In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Why I Am Pro-Choice

This is a guest post by Tiffany Diane Moon. Tiffany holds degrees in Music and Linguistics from San Diego State University, where she taught Writing and Critical Thinking to non-native speakers of English. She is the CEO of Tiffany Moon Enterprises, encompassing the Institute of Arts and Letters and Moon Metaphysics in San Diego, as well as her private artistic and academic endeavors.

Trigger warning for sexual assault, child abuse and violence.

I am a survivor of childhood incest, rape and kidnapping. It is for this reason that I understand what too many arrogant lawmakers cannot: A woman’s freedom to decide what happens to her body (and mind), especially after it has been violated, is crucial to her physical, mental and emotional survival.

I grew up in an abusive, violent, drug-using, alcoholic home; I also grew up being sexually abused. My first experiences of digital penetration were during my second year of life, and my first experience of penile penetration occurred when I was seven. By the time I was eight, I had been raped by both my stepfather and a boarder who lived in our home. When I was nine, after my mother had moved me to California to escape the abuse we were both suffering, my stepfather kidnapped me and raped me again. This was the last time.

I was fortunate enough not to have reached puberty until after my abuse had ended; however, had I become pregnant while still a part of this family experience, I would likely either have been subjected to another form of violent abuse to end my pregnancy in order to prevent prosecution for my rapists, or I would have killed myself. I was also fortunate in another way: My experience caused me to despise sex; because of this, I did not act out sexually with others, a common reaction in sexually abused girls, and so, I did not become pregnant trying to act out or resolve my abuse in my adolescence. However, had I done so, the physical, mental and emotional abuse that continued in my extended family would also have resulted in my killing myself before having to explain that I was pregnant. Alternately, because of the damage caused by the early abuse, if I had been forced to carry a baby to term, all other social, emotional, financial and educational damage aside, I might have been in danger of dying while giving birth.

Despite my abuse, I was so much more fortunate than are millions of women who are raped and/or victims of sexual abuse and incest in this country: This includes one in every four girls who are victims of sexual abuse, and at least one victim of rape every two minutes, 44% of whom are under the age of 18. Those who become pregnant are not only forced to bear the many consequences of pregnancy after having been a victim, but are forced to bear a mental and emotional consequence that is inconceivable to those who have not lived the experience, and that, statistically, will be passed on to a child brought into this world by the most damaging violent act possible.

It is this undeniable fact that I understand, that rape and incest survivors understand, that certain arrogant lawmakers cannot, lawmakers who are attempting to rape every woman in this country by attempting to control their bodies by force of law. This is why I am pro-choice, because I understand, and I refuse to be raped again by anyone passing a law that tells me what I must or must not do with my body, mind and soul.

My addendum:

I am not pro-abortion. I believe in education, in abstinence, in responsible sex. I believe in population reduction by responsible, intelligent couples or single women who chose not to become pregnant. However, we live in an imperfect world, one in which violence is common, and in which sexual abuse and sexual violence against girls and women is prolific, and results in pregnancies that are life-sentences of damage to its victims, while allowing perpetrators of such violence a majority of a life of freedom, if they are ever incarcerated at all. Therefore, while I disapprove of abortion as irresponsible birth control, while I am not pro-abortion, I understand that what may appear irresponsible to someone who doesn’t know the woman choosing the procedure, may in fact be a necessity for someone whose abusive past has resulted in a situation that pregnancy would exacerbate. This is impossible for anyone to know or determine; for this reason I am pro-choice.

I am also pro-choice for another, very simple reason: I am not the sole cause of pregnancy, nor is any woman. Oddly, however, in the determination of US law regarding pregnancy, only woman are targeted, both regarding prevention and consequence. The same arrogant lawmakers who currently wish to outlaw abortion also want to outlaw female contraception. This is clearly sexist, but manages to continue. Therefore, I continue to propose to the US Congress, particularly the currently misogynistic House of Representatives a simple solution to its concern about abortion: Simply require that every male residing in or visiting the US have a vasectomy. This is a simple procedure, will reduce medical and insurance costs, and may ensure that abortion would rarely be necessary. Men who wish to procreate and are approved by respective consenting females may be screened by a government agency to determine their suitability (education, profession, criminal records, sexual habits, manner of dress) to have the procedure temporarily reversed, allowing any poor use of ejaculation, such as rape, to be more easily monitored and determined. Problem? If this solution seems somehow troubling or unreasonable, it might be time to wonder why, as it’s currently the manner of law-making being set upon women alone, and until sexism in procreation is removed from the law-making process, this is the reason I am pro-choice.


