In defense of the sanctimonious women's studies set || First feminist blog on the internet

Search for the Next Stupak

Over at the Daily Beast, Dana Goldstein has some insight into the next big brouhaha to come out of the health care bill — Conservative mobilization against free birth control:

[T]he Daily Beast has learned that many conservative activists, who spent most of their energies during the health-care reform fight battling to win abortion restrictions and abstinence-education funding, are just waking up to the possibility that the new health care law could require employers and insurance companies to offer contraceptives, along with other commonly prescribed medications, without charging any co-pay. Now the Heritage Foundation and the National Abstinence Education Association say they plan to join the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in resisting implementation of the new provisions.

On the one hand, I’m amped to hear that the new health care plan could mean free birth control as a “preventative” medication. On the other, I hate being reminded of the power that these fringe anti-birth control groups wield.

Thankfully, there’s some good news. Goldstein reports that unlike America’s split on abortion rights, public opinion roundly supports birth control. So even if the Heritage Foundation and NAEA manage to get the support of someone like a Bart Stupak, it would be unlikely to gain as much traction.


15 thoughts on Search for the Next Stupak

  1. Fortunately, it’s much harder to confuse the issue with allegations of baby! murdering! when it comes to the pill. You can drum up a lot of knee-jerk misogyny in people who haven’t thought about it or immediately apply it to their own situation–the “I would never have an abortion”/”I definitely wouldn’t want my girlfriend aborting my baby” crowd–and universalize from there.

    It’s a lot harder to get people on your side when you’re trying to ban the pill or condoms, because pretty much everyone who’s not out there waving dead-fetus signs at preschoolers is or has been on the pill, hyperventilated because maybe that girl they had sex with while drunk last night wasn’t on the pill, been prescribed the pill for medical reasons, done a risk analysis while considering going condomless in a long-term relationship, etc. Abortion is more or less an emergency remedy to something having gone wrong with Plan A; it’s fairly easy for people to think that nothing will ever go wrong and they’ll never need it, so what do they care if it goes away? Not so much with one of the most popular versions of Plan A.

    Not to mention that you run into the same commonsense barrier that RIAA and the MPAA have been fighting with pirates. Abortion, unless it doesn’t work, results in an embryo or a fetus that is no longer in the pregnant woman. It was there, now it’s not. Pregnancy over. Something actually happened there. The pill and condoms are preventing something from happening, so it’s a lot harder to convince someone who’s not deeply into the philosophy section of the “God wants you to have babies” argument that preventing sperm and egg from meeting killed a child.

    You start howling at someone who used a condom during intercourse to prevent a pregnancy that it should have resulted in a pregnancy, and there isn’t a pregnancy, so you both might as well have murdered an infant together, and they start looking at you like maybe you took the brown acid. They aren’t coming at it from the axiomatic position that every instance of sex ought to result in a pregnancy, which ought to result in a birth (or, failing that, a dead woman or emotionally-scarring miscarriage).

  2. I wish I could be as optimistic as you, Preying Mantis. It’s always easier to get people to rally against something than for something, and furthermore people are dumb as bricks in crowds.
    This is why I’m pretty sure we’re not going to get free brith control in my lifetime.

  3. In order to rally against it, though, you have to get a lot of people thinking it’s wrong, or pretending to think it’s wrong, on camera. When the median reaction is going to be “Would the speaker like to decry seatbelts coming standard with cars or perhaps flossing once a day next?”, that can be hard to swing.

  4. To be a little more precise, I think this is like the political arguments about pot vs. the political arguments about alcohol. The pill is something that roughly 80% of the adult population regards as their right to use or benefit from their partner using without bothering to even pretend to feel guilty about it. I think “I’m going to throw a giant fucking tantrum on the floor of the Senate about the possibility of the pill getting covered by insurance” will go over about as well as arguing seriously for raising the drinking age to 25 or a return to abolition.

  5. Sorry–‘prohibition,’ not ‘abolition.’ (Comment to which this applies currently stuck in the mod queue.)

  6. One quick question: if the new health care plan requires insurance companies to cover the birth control pill without a prescription, does this mean it will be free for everyone old enough to buy it?

