In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

The Expat Perpetual

“People are strange, when you’re a stranger.” – The Doors

The first time I became an expat, I was ten. My parents and I moved from Ukraine to the U.S. We bought a home in a quiet neighbourhood, and deer came to graze in our backyard. I nearly had a nervous breakdown when I discovered that the windows of our new house were OMIGOD NOT BULLETPROOF. Sounds hilarious now, doesn’t it? I got over the non-bulletproof thing eventually, and went on to have a pretty good life as an American, with no small thanks to Mama & Papa.

Moving to the Middle East for work, and occasionally going back to Ukraine (where my family is presently located), means that I’ve almost made peace with the fact that I will be, to some extent, a stranger everywhere. After all, being a stranger is can be made easier by being a white person with an American passport. I learned that even before I moved to Jordan.

While on a visit, I went to register at the local police station, and witnessed an officer shout abuse at a family of Iraqi refugees, then turn to me with a smile and ask me if I want a cup of tea in the same breath (!!!).

I ask readers to refrain from forming stereotypes of Jordanians based on that encounter, but I do wish to bring it up to highlight the fact that different people have different experiences, and mine is not the gospel.

Now if only people would stop assuming I’m soulless and sexually available to all and sundry…

You might think that the “soulless slut” thing only comes up in the ME, but in my native Ukraine and in Russia (I’m half Russian and my first language is Russian, if you’re wondering how it fits), some people think that women like me are nothing short of monsters.

There is a proprietary view of women’s bodies at work – “our” women should only be with “our” men, is the idea. I’ve been very sad about not being able to live in Kyiv at this point, because I’m scared that my boyfriend will get knifed for not looking white enough. I don’t wish to paint my native land as a country of racist barbarians, but being screamed at on a bus stop, reading news of racist attacks, and getting hate-mail has frightened me. I’m confident that things are getting better, but my exciting and colourful past is making me even more wary than the average person.

The last time my boyfriend and I were in Kiev (I use the Ukrainian and Russian spellings interchangeably) together, I dyed my hair dark so that we would attract less attention as a couple. It appeared to work. This made me think long and hard about being a stranger in the beloved and beautiful land of my birth. This is a special kind of pain. It’s like getting poked with a cold spoon under your ribcage.

Jordan comes with its own expat issues, especially for a woman. I can’t walk down the street in jogging pants and ratty t-shirt, without some guy expressing his delight. Generally people are non-threatening, and I therefore don’t mind, but I have been scared on a few occasions, scared enough to feel like I need a drink afterwards.

Being Slavic often does me no favours. People have told me they mistake my e-mails for sex-related spam. Some think it’s cool to be rude if they overhear me talking in Russian on my mobile. Hell, some think it’s cool to be rude if they decide I look Slavic enough. People can be… strange. But I’m not dyeing my hair dark again, dammit.

There is a problem of trafficking in this region, and the added problem of some people blaming the victims of trafficking for their own misfortune. There’s also the fact that some women come here to engage in sex work of their own volition, for a chance at a better life – and often do not have much in the way of rights. I highlight these problems specifically because many of the people involved are from the former USSR.

Compared to some of my fellow ex-Soviets, my life in Jordan is charmed. I’ve had the chance to challenge people’s notions about what it means to be a Slavic woman, for example. While I don’t represent anyone but me, myself, and I, I’ve had people tell me that by seeing me as a human being, they were forced to reconsider old stereotypes.

Above all else, I have the opportunity to work with and talk with people who have changed me for the better. And that is no small gift. No small gift it is also to walk the streets of my neighbourhood at dusk, ducking to avoid the jasmine branches brushing my face, and composing bad poetry to the beat of someone’s stereo playing “Enta Fen.”

My mother once told me that I was born in the day of the Archangel Raphael, the guardian of travelers, and the experiences of the past year make me wonder if there is truth to that. Of course, my mom also thinks I’m rootless and unfettered and (here’s that word again) strange. Maybe she’s right. Some of us don’t belong anywhere. I’d like to write about how globalization has contributed to the rise in our numbers, but my mind is too weary.

The bottom line is, we weird people out, we piss them off, but we are who we are and maybe there’s some purpose to that as well. Even the wisest cannot see all ends.

If you’re reading this and thinking of visiting Jordan for the first time, this is a good site to start with. If you’d like to visit Ukraine for the first time, I recommend starting with the Lonely Planet guide as well as this site. Ukraine, together with Poland, will host the Euro 2012, and I, for one, cannot wait. πŸ˜€


16 thoughts on The Expat Perpetual

  1. I really enjoy your posts and your blog. As an American of Ukrainian descent and wife of a Ukrainian man that left the his country when it was still the USSR, I really enjoy reading your experiences in the U.S. and around the globe. I could not imaging living in the ME or many other countries. I wonder how globalization, beyond business, will transform individual national idenity to one of planetary solidarity.

  2. Hi Natalia,
    Just wanted to send a shout-out to a fellow expat-everywhere, “rootless cosmopolitan” like myself. (Tony Judt, a historian at NYU, once called Edward Said a “rootless cosmopolitan” – I have since adopted the term as a descriptor for me since it fits so well πŸ™‚ ) It is very odd (sometimes) to not “belong” anywhere, but I find that I’m actually at peace with who I am and all the places I don’t belong. Its only in the company of people who belong and expect me to that I start feeling strange. You’re absolutely right, it freaks most people out. Sigh. This is lot, I suppose πŸ˜‰
    Keep up the good work!
    NormaJ

  3. This was a lovely post, Natalia, though the mention of the insulted Iraqi refugees makes my heart ache. I work with Iraqi refugees in the US.