41 thoughts on Why I Am Pro-Choice

  1. Therefore, while I disapprove of abortion as irresponsible birth control

    I could have done without this. If you really believe that what a woman does with her own body is her choice, then it’s not necessary to bring up the abortion-as-birth-control strawman that is so popular amongst the anti-choice. If you agree that a woman has a choice of what to do with her body then the number of abortions a woman has, or the frequency, or her reasons for doing so are none of your business.

    Adding this bit about your personal disapproval comes across as disingenuous. Basically like you’re saying “I support choice, just don’t be a dirty slut about it.”

  2. A woman’s freedom to decide what happens to her body (and mind), especially after it has been violated, is crucial to her physical, mental and emotional survival.

    I am not pro-abortion. … Therefore, while I disapprove of abortion as irresponsible birth control, while I am not pro-abortion, I understand that what may appear irresponsible to someone who doesn’t know the woman choosing the procedure, may in fact be a necessity for someone whose abusive past has resulted in a situation that pregnancy would exacerbate.

    I don’t understand the logic of being pro-choice only in cases of sexual violence, which is what your addendum seems to suggest.

    You appear to disapprove of abortion outside of sexual abuse, even though you’d allow it in order to protect abuse survivors. But you also recognize the importance of self-determination and the right to bodily integrity for women abuse survivors.

    Surely you can see, first, that *all* women have the same right to self-determination and bodily integrity, and, secondly, that a society that doesn’t recognize these rights is the same kind of society that tolerates sexual abuse.

  3. while I disapprove of abortion as irresponsible birth control

    So you believe in the myth that there are untold thousands of “irresponsible” women (I won’t use the “s” word) who go around having casual sex without birth control and then “get rid of their babies” without giving it any more thought than what TV program to watch? And that if there are such women, they shouldn’t be “allowed” to have abortions?

    What gives you the right to decide what is or isn’t a sufficiently important justification for exercising self-determination and making that choice? Where exactly do you draw the line? And so on.

  4. I am not pro-abortion. I believe in education, in abstinence, in responsible sex. I believe in population reduction by responsible, intelligent couples or single women who chose not to become pregnant. However, we live in an imperfect world, one in which violence is common, and in which sexual abuse and sexual violence against girls and women is prolific, and results in pregnancies that are life-sentences of damage to its victims, while allowing perpetrators of such violence a majority of a life of freedom, if they are ever incarcerated at all. Therefore, while I disapprove of abortion as irresponsible birth control, while I am not pro-abortion, I understand that what may appear irresponsible to someone who doesn’t know the woman choosing the procedure, may in fact be a necessity for someone whose abusive past has resulted in a situation that pregnancy would exacerbate. This is impossible for anyone to know or determine; for this reason I am pro-choice.

    Thanks god the first couple of comments say what I was thinking because I have major issues with this whole addendum. First, I think abortion should be available to women even if all sexual assault ceased to exist. That does not make me “pro-abortion,” it makes me pro-choice. Second, a “belief in abstinence” is also telling people what to do with their bodies. You can “believe in abstinence” for yourself but it’s not up to one person to make that decision for another. Third, what’s with the whole population reduction for single women who choose not to become pregnant? Does that mean that the “belief in abstinence” is only for a certain age and adults are free to have sex? Does it mean that single women shouldn’t choose to become pregnant? Why not? Does it mean the choice to have children should be weighed against the number of the people already in the world? That may be how one person chooses whether to have children but does it really need to apply to everyone? Fourth, why is abortion ever irresponsible birth control? I think it can only be responsible birth control. If a woman is so irresponsible, do you want her to be a mother? Or do you want her to be forced to be pregnant and give birth so that others may adopt her child (assuming we’ve erradicated all sexual assault and she wasn’t raped)? Is that really a better alternative to “irresponsible birth control”? I know, I know, education and access to birth control is the alternative. Even so, let’s assume some women still end up not taking advantage of birth control, is having abortion available to those women going to cause some sort of huge problem? I think someone already mentioned a “straw woman” argument here, so I will desist on that point. Fifth, two reasons abortion should always be available to women are for women’s health and for women whose birth control fails them. Even anti-choicers mostly agree that abortion in case of a woman’s health or life is acceptable.

