broccoli lobster.” “I would like to wear a bearskin rug as a dress and then set things on fire.” “I would like my whole butt on screen now please.”

It’s truly amazing. And I love that she features her Great Dane in every video she does.

Audacity indeed.

gabbysidibe091005_1_250

I very much want to see Precious. I have heard nothing but good things. Push is an incredible book and it sounds like the film does it justice. And I absolutely love Gabby Sidibe, who plays the lead role.

What I don’t love is the media narrative about the film and about Sidibe. Luckily, she seems like she can handle it, and has been critical of attempts to cast her as the ugly duckling turned swan: “They try to paint the picture that I was this downtrodden, ugly girl who was unpopular in school and in life, and then I got this role and now I’m awesome,” says the actress. “But the truth is that I’ve been awesome, and then I got this role.”

Gabby Sidibe is also fat, and that’s something that the media, and even the director of Precious, can’t seem to get over. From the NYMag article:

[Precious director Lee] Daniels, who saw hundreds of audition tapes from across the country (350-pound actresses don’t grow on trees), was blown away by Sidibe. “She is unequivocally comfortable in her body, in a very bizarre way. Either she’s in a state of denial or she’s so elevated that she’s on another level,” he says. “I had no doubt in my mind that she had four or five boyfriends, easily.”

Ah, yes, her weight. When Sidibe was 11 years old, an aunt offered to pay for a cruise if she lost 50 pounds. Friends and family continue to pressure her about it. “I still hear it from people who don’t know that they’re pretty close to hurting my feelings,” she says, “people who care about me, like this one friend. I was eating a light potato chip, and she eyeballed me like I was the most disgusting thing she’d ever seen. She says, ‘Every time you want to put something disgusting in your mouth, think of the designers who won’t make a dress for you because you’re fat.’ ”

But at some point, says Sidibe, “I learned to love myself, because I sleep with myself every night and I wake up with myself every morning, and if I don’t like myself, there’s no reason to even live the life. I love the way I look. I’m fine with it. And if my body changes, I’ll be fine with that.

God bless this girl.

But perhaps the biggest offender I’ve seen so far is the New York Times Magazine. The Magazine article isn’t just incredulous at Gabby’s fatness, but also totally weirded out by the fact that this movie was made mostly by black people. Some of them are even fat black people, like Mo’nique, whose every bite seemed to be chronicled in the story. And some of them are even gay black people, like Lee Daniels, whose gayness is proven via a comment about Vivienne Westwood (but about gangsters, so, still black).

It’s sad, but I’m dreading the release of the film, just because I don’t want to read the reviews.

Body Impolitic Greets Feministe!

Laurie Toby Edison and Debbie Notkin say:

We are delighted to be invited to guest blog here at Feministe.

We can usually be found (along with a couple of regular guest bloggers) at Body Impolitic, where we blog about body image (interpreted as widely as possible), photography, art, and occasional other topics.

We got into working together more than 20 years ago, when we started work on Women En Large: Images of Fat Nudes, which was published in 1994.

Cover of <I>Women En Large</i>

Ten years later, we published Familiar Men: A Book of Nudes.

Cover of <I>Familiar Men</i>

Our most recent project, not yet in book form, is Women of Japan, a series of clothed portraits of women who live in Japan, which was done in collaboration with Japanese feminists.

Lifelong Friendship

Laurie is the photographer, and Debbie writes, edits, and manages the text portions of the projects.

Twenty-plus years of body image work is long enough to give us a lot of perspective on what changes, and what remains the same. Both of us were active feminists before we started doing specific work around body image; so we knew we were in for lifelong (generations long) battles. It’s been fascinating to watch what has gotten better. For example:

  • a much larger community of people are talking about and working on body image issues,
  • good information and health statistics are more available to everyone, 
  • attractive clothing is sold for women of different sizes, and
  • social awareness and acceptance of transgender issues has grown remarkably.
  • We’ve also watched what has gotten worse, including:

  • the media definition of “beauty” is a lot narrower now than it was in 1989,
  • the sexualization of young girls is rampant,
  • medical procedures like Botox and labiaplasty have become normalized, and
  • men’s looks have become almost as commercialized and commoditized as women’s.
  • As we do in the photographic work, at Body Impolitic, we try to look at the immense number of factors that affect how individuals feel about our bodies, about living in our bodies, and about the vast pressures on all of us to hate ourselves and our bodies. While “body image” is a term that people frequently associate with weight (and we do blog about size acceptance and health-at-every-size issues), we also cover racial issues, cultural expectations of masculinity, parenting practices, ability/disability, and much, much more.

    We believe that knowing and appreciating the power and beauty of everyone’s bodies, exactly as they are, is a cornerstone not only of feminism, but of living well in the world.