  7. Hard for me to be sanguine about it when I at one time needed the Pill to stop bleeding that my doctor had told me would’ve eventually killed me. My insurance would not cover it, not even with doctors’ notes, pardon the expression, out the wazoo, and the not-garden-variety dosage and brand of pill I had to take cost something like $30 a package, which was food for several days that I did not get to eat because I was so poor.

    All I can think of when these fuckbags start in on birth control is of some other poor young woman like me, breaking bricks of Ramen noodles in half, all the while terribly hungry from the anemia and unable to afford fresh red meat for the iron, unable to keep fresh spinach greens or meat for more than a day or so because there was no fridge, unable to afford iron supplements.

    Even once I had the bleeding under control and was on cheaper pills, I could barely afford the birth control I needed to NOT have a baby I also could not afford. It was fucked up and hateful, and these people who just handwave all of that away because they think they know better piss me off so goddamn bad.

    You know how I felt while all that was going on? Worthless. Completely worthless. It makes me want to puke thinking of other women going through that, or of anyone wanting them to.

  8. “I don’t want to overstate or understate our level of concern,” said McQuade, the Catholic bishops’ spokesperson. “We consider [birth control] an elective drug. Married women can practice periodic abstinence. Other women can abstain altogether. Not having sex doesn’t make you sick.”

    WTF. I totally respect a person’s right to not have sex and to be asexual, but the majority of the human race has a sex drive. Am I really expected to only have sex perhaps a dozen times in my life as I try to conceive? Really? And this will have no consequences? Abstinence for life is certainly working out for a certain group of men in robes and collars.

  9. Coming from the UK, where the pill (or any form of contraception) is prescribed free of charge to anyone who wants it, and in some cases is available without prescription, this is something that I’ve never really thought about. If you need the morning after pill here, you just head over to the supermarket and get it, free of charge, under an NHS scheme to make it more freely available. That women in the US – a country in which abortion rights are so fiercely fought over – have to pay for their contraception is just baffling to me.

    I started having sex at fifteen, so I trotted off to the doctor and got the pill. Boom. When I went to the Family Planning Clinic to get more, they gave me a huge bag of condoms as well. Hormonal contraceptives are not suitable for me any longer, so I’m currently considering the coil, and that will be free as well.

    Sure, it’s not a contraceptive utopia over here, but because the pill, and other forms of contraception, are free, this has a massive knock-on effect as to how they are viewed in society. Contraceptives just are; they are a fact of life, prescribed by every doctor and funded by the state. Sure, we have the occassional cleric or pressure group moaning that ‘access to contraception = the wimminz having sex!’, but I cannot emphasise how unthinkable it would be for any group to call for a restriction the free availability of contraception. It has simply been widely available for far too long.

    I sincerely hope that this bill passes, so that in five or ten years’ time, US women will be in the same position as we are in the UK.

  10. I feel the danger lies in the money these organizations obtain. Your average individual who “supports” the “pro-life” movement generally only knows one thing. They are against abortions. They often are no more informed than that and how to describe “partial birth” abortions to people in detail. So they funnel money into these organizations and never look at other things their doing. The message has always been abortion is the worse thing ever, we must stop it, that many people don’t look past that. So these individuals who are probably fully in support of birth control will be sending resources and money to organizations that are lobbying to take that away. The head honchos know they can distract them by just yelling “dead babies” if they start to focus too much on the other stuff.

  11. “I don’t want to overstate or understate our level of concern,” said McQuade, the Catholic bishops’ spokesperson. “We consider [birth control] an elective drug. Married women can practice periodic abstinence. Other women can abstain altogether. Not having sex doesn’t make you sick.”

    I await the religious right’s crusade against ED drugs. After all, you don’t have to have sex–not having sex doesn’t make you sick. Why are they needed and why are they available?

  12. These people are unbelievable. They’ll blandly demand that taxes get funneled directly to wholly unaccountable private schools in the form of “vouchers,” then scream if one single tax dollar gets anywhere in the neighborhood of a contraceptive.

    Hey, assholes, a whole lot of my taxes go for shit I don’t believe in. Deal with it.

  13. Married women can practice periodic abstinence. Other women can abstain altogether.

    NO, random stranger, you do not get to arbitrarily decide that I don’t get to have sex.

  14. Preying Mantis: To most people, birth control does not equal seat belts. Also see my previous comment- people, especially in the U.S. are NOT smart enough to separate birth control from abortion.

Comments are currently closed.