    In conclusion, I think that whole addendum is meant to be some sort of moderate position when it’s just not.

    After that pile-on, I will praise the last paragraph. I like having the argument turned around like that.

  5. I, also, was agreeing until the addendum when it also seemed to introduce the dichotomy of “responsible, intelligent” childfree-ness and mindless moo-breeders hellbent on bringing the end of the world.

  6. You’ve really had an awful time and I’m sorry.

    Though I went through my own childhood sexual abuse, I did not despise sex by the end. If anything, I went in the exact opposite direction. There may have been pleasure mixed in with the pain. The brain responds to trauma very differently in every person. And, that manifestation may be very different with men, so I acknowledge that up front.

    I was not especially selective about the men that I slept with, this for years. I thought that being with lots of men would help me come to terms with my fear of them. But instead, it didn’t really make any difference one way or another. I recognized that the anger that lurked underneath the surface was really terror.

    The anger you feel guides your arguments, towards the end, in a direction that other posters have called out. I am not unsympathetic to your struggles. I think, however, that further healing, however and whenever that occurs, will lead you away from your damage and the scars you bear.

  7. You might not be “pro-abortion”, but I am. Abortion is good for women, good for children, good for families and good for society. It creates untold amounts of freedom, relief, succour and hope for scores of people, while taking nothing from the world. I am grateful that I live in a country where I have relatively convenient access to safe, hygienic termination procedures, and if I had the means, I would become an abortion provider myself.

    I am so tired of people who say; “I’m not pro-abortion!” as if being pro-abortion is some kind of indisputably horrible black mark on someone. It isn’t. So many women who identify as feminist treat abortion as an unfortunate but practical fact of life, begrudgingly. Not me.

  8. Some of you may be missing the main points. I agree with what your saying; everyone has a right to chose regardless of thier reasons, but I think the big point is the end. The sexism in the whole conversation. When do men get held responsible? I would add that male masterbation should be illegal – that’s millions of potential lives being lost! 🙂 Seriously though, we don’t need to agree with every point she makes to agree with the general sentiment. In fighting doesn’t really help…

  9. I deal with second- and third-generation adult “drug babies” on an almost daily basis, and with the offspring of centuries of inbreeding and incest frequently Tiffany, you rock. I would add only that contraception on demand should be as subsidized as access to roads and sidewalks. Some will be too stupid or stoned to use it, but overall, it will reduce a variety of social ills and cut that darned deficit. I insisted that my husband get a vasectomy before I would marry him, and he complied. Feel free to do likewise.

  10. I deal with second- and third-generation adult “drug babies” on an almost daily basis, and with the offspring of centuries of inbreeding and incest frequently Tiffany, you rock. I would add only that contraception on demand should be as subsidized as access to roads and sidewalks.

    This language is dehumanizing. WTF even *is* a “third-generation adult ‘drug baby'” and how does one “deal” with them?

    Jesus. The OP was not about ridding the world of incest survivors. It was about not further stripping them of control over their bodies.

  11. Don’t be too harsh with the anti-abortion call out. Even from a medical standpoint alone, it is invasive compared to taking a pill, having a patch, etc. As a fellow incest survivor, I can totally understand having a flinch response to being penetrated to “fix” something yet again. Yes, I could totally be projecting.

    No, I’m not anti-abortion, but it makes sense to see it as a Defcon 1 response, rather than Defcon 5: yes, all levels of response should be available for the individual to determine.