    And we’re looking forward to being a more active part of the conversation here.

    EWW! Is That Period Blood?!

    One thing that never ceases to amaze me is people’s aversion to menstrual blood. Perhaps I’m just super comfortable with my body or took one too many reproductive health classes or maybe I’m just gross, but I really don’t get why people are so thoroughly disgusted by menstrual blood.

    I’ve been thinking a lot about this recently because I got a Diva Cup a couple of months back. I brought it up one day when I was talking about traveling because I was excited that I wouldn’t need to carry loads of pads and tampons anymore — just my little Diva Cup and a Lunapads pantyliner. Everyone [all female] turned around and looked at me as if I had just said I drink urine with my breakfast or something. I’ve shared my excitement with other people, and they also seem put off by this.

    Then yesterday, I somehow ended up on a link about menstrual art, which I shared with a friend of mine [also female] and her reaction was “EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW.” I didn’t think to myself to save the link (because I’m a moron sometimes), but here are some menstrual art links for you to enjoy! So anyway, she freaked out, but I thought it was cool. I think some of it is really rather beautiful.

    painting made with menstrual blood

    I know we’re taught to hate menstrual blood. We’re made to believe that it is unclean, smelly, gross, and every other negative thing you can think of. This fact is nothing new to most of us who read and write about feminism on a regular basis. Yet it still strikes me as odd whenever I see another example of this, especially from women I know. Somehow I expect more from them I guess…

    I just can’t see what is wrong with inserting a cup into your vagina, collecting your menstrual blood, dumping it, and then doing the process over and over again. Many of us have no problem inserting other types of foreign objects into our vaginas, so what makes this different exactly? The fact that your skin might come into contact with your blood?? *GASP* OH, THE HORROR! And if people want to keep that blood and then turn it into art… I just don’t see what the problem is.

    Does this cross some sort of blood tolerance line that I wasn’t aware existed? Am I really just so incredibly feminist that these things don’t faze me anymore? And can somebody please let me know what they might say in my position so I can start having my responses ready?

    (Cross-posted at Jump off the Bridge.)

    today I am thinking about: CLOWN SCHOOL I

    The past few weeks I haven’t been around as much as I’d like because I have been busy going to clown school. No, really. What do you learn at clown school, you ask? Character work and circus skills and improv games and how to make bits work and classic clown gags and yes, Virginia, we learned how to get pied in the face. Clown school is single-handedly restoring my love of performance and my committment to this kind of theater work. Just for the hell of it, here is a link about anti-racist clowns that you should read.

    Here are some thoughts. More to come but this is getting a little tl;dr.

    First, clown school is something of a culture shock. I pretty much live in a progressive queer utopia. No really. I live in a gaywad house, I work a queer job, I practice homosexuality with my homosexual heterogenderous sweetheart, I train unicorns on the weekends. I pretty much piss glitter and shit rainbows of justice and sodomy and intersectional politics and privilege analysis.

    Clown school is not like that. This kind of clowning is mostly made up of heterosexual white guys, with just enough women involved that people can now say things like “the year of the woman clown” and totally mean it. Women clowns are still new in clownland, and by clownland I mean circus clowns and mainstream clowns — white face paint, goofy outfits, you know what I mean. It’s pretty dudelike in mainstream big-ticket clowning, even as people who are clowns are super aware of this and working on it.

    And while there are clowns of color, they are few and far between as far as I can tell. This program, there is one Latina and one Japanese woman and everybody else is variations on ethnic white — Jewish, Russian, Italian, and a few assorted-white-places people thrown in.

    One of the main clown school instructors (white guy) used to run things for the Ringling Brothers Clown College — the Harvard or Yale of clown training, back when it was open — and he says how distressed he was when he realized how few people of color were auditioning. He says he went to talk to people out in communities of color, and the theory that he formed was that folks who were still fighting for their human dignity in the everyday were going to be much less likely to want to make asses of themselves 10 shows a week in front of huge crowds of people — and that he thinks this is also why women do not want to be clowns, because they are not yet in a place where they feel they can be laughed at without it meaning something politically.

    This is curious to me. First of all, it has a lot to do with what the gig was — Ringling Brothers, a big public deal. I am no clown ethnographer but I know that every culture has its clowns and I know that there are clown traditions in communities here in the US that are alive and well with no need for white people and our clown colleges. But that’s part of it, right — to be able to be laughed at by EVERYONE, you have to know you’re secure and safe, and if you’re not sure the crowd will respect your dignity, you are going to be a lot more wary about getting up in front of everyone.