  4. I really enjoyed this as a Slavic woman myself. I am Serbian Orthodox and live in an area with a high population of Serbs. The steel mills in our area offered many job opportunities after WWII and the families in the area have grown as more people have immigrated over. As such, there are few people in my area who don’t know someone who’s Serbian, which means there are few people that don’t have preconceived notions. Aside from the typical “dirty serb” comments, I often would have males from my high school learn harassing statements in Serbian and say them to me as I walked into classrooms. There also is the common “don’t bath, girls are slutty etc.” which I would hear about often. It always frustrated me because I am very proud of my heritage and my traditions and I hated feeling like people judged so quickly once they knew I was serbian.

  5. Have you read/seen Persepolis? The author addresses just this issue, being Iranian but spending the formative years of adolescence in Europe, and finding she doesn’t fit in anywhere because of it.

  6. Lovely post.
    I am also what was refered to as a ‘third culture kid’.
    I grew up never spending long enough in any one place (or continent!) to get a grasp of the culture and feel at home.
    I know live in small town America, and struggle daily trying to find a way to reconcile my past and what I consider my culture.
    I do love the small town feel though, when grocery checkers know your name and you can walk to work… I feel like it creates an atmosphere of belonging that I otherwise would not have.

  7. Natalia,

    Thanks so much for your post. I was also first expatriated as a child and ever since, “home” has been a concept with no referent for me. And, while I also certainly don’t want to perpetuate stereotypes about Jordan or Jordanians (who are consistently lovely), it would certainly also be lovely to run out for water in a t-shirt without so many expressions of excitement! Not to say that street harassment hasn’t been a problem everywhere I’ve lived — it has — but I am still in the process of trying to understand how race makes my situation here different than in Europe or America.

    In the meantime, I’ll just enjoy the jasmine branches and the mango juice. πŸ™‚

  8. Thanks for reading, guys. This one was difficult for me to write.

    Haven’t read or seen Persepolis, but I ought to.

    I always joke that the Russian Orthodoxy is “a cross I must bear.” But I know there is a reason why it’s part of my life.

    Jasmine branches are good, unless they end up walloping you in the face when you’re walking behind someone.

    Oh, and – Natalias of the world, unite! πŸ˜‰

  9. Some of us don’t belong anywhere.

    I like to think that that can be also seen as “some of us can belong anywhere”. Once you have lived in like 4-5 different countries like I have, I feel that each one is part of you, and that would be great because you actually “belong” to all the countries you lived in.

    But I can see how some people might not feel they truly belong anywhere, always travelling from one country to another.

    I like to think of it as Home is wherever I am, rather than a fixed location. Globalization should mean there are no longer any boundaries.

  10. Thanks for that, it was very interesting, though ditto on the part about Iraqi refugees being depressing. I find it -literally- unbelievable that anyone could have a problems with refugees! My young British friend was parroting her daddy about too many refugees (haha, she’s an immigrant anyway!) and I had a real go at her about how would she feel if NZ was fucked and she had NO WHERE to go and no one would take her? She didn’t know what to say. The same girl uses the fact a friend was killed in 9/11 to silence other people when it comes to discussing Iraq/Iran et al but I’ll tell you what she changes her tune mighty quick when talking to me. *sigh* If only it would stick.

    I’ve lived my whole life in NZ, but have never stayed in a house for more than 2-4 years throughout my childhood, went on roadtrips a few times every year, visited friends and family overseas (my father’s half Austrian, half English) etc. I’ve also been to Thailand with my muay thai club and Canada to visit a friend. It is a little different in NZ where everyone does and “OE” (overseas experience) than the US where apparently a lot of people don’t travel at all? But my upbringing definitely instilled in me a sense of restlessness, and two years since my last trip I am missing that feeling of being somewhere else, somewhere that feels different, breathing in the taste of different cities and languages and cultures.

    This is all from the very privileged position of being a well-off (well I’m not rich but live very well) white girl, who’s fairly attractive but not attractive enough to get too much shit, and with my Maori nose, dark hair, and extremely light but yellow-tinted skin don’t stick out as much as glaringly white many countries where that matters.

    It’s sad to hear about all the different prejudices you have seen and experienced, but I think it’s valuable to share and very brave of you. Looking forward to reading more from you πŸ™‚

  11. it’s the 4th of july, and i’m sitting with my puppy in my large empty apartment in cairo. i recently decided not to return to the states (as planned) and instead stick around egypt for another year (i’ve been here for a year already).

    today, for the first time in about 4 months, i missed “america” terribly. i wanted a feeling of “home.” whatever that means. my mother is pakistani, raised in england her entire life, and has lived in the states for about 32 years. my father is indian & chinese (chinese adopted into a malay-muslim family), raised in singapore, educated in the british system, college-educated in london and has been living in the states for 32 years. i’ve moved from city to city since the age of 4 and i can’t honestly call one place “home.” i’ve been searching for that since i can remember.

    i loved this entry. it made me feel like i wasn’t the only “stranger” out there. even though i’m muslim and i thought moving to a muslim country might be the first step in trying to find a place i “fit in,” it really hasn’t.

    i ramble…but the point is: i’m glad i’m not the only stranger.

  12. “The bottom line is, we weird people out, we piss them off, but we are who we are and maybe there’s some purpose to that as well. Even the wisest cannot see all ends.”

    This hit a spot I didn’t know was still there.

  13. Oh, wow, I love this post. Right now I’m in Hungary, and I’m having a bit of an identity/culture crisis… I’m Hungarian but I was raised in Australia and the US, so where does leave me? I’m not Hungarian by Hungarian standards, but I don’t feel American. Other aspects of my identity make it even more impossible to reconcile everything and find somewhere, something to fit into.

Comments are currently closed.