  12. Even from a medical standpoint alone, it is invasive compared to taking a pill, having a patch, etc.

    Some abortions are performed by taking a pill, like mifeprestone. They’re not all surgical.

  13. I insisted that my husband get a vasectomy before I would marry him, and he complied. Feel free to do likewise.

    Geez, I don’t even know where to start with this.

  14. First, let me express my sympathies for what a horrible situation you grew up in, and gratitude for the perspective your story has opened me up to.

    Second, I apologize that people are so hyper-aware of other people’s stances on abortion when they differ from their own, that they’re ready to completely erase everything else you had to say about a different subject entirely.

  15. ” irresponsible birth control” is maybe a bit strong. I don’t think it’s a good idea to be having abortions instead of taking birth control but there will ALWAYS be abuse, wathever the legislation, wathever the subject (be it shopping, taxes, etc.)

    My main point is “error is human”. I think hard that no-choice say “I just had to take a little pill, is that to hard for you ?”. Well, maybe you forgot 1 out of 150 ones, or maybe the pill didn’t work or it gave you headaches.
    And if the combination of problem with contraception + sex can cause my life to dramatically change without me having any control on it, i’ll be so much more stressed out about it ! It’s like i’m taking a really important and difficult exam each time, with a chance factor…
    Why does it happen that men don’t have to think about it even a little ???

    Anyway, i don’t mean to be hard on you, you seem to have had a pretty hard life (which is not my case), and i hope you the best for the year !
    Thanks for sharing,

  16. This post completely enrages me, and no, your history of abuse does not absolve you of the judgement you’re passing on people who get abortions as “irresponsible birth control”. I was sexually abused as a small child. I had an ‘irresponsible birth control’ abortion that was unrelated to any abuse much later because I wasn’t ready for a family and wanted to finish my Phd. And you know what? I am 100% happy with my choice because it was the best one I could possibly have made.

    These ridiculous arguments that separate the ‘good abortions’ from the ‘irresponsible birth control’ abortions do the movement and women no good. In fact, I’d say they do more harm than they could possibly be worth. Either you believe a woman should have bodily autonomy or you don’t. Simple as that.

  17. And to the commenters saying that we shouldn’t be harsh with the OP because we should overlook the points she’s making that have traditionally been weaponized against women who have abortions for any reason other than rape/incest or imminent death, I’ll remind you that you’re effectively erasing a large percentage of women who choose to have an abortion. And I, for one, don’t appreciate it.

  18. The way I read her, Tiffany Moon doesn’t claim to speak for everyone who supports abortion rights. She has her reasons for wanting abortion to be safe and legal. Which are not my reasons. I am fortunate and privileged enough not to be living with memories of sexual abuse, and I’m much more aligned with what the comments said.

    As long as Moon wouldn’t require a woman who wants an abortion to prove she’s not one of the “irresponsible” ones who use it for belated contraception, I have no problem with this post.
    Maybe Moon should have dropped some of that rhetoric about female irresponsibility. But I think she meant to say she was pro choice.

  19. Second, I apologize that people are so hyper-aware of other people’s stances on abortion when they differ from their own, that they’re ready to completely erase everything else you had to say about a different subject entirely.

    Seriously. 20 comments about what a jerk you are for one sentence in a post about how society gleefully perpetuates trauma on survivors of horrific childhood sexual abuse? People should be ashamed.

  20. Honestly, though, abortion is birth control. And so what if it is? The ultimate purpose of abortion and birth control that one uses before conception is equivalent, and those who argue that women who have multiple abortions are careless need to be reminded how the law of probability works. It doesn’t mean that because you’ve had your one conception in your hundred PIV, your next 99 are all good.

    I think it is only irresponsible birth control if it becomes illegal and women have to risk their health to have one. And THAT irresponsibility lays not at the hands of the women, but at the assholes would have made it illegal.

  21. Honestly, though, abortion is birth control. And so what if it is? The ultimate purpose of abortion and birth control that one uses before conception is equivalent, and those who argue that women who have multiple abortions are careless need to be reminded how the law of probability works. It doesn’t mean that because you’ve had your one conception in your hundred PIV, your next 99 are all good.