    Here’s the thing about clowning: it is all about staying open to the moment and thinking on your feet. We are playing improv games and working in slapstick — big picture issues. Today I actually did a gag about peeing on the floor. When you are thinking fast, your brain goes to stereotypes. When you are thinking fast, your brain goes to racist, misogynist, classist places. We were playing with voices today and the instruction was “do the voice of a stupid person” and of course everyone instantly developed speech impediments, lisps, et cetera. If you are coming out and need to communicate something fast and without a lot of talking, it is easiest to communicate something stereotypical — not only for you, but for your audience. This means that if you are a woman, on stage, it’s going to be easy to make it about “woman things” and if you are onstage with a man, it’s probably about to be a love story. And if you are onstage, you have to figure out how to deal with it without killing the scene. It takes a lot of thought to redirect sexism and classism and racism etc at all, let alone to call someone out publicly, let alone to call someone out publicly in the context of a show or scene, let ALONE to do so while not shutting down the whole rhythm but to keep it in the moment. This is something I am still working on.

    I am a queer, queer clown. And yet, clown school is probably the first place in a long time where I do not feel my gender is at all remarkable — because I am one of the girls, women, girls, women, ladies, women. Even with short hair, even with a moustache, even with my feygele sugardish, I am just one of the ladies. And the thing is, rather than feeling erased, I kind of love it. I love it because there is something queer about clowning, just a little; there is a certain committment to live and let live as long as you’re funny about it. My clown is a moustache clown; my clown is not a girl clown, or even necessarily that womanly a clown. I feel good about the room that I have, even though I am constantly worried about being called out about it or told I am not being authentic or some business like that. I worry this will stop working — I will do something too transgressive, and I will get kicked out of the club. This is the privilege of passing, or some kind of passing. Passing as normal enough. Passing as part of the group. I’ve been shaving my chin because I am afraid of the stubble somehow pushing it over the edge to not normal enough. I will admit that, because it’s honest, and because I feel lucky I can get away with this.

    Today I was working on slapstick with another woman student and we were really getting into it, fake brawling, fake pulling each other’s hair and throwing fake punches and fake kicking each other and slapping each other, and it was so fun. We were really being fake violent, talking shit, having a clown fight. It was delicious, until someone said “catfight!” PLEASE, triflers. There was nothing catty about this fight. We were out for clown blood.

    Finally, I want to talk about the Westchester Ladies. These were ladies from the Bronx, now in Westchester, who decided to take class. Italian loudmouth ladies, retired teachers mostly. THESE LADIES WERE AMAZING. They were the funniest I have ever seen, the kind of funny you only get from age and experience and long and tired experience. I hope I am brave enough to go to my equivalent of clown school when I am retired and I hope I am as sincerely joyful as they all were.

    Discussion questions if you need inspiration:

    1) What clowning traditions are you a part of? Do you like? Do you dislike?

    2) Have you performed much? Improv performed much? What have you done about oppressive behavior on stage?

    3) Who is your favorite funny person?

    4) Are there spaces that have surprised you with how good they felt when you were expecting something oppressive? Where?

    5) How comfortable are you making an ass out of yourself publicly? Tell me about that comfort level and how it intersects with your privilege locations.

    Today I am thinking about: Collective Geography I

    I have become obsessed with mapping.

    More precisely: I have become obsessed with Google Maps. I love how they let you carve out geography. I really love how you can put them on top of Google Earth and fly around and view all the different sites. I love how you can tell a story in — or laid on — the place it took place. I have made maps of the places I have and had not had sex, and maps of my childhood neighborhood.

    And now I want us all to make a map together. I really want us all to make a couple of maps together, but we will begin at the beginning.

    Your assignment, should you choose to accept it: tell us the story of a place you feel strong on the Google map linked below:

    View Feministe: Strong Geography. in a larger map

    This is how you do it:

    1) You need to be logged into a Google account — any Google account — to edit the map. If you are worried about anonymity and do not have a throwaway Google account, please email me: interestingDELETETHISPARTtwice at gmail dot com(munism) and I have a solution worked out. Note it might take me a little minute to reply during the day because I am at clown school and largely offline.

    2) Click on the map pictured above. Note that it does encompass the whole world. I can’t figure out how to get it to zoom out to the whole world without breaking the embed code; PLEASE do not let Google Maps’ US-centrism make our map similarly US-centric.

    3) Click that little “Edit” button.

    4) Some tools will pop up in the map window. Select the blue marker, and drag it to where you want to leave a point. Tell the story in the window! Tell us about it! What happened?

    5) If you want to give it a funny or custom marker, click on the picture of the marker in the box where you add text, and it will give you the option to choose amongst Google’s options or even to upload your own.

    Awesome! I will be checking on that map, so don’t pull any funny business. If this goes well, I have a second project for next week, so let me know what you think about this sort of thing in the comments.