    I think it is only irresponsible birth control if it becomes illegal and women have to risk their health to have one. And THAT irresponsibility lays not at the hands of the women, but at the assholes would have made it illegal.

    Quoting the whole thing just because it’s that brilliant. Plus, why is there this thought that the women having “irresponsible” abortions weren’t using some other form of birth control in the first place? Contraception fails.

  22. Some of the comments above are unbelievably cruel. Tiffany Diane has suffered a great deal, and it took a lot of courage for her to reach the point that she could talk about it and articulate her position on abortion. While I, too, agree that abortion should be freely available, and no woman has a right to be judged for having one, some of you attacked Tiffany Diane for ONE SENTENCE that wasn’t exactly in accord with your own position. If we can’t bother to acknowledge the level of suffering that some women have gone through, and the despair they continue to feel as a result, if we have no reaction other than to pick apart their positions, what are we really working for? I thought we were all in this fight together.

  23. some of you attacked Tiffany Diane for ONE SENTENCE that wasn’t exactly in accord with your own position.

    See, but, it’s not one sentence. It’s the dichotomy she’s set up in the very structure of the piece: the deserving woman as she defines her, vs. the irresponsible woman who uses abortion as a form of birth control (which, as shfree points out, it is). I too was a victim of sexual violence as a child, but my abortion would definitely fall within her definition of ‘irresponsible birth control.’ I mean, its fine that she thinks some abortions are more right or moral than others, but it’s also fine that those of us who are ‘irresponsible’ disagree strongly.

    Also, what kind of violence do you think is done to women who got pregnant young, before they were ready, before they had a support structure set up and decided to terminate, when they’re constantly met with these kinds of judgements? Oh, you didn’t have the right kind of abortion because you were just irresponsible. I mean, how hard is it to just take a pill every day? This is the script too many of us are used to hearing All. Of. The. Time.

  24. Disagreement /= attack.

    I mean, yeah, vicious comments are definitely not unknown on Feministe, but this? Not that.

    Also, my interpretation of a post entitled, “Why I am pro-choice” is that it is about reproductive rights and abortion, with childhood sexual abuse as an important component of the OP’s experience in relation to her position on that issue. Not that it’s about childhood sexual abuse with abortion as a side issue. So why wouldn’t the commenters be discussing that primarily? Especially the part that they disagree with, rather than the part that they are able to sum up with, “Yes, I agree”?

  25. It is true abortions can be done with a pill, which is less invasive than surgically. It is still more invasive of a hormonal treatment biologically, then again, say birth control pills (though present long term hormone treatments are another can of worms) – but much less invasive than an unwanted pregnancy, I agree whole heartedly.

    This is all moot; what I’m saying is that anything that can be done to minimize the angst/pain, heck, even inconvenience of reproductive choices is good in my view. The less hassle, holistically, the better.

    Which is why in a perfect world, I would rather there be a magic, non-side effect, implant that everyone responds to equally well and makes accidental pregnancies go bye bye forever. And is no one’s business but the individual. (Male implants, anytime now?)

    I know, for myself, that being treated as a toy or commodity as a little girl tends to make me hyper aware of mistreatment for other people in positions of power inequity. When I read the OP, my feeling was that she was identifying more with the “non-entity” of the pregnancy than the woman pregnant i.e. adults –> non adults. Boggy trauma ground.

    I know how hard it is coming from that type of beginning for lots of abuse survivors. About half the cousins abused in my family are deep into substance abuse and serious acting out behaviors, but even those who seem to manage better have to fight for balance. Tiffany Moon should be given some kudos for trying to make something good come from it.

    Hot topic, yep, but is friendly fire cool to be on?

  26. Hot topic, yep, but is friendly fire cool to be on?

    Sorry, you don’t just get to shut down discussion on a very problematic structural component of the post just like that.

    The OP is allowed to think whatever she wants about abortion and who is deserving of having one, and that opinion can be, and in fact is, informed by all components of her life. And those of us with different life experiences which inform our definition of who is worthy of an abortion get to have our opinions. And we get to disagree with the opinion of the OP, when she presents it to us in a public forum such as a major feminist blog with open comments.

    And we ought to be able to do it without being told to be nice and behave ourselves because our anger or forcefulness of opinion isn’t attractive and might make someone feel bad, never-mind that the aforementioned openly stated opinion has already had that very effect.

  27. I appreciated the author’s willingness to open up and share her traumatizing experiences — and to attach her name to her story. I’m sure that was not easy. Sharing stories about sexual assault, incest and other social events experienced largely by women — such as abortion — are a powerful way to break the silence and regain control.

    So in counterpoint I’ll offer a personal experience of my own. I’ve worked in abortion care for more than two years and I’ve yet to meet a woman who is using abortion as a replacement for birth control. I’ve also yet to meet someone who was too “stupid or stoned to use” birth control, and the comment of Angie at #10 seems like the most dangerous attitude expressed here.

    Women seeking abortion each have their own unique and valid reasons for doing so, whether they experienced a birth control failure (and all methods can fail, from IUDs to Depo) or were raped or had unprotected sex. The choice and the emotional consequences are theirs alone to deal with. Many of them think they’re bad people for having abortions, and it is that burden of guilt and shame — internalized due to a social environment that treats women who have abortions as “irresponsible” — that I try each day to lift from them. Mostly, they choose abortion out of love for themselves and/or their families. That is all that should matter.

    Also…a quick word on the abortion pill, or pills, actually, since the process generally involves taking more than one pill. Some women find it less invasive. Others prefer to convenience and peace-of-mind of a surgical abortion. Like the decision to have an abortion, it is every individual woman’s choice.

  28. I really hate the idea of limiting abortion to rape/incest survivors. (Incest really ought to be ‘familial rape’ since almost no one engages in it voluntarily, but I digress.) In that case, it’s like another trial- and the victim is always on trial, not the rapist. Every single area that limits abortion to rape and incest proceeds to make the experience as astonishingly horrible as possible. I think it’s in women’s best interest to jump through as few hoops as possible, especially in a time-sensitive matter such as abortion.

    For the record, I’ve never been raped, but Tiffany Moon has my sympathies.

  29. Incest really ought to be ‘familial rape’ since almost no one engages in it voluntarily, but I digress.

    Except that not all incest is the rape of a minor by an older family member… What if it’s two consenting adult family members — I mean obviously it’s wrong but it’s a bit of a stretch to call this rape.

  30. The one thing that we can all agree on is that the US has an embarrassing record of poor protection for children & women. 1 in 4 women can expect to be sexually abused in her lifetime. Those who want to leave this to the “States” to decide what is decent are forgetting that 55% of the population is female and less than 10% of legislatures in any state are female. As long as we are the only ones who can carry a child, we should be the only ones to decide any legal decision that require a uterus for resolution. Let males have their 3-5 minutes of discussion – the average time it takes them to knock someone up. We need leaders who respect women, understand mental health and biological science.

  31. Many of them think they’re bad people for having abortions, and it is that burden of guilt and shame — internalized due to a social environment that treats women who have abortions as “irresponsible” — that I try each day to lift from them.

    Thank you for doing what you’re doing. I hope you hear that every single day.

  32. Thank you to Vigee, you’ve been counteracting what I consider the dangerous “Author has had bad experiences, so its ok if she makes a poor argument- let’s not disagree!” line of thought. I agree with your comment that you’re either all Pro-body autonomy or you’re NOT Pro-body autonomy. And I find the author’s opposition to “irresponsible” abortions extremely offensive, with a special eau de slut-shaming.

    Her experiences are really terrible. But its important to note that people are not disagreeing with her experiences, but her ideas.

  33. Sorry that you had such a sad childhood.

    pro-choice is just that respecting a women’s right to make choices for her own body, what ever they may be.

    Your post seems to be engaging in the rhetoric that many women have been fighting against, that somehow if women just cross their legs, don’t engage in sexual activity, and just say no then there will be no need for abortions, while on the other hand saying, boys will be boys, and if they knock up the girl, it’s her fault for having unprotected sex.

    The simple fact is that women are targeted – 35% of all women have experienced birth control tampering by a male who she has been in a relationship with. There has been a targeted attack on women getting access to not only birth control but medical treatment. There is no easy access to birth control. Poor Sex-ed in this country. More teenaged boys and adult men are not wearing and will not wear condoms because it supposedly affects their performance — Seems like they don’t care about the consequences only their “feelings” matter.

    Abstinence only programs in this country don’t work.

    Requiring men to get a vasectomy is going to far.

    I am a childfree person — But wouldn’t make my partner get a vasectomy to prove to me that he is childfree as well.

  34. Jorge: Outside of porn, I don’t think there are any legitimate records of incest occuring between consenting adults who are aware of their familial relationship. Just doesn’t happen.

  35. Jorge: Outside of porn, I don’t think there are any legitimate records of incest occuring between consenting adults who are aware of their familial relationship. Just doesn’t happen.

    Yep, it does. I read a non-fiction book once (struggling to find the title now, sorry – I just picked it up off the shelf in a university library once while skimming titles in the human sexuality section) that contained a number of first-hand accounts of people who were in consensual sexual and romantic relationships with their biological siblings with whom they had been raised or were at least aware of their relational status. (I think they were all sibling relationships, though one may have been a mother and son? It was a few years ago.)

    Obviously not very common, but not impossible.

  36. Incest between two consenting adults is unlikely to result in abortion and, if it does, they’d still be covered under the “rape and incest” category.

    As for “irresponsible birth control,” it sounds like the most responsible thing in the world for a woman who doesn’t want a child to not.

    I’m sorry for your hardships and torture, truly, but moralizing about abortion is only half a step away from victim blaming.

    Signed,
    A six-time rape victim, raped past puberty

  37. I have been reading the responses and can respect the opinions and appreciate the knowledge expressed — on all sides. What I would like to contribute is that Tiffany is not alone in her pro-choice/ anti-abortion theory. I am pro-choice because I do not feel that is it anyone’s right to legislate my body. I think the black/white thinking of pro and con is what causes derision and arguments between people. The shades of gray in pro-choice can include anti-abortion. Who, among us, who has had an abortion would do it again? I had an abortion because I was homeless, although my issues were not because of second and third generation incest… mentioned earlier. I am grateful for the people at that clinic, that there can be clinics… but I would not have another abortion — nor would I hope that my daughters would. There are a lot of people in this world that don’t harm children and spend years looking for a child. And there are children out there who were the products of rape and incest… and lived. The real issue is that no one should be able to make the decision to abort or not… except the person carrying the baby. And… while I’m at it, thank goodness there are men with the gonads to join into the conversation, and if there was not incest between consenting adults, there would have not been a monarchy in England — although, admittedly, there would not be haemophilia either…but, I digress.

    Tiffany, thank you for sharing your life with us. I could put in my statistics on sexual abuse in my signature line, as well… but that would just be snarky and demeaning. I’ll just say that there isn’t a year that’s gone by that I haven’t wondered about my child who would have been 26 years old this year. That’s my argument with abortion.

  38. Why is everyone so mad that while she thinks that you shoud have the right to do what you want with your body she also thinks that not every reason to do something is as commendable as all others? it was the equivalent as that quote ‘i may not agree with what you have to say but i’ll fight to defend your right to say it’. if someone says ‘its not a good idea to tattoo the name of your boyfreind on your body during the first month of the relationship’ do you automatically blast them as being against all forms of body art and accuse them of trying to help shut down tattoo parlors? No. Being pro choice does not mean you have to think that every unplanned and inconvenient pregnancy should automatically be terminated and other choices such as adoption are horrible for children. Personally I think never being born would be much worse for a child than being adopted. Getting an abortion or not to is a complex issue and no one will agree on all aspects of it. There’s another quote that comes to mind ‘we’re more tolerant of those who believe none of our creed than we are of those who only believe part of it’ and yes I have again forgotten who said it. But I’m pretty sure they’re dead and will not sue me for copyright infringement. If not I would be more than happy to let them have all the shit I’m sure will come my way from this post as my only profit from making the suggestion that maybe abortion is not the best solution for every less than ideal pregnancy.

Comments are currently